Even if government worked exactly as it's supposed to, the law would be at best a reflection of the will of the majority of people. But I don't give the majority of people any benefit of the doubt for creating just rules, and why should I?
The government is not perfect (but what large group of people is?), but affecting change should be done by participating and from the inside, not by willfully ignoring laws that you don't agree with from the outside.
Moreover, there are so many laws that are down-right wrongheaded, and everybody agrees about it, that it corrupts respect for the laws that are just morally grey.
Maybe everyone you know, or everyone you interact with. Especially if you're talking about laws that are largely based on morals (gay marriage, marijuana, etc). There are plenty of loud, outspoken supporters of even the dumbest laws.
For instance, there is an ordinance in the town I work in that it is illegal to back into a street parking spot. Why? No one knows, and it is rarely enforced, but technically can result in a non-trivial parking fine.
You always have a choice to either follow the law or not to follow the law.
Both choices come with consequences that can be either positive or negative to you - it all depends on situation.
That said, part of living in a society is following the laws you don't like too. The cases where an upstanding citizen will decide to disobey the Man exist, though they are rare in a functioning society. What I find problematic is encouraging people to treat breaking random laws for no serious reason as a good thing.
How does your contention account for speeding, jaywalking and marijuana use? Those are three examples that jump to mind of laws that are essentially universally flaunted in the US (and I suspect elsewhere). Is America not a functional society, or do we have almost no upstanding citizens?
http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/general-statistics/fatalit...
Why is it that so many need the above explained?
Those are questions that one has to ask oneself too when considering breaking a law. People don't speed or evade taxes because government is corrupt and people are stupid. They do so mostly because they're lazy and selfish. Dumping costs and risk on other parties is easy, but it's not a way to live in a civilized world.
Again, I'm not saying all laws are Words of God - just that there's a difference between breaking something out of necessity because it's unjust or totally broken, and breaking something to exploit it for personal profit / encouraging others to do so.
Then the lawmakers pass a law that clashes with something that many believed in. In this case with property rights.
In such a case people will not follow laws without thinking about it, instead they will consider carefully the tradeoffs of breaking it.
People are not robots that follow new rules mechanically, the rules must be reasonable to them.
[0] - Since you bring up Napster; yes, I'm guilty of piracy just like everyone else and I'm in general opposed to the very concept of "intellectual property". I applaud initiatives like SciHub too, but don't encourage - or consider virtuous - breaking laws for personal profit at expense of society at large. So while it may seem so, it's not hypocritical. I think of SciHub as a Good Thing, while I consider my own past history with downloading video games as a small but bad thing. The stuff Uber, AirBnB and tax evasion in general does lands squarely on the bad side of this - ignoring laws for personal profit, local markets and society in general be damned.
They will simply ignore them. Lawmakers have to carefully consider this and they generally do it.
Not to mention the fact that we don't hold people accountable for questionable outcomes after the laws are enacted. We're essentially stabbing in the dark, expecting to have a more "accurate" stab the next time around using previous experience. Social policies, and their results are inherently grey, and we should treat the laws that surround them as such.
The moral valence of the law has been corrupted by asshole laws designed exactly to dump externalities on people who didn't generate them for personal advantage, among other things. So when you've got asshole laws, it encourages asshole behavior.
In the United States, anyway, disdain for laws you disagree with is baked into the culture. The American Revolution and the Civil Rights Movement are both all about breaking laws that were considered unjust, and popular entertainment is packed full of vigilantes breaking the law in pursuit of a greater good.
With that sort of mental baggage swimming about in people's heads, is it really any surprise when large numbers of Americans decide to simply ignore laws and regulations they don't believe are justified?
No, he didn't.
That's a big reason why discussions here go wrong. You either write paragraph after paragraph, closing every little loophole in your argument that someone can abuse, or people jump on to an outlandish, uncharitable interpretation and the subthread is toxic.
Going back to the article - I might decide not to run an AirBnB unit if it was truly inconveniencing the neighbors, and I might decide not to run an AirBnB unit if I was afraid of getting fined a large sum of money, but I'd never give up my AirBnB units just because the local government said I had to. It would never even pop into my mind - I just wouldn't consider the regulation legitimate.
I wonder why we're so different. Education? Parenting? Stuff like this is so interesting!
So this is where I come from. Even though I'm not a religious person anymore, over the years I thought a lot about the approach to the rules and oragnizations, and came to the conclusion that the society is better off if everyone follows the rules by default, suboptimal they may be, instead of rebelling whenever they feel like. Both because some rules are actually good even if they don't seem so, and for others, it's easier to change things when people are willing to cooperate and authorities aren't so busy fighting fires.
Back to the culture. For context, I'm from Europe, Poland. I meet a mix of various approaches. Some are law-abiding citizens. Most break laws here and there, but generally treat upholding them as a virtue and their behaviour as something not good, but done out of practical necessity. I don't encounter people glorifying law-breaking very often.
As for vigilantes from TV you mentioned in your previous comment, I like those shows like everyone else. Though I have to remind myself all the time that it's fiction - law enforcement isn't as incompetent as those shows always portray, and lot of the stuff heroes do aren't feasible in the real world. Then again, I'm still a Star Trek guy - I side with organizations made of good, competent, ethical people.
Ah. Well a lot of other people were brought up, to so speak, with a more Firefly-inspired worldview.
It seemed so obvious (to me, anyway) why people routinely break laws that I assumed the person I replied to came from a very different culture than my own, and I wanted to learn where the person's actual boundaries were. There are cultures out there that (from my perspective) believe some deeply weird things about the role of law and government in society, and it fascinates me.
I suppose I could've phrased it differently, but when I ask a question, it's because I'm looking for clarification, not because I've decided on an interpretation.
In the same way that Airbnb, Uber and a lot of HN are arguing that 100% of laws and regulations should be repealed, 100% of government employees fired and everything turned over to a meritocratic free market which will instantly perfectly and permanently solve all problems.
I mean - should I interpret it as a good sign, of people questioning assumptions to check if they still hold true, or is the society really going so bonkers that the very idea of being a law-abiding citizen is seen in negative light?
EDIT - added "in general [0]" and a footnote to clarify.
[0] - I mean not "follow all regulations blindly", but "follow regulations by default unless there is a very good reason not to".