News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by kevenwang0531 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @08:43PM (#12108468)
The counter-argument to our fear of planned obsolescence here is the ridiculous speed of technological improvement in LEDs relative to incandescent lighting. LED's cost per lumen falls by a factor of 10 every decade (see Haitz's Law), while a user's actual lighting needs may never exceed 800 lumens for an standard A19 bulb. Any attempt to form a cartel in this market would be swiftly defeated by ever-falling unit economics. Far from a cartel, we should let the government create a standardized LED lifespan rating based on the actual needs of consumers. For example, if we know the average renovation cycle for single family houses in the US is ten years, then we should make LED bulbs that are rated for 10 years. This way, manufacturers can deliver these products at at the most affordable price point, and consumers for the most part won't have to worry about replacing their lights ever again.
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Stratoscope on Saturday July 16, 2016 @10:13PM (#12108751)
So instead of a private cartel regulating light bulb lifespan and fining manufacturers whose bulbs last more or less than that time, you want the government to do the same?
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Dylan16807 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @11:43PM (#12108930)
There is a pretty big difference between a mandatory lifetime and a minimum lifetime.

As far as I know, minimum fitness-for-purpose standards are pretty good for the consumer.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Stratoscope on Sunday July 17, 2016 @04:43AM (#12109491)
That's a fair criticism. I did conflate two different things there, and I was needlessly snarky. (And I upvoted your comment for pointing it out.)

I also failed to address the thing that bothered me in the comment I replied to:

> Far from a cartel, we should let the government create a standardized LED lifespan rating based on the actual needs of consumers. For example, if we know the average renovation cycle for single family houses in the US is ten years, then we should make LED bulbs that are rated for 10 years.

Why should it be the government's business to determine what "the actual needs of consumers" are? How does the government know what the average renovation cycle for single family homes is? What about people who want to spend more for longer-lasting bulbs, or spend less for shorter-lived ones? What about other types of homes that don't fit the government-specified "average renovation cycle"?

How do companies innovate when the government has said, "This is the standard specification for an LED light bulb. You will make them to our standard or you won't make them at all."

I just find the very concept offensive that this should be any business of the government. Life is full of trade-offs, and it seems to me that the government - the instrument of force - is least capable of anyone to make these trade-offs.

Regardless of my personal feelings, there is a real cost in getting the government involved in these things. Government intervention never comes for free.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by DanBC on Sunday July 17, 2016 @04:49AM (#12109505)
> Why should it be the government's business to determine what "the actual needs of consumers" are?

The government has signed up to various international treaties around ewaste and other eco indicators.

Consumers only buy on price.

Government sets minimum standards, which forces manufacturers to build their minimum cost devices to that standard. Manfs can also offer better devices for more money.

> How do companies innovate when the government has said, "This is the standard specification for an LED light bulb. You will make them to our standard or you won't make them at all."

Your mobile phone is intensely regulated across a number of different regulators. There seems to be plenty of innovation in cellphones.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Stratoscope on Sunday July 17, 2016 @05:27AM (#12109552)
Thanks for your comment, you raise some good points. I do have to question a couple of things:

> Consumers only buy on price.

Really? Everyone I know also looks at reviews, brand reputation, and other factors. Of course you're right that sometimes we just buy the cheapest option. :-)

> Your mobile phone is intensely regulated across a number of different regulators. There seems to be plenty of innovation in cellphones.

Is the innovation in the areas governments regulate, or in the areas they don't? I just made a list of 20 or so key attributes of a cellphone, and I don't think they are things that are regulated. (I was going to post the list, but had second thoughts that it may seem argumentative, and they seem pretty obvious anyway.)

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by TeMPOraL on Sunday July 17, 2016 @07:11AM (#12109762)
> Really? Everyone I know also looks at reviews, brand reputation, and other factors. Of course you're right that sometimes we just buy the cheapest option. :-)

Anecdata time! :).

I think that this sometimes turns out to be more often than not :). Not many people have time to read reviews and check brand reputations for everything they buy. Personally, I divide shopping decisions into two groups - where I care about quality, and where I don't. In the former group, which includes mostly expensive stuff, I'll check some reviews. In the latter, I don't care. The latter group mostly consists of things that cost about as much or less than my time spent on doing research.

But from what I've seen (and experienced), a lot of things move from the "check reviews" to "buy on price" group the moment one is low on cash and/or low on free time. Anecdata - my mother used to buy CFLs but at some point switched back to incandescents (the ones that are illegal in EU, but are being sold in every corner shop anyway, just labeled as "not for household use") just because she didn't have time / energy to go to the big store that sells decent CFLs at a reasonable price. I only upgraded her apartment to LEDs after few of those cheap-ass incandescents literally exploded, sending glass shards all over the kitchen.

> I was going to post the list, but had second thoughts that it may seem argumentative, and they seem pretty obvious anyway.

Please post that list, I'm interested. Even if it seems obvious, it may not be obvious to everyone.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Stratoscope on Sunday July 17, 2016 @05:43PM (#12112021)
I think your anecdata is right on the money!

(Pun unintended, but now that it's there I'll take credit for it...)

Yeah, when I said "everyone I know looks at reviews" I meant "at least some of the time". :-)

So my list of cellphone characteristics I didn't post - I was thinking of things like this:

Size, shape, and weight. Battery technology and capacity - removable or not? Display technology, size and resolution. Resistive or capacitive touch? Stylus? Physical keyboard? Processor technology, how many cores, what instruction set, what GPU? Memory size? Storage size? External storage (SD)? Charger standard? External audio and digital ports? What kinds of sensors? Operating system and application software. What programming languages are used. How software is distributed. Who is allowed to write software.

I don't think many of those are specified by a government agency. At least I hope they aren't!

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Spooky23 on Saturday July 16, 2016 @09:48PM (#12108679)
LEDs suck less, and are much better than garbage CFL, but are still more expensive and less versatile than the old bulbs, particularly when you need a bright bulb.
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by wtallis on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:03AM (#12109081)
Fortunately, you only need a bright bulb for flashlights and for fixtures that are intended for incandescent bulbs. For general interior lighting, a large array/string of relatively dim LEDs is usually fine.
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by _ph_ on Sunday July 17, 2016 @04:39AM (#12109485)
Not sure why you would think anyone today would use an incandescent bulb in a flashlight. This is where LEDs just took over. I have a pencil sizes LED flashlight that matches the brightness of my Maglite only when I put it in power-saving mode - otherwise its about 10x as bright.
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by srtjstjsj on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:26AM (#12109125)
except that many LEDs flicker horribly because they have bad electronics, and the consumer has no way to judge quality.
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by snuxoll on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:52AM (#12109171)
This really is the crux, unlike fluorescent (including CFL) and traditional incandescent lamps LED's are a lot more sensitive to having consistent DC power, a crappy little capacitive dropper is not appropriate to power them, yet a lot of manufacturers decided to cheap out on an additional diode to build a proper bridge rectifier. The amount of electronics to properly drive an chain of LED's is so simple and cheap I really can't figure out why they are shaving tenths a penny or two (considering the bulk rates they can get these parts at) on lamps that are sold at pretty high profit margins.

I really wish there was someone like bigclive that just tore down LED lamps sold in the US and posted reviews on Amazon, etc. about the internal driver circuitry.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Spooky23 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @01:59AM (#12109179)
Your comment captures the problem far better.

For 100 years, if a bulb burned out or you bought a lamp, you went a bought a sodding lightbulb. The choices were clear... good brand/shit brand. 20/40/60/75/100/150/3way. Soft white or not soft white. They cost like a quarter.

Now the Home Depot lightbulb aisle is as complicated as the screw and fastener aisle. My guess is the average bigbox home store has 50 SKUs on the shelf for 60 watt equivalent bulbs. It's ridiculous.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Symbiote on Sunday July 17, 2016 @03:03AM (#12109320)
Go to Ikea.

They have about four bulbs for each socket (pear and candle, dim and bright), and the ones I bought a year ago are very good.

I think they have more incentive to sell good quality bulbs than the average store, since they sell the fitting and market being environmentally friendly.

Of the ones I bought, some were made in China and some in Germany.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by afarrell on Sunday July 17, 2016 @04:44AM (#12109493)
There are some US states whithout an IKEA, such as Maine.

Incidentally, in Maine, incandescent light bulbs are almost 100% efficient for much of the year as they produce both light and heat.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by CalRobert on Sunday July 17, 2016 @06:43AM (#12109689)
100% is a bit of a deceptive claim, since 1) we can exceed 100% with heat pumps, and 2) pretty much _every_ electrical appliance in an enclosed space is 100% efficient at converting energy to heat. 3) For the most part, the electricity being used to power those incandescents is produced with 25-50% efficiency. Burning gas to make heat to run a turbine to produce electricity to transmit it to your home to heat a coil to make light is not very efficient. Ideally it's combined-cycle (waste heat boils water to spin another turbine) but it's still not as good as just burning that gas in your furnace.

My apartment, lovely as it is, has vile, ancient, horrible resistive electric storage heaters. I live in a somewhat cold climate. I suck it up and pay for renewably-sourced electricity to assuage the guilt because there's no way I'm going to win in a fight to install heat pumps or gas-fired heating with my landlord.

In this limited scenario, incandescents make sense. If I owned this place those hunk-of-crap heaters would be in the skip tomorrow and all the incandescent bulbs with them.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by douche on Sunday July 17, 2016 @07:40AM (#12109832)
Electric heating is a huge red flag - living in the northeast US, that tends to indicate that whoever built the building is not from around here, and perhaps came up from the South, or some other area that does not have real winters. Usually where you find electric heaters, you'll also find wildly insufficient insulation, foundations that aren't up to frost, and any number of other design flaws that bite you in the ass when it is below freezing for four or five months out of the year.

Natural gas or heating oil is far more economical, although nothing beats the warmth provided by a good wood stove.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by CalRobert on Sunday July 17, 2016 @10:48AM (#12110341)
I agree, though in this case it has more to do with Dublin apartments generally having crap heating facilities. The landlord knows full well the costs he imposes.

Of course, I could also have looked for an apartment with gas heating, but the reality is the rent here is low enough that simply offsetting the environmental cost of electric heating with power sourced from wind (which is where almost all of this island's renewable energy comes from) is still a better deal.

It may be worth noting that it gets cool, but not especially cold, here, at least by New England standards. In January the average low is 3C, so still above freezing, and snow is rare, though it does happen.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Symbiote on Sunday July 17, 2016 @05:53AM (#12109600)
When using electricity for heating, a heat pump is more than 100% efficient.

I live in Denmark, where regulations mean new buildings can't have simple electric heaters installed.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday July 17, 2016 @06:33AM (#12109675)
Yep, modern heat pumps are up to and above 4:1 thermal efficiency. References in my other comment.
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by PhantomGremlin on Sunday July 17, 2016 @06:03AM (#12109617)
I really wish there was someone like bigclive that just tore down LED lamps sold in the US and posted reviews

There is such a guy "electronupdate", but I think he's from north of the border. Close enough. His older teardowns were better, because the bulbs themselves were better. Now there's a race to the bottom (of course).

If you watch his teardowns you will see that the older Philips bulbs are superior to all others.

E.g. here's a very good review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OWKAub54sLU

He's also done teardowns of some real crap bulbs.

There are also some "bigclive" LED bulb reviews on Youtube but I haven't watched them.

Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by Retra on Saturday July 16, 2016 @10:07PM (#12108728)
"Consumers for the most part" do not regularly renovate their houses. Most of them are renters. And paying someone else to change your lightbulbs doesn't protect you from having to get them changed.
Re:The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy (2014) by seanp2k2 on Sunday July 17, 2016 @02:26AM (#12109234)
This. I know that the "10 years" was just an example, and I don't have the relevant data on home remodels, but 10 years on average in the US seems ridiculously fast to me. I would guess that the average is more like 30-40 for those doing renovations, and like parent says, many aren't renovating.