News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by venomsnake on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:46AM (#12086073)
> In its press release, the BKA said that the operation carried out this week aims to combat a "strong rise in verbal radicalism."

Raiding homes of people posting stupid private shit on the internet is also great way to get more physical radicalism.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:22AM (#12086316)
It is more than stupid shit, it is illegal stupid shit. Please read (edit: replaced, was "the") the German legal code. From your argument it would be better not to pursue crime just because you might "(to) get more physical radicalism"? That is clearly not justice.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by frabbit on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:39AM (#12086453)
That's right. If it's the law then it must be right. It's a simple way of thinking that has worked out very well in many situations.

Meanwhile: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/apr/15/angela-merkel-...

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:04AM (#12086683)
You forget that in Germany we have "Gewaltenteilung", meaning that legislation, judiciary and executive are separated. This is a concept that is fundamental to our country and culture. If the law is not okay it is not in the power of the executive to change, not enforce or bend it. There is a separate process for it that must be invoked. (In this case) there seems to be no critical mass that calls for changing this particular law. And you can rest assured that we have a very active public discussion about changes to the criminal code right now, with thousands of people actively participating. As you might be better informed the me, could you please cite at least one instance of what these people or people in similar cases said/wrote that should NOT the punishable, but is under current law?

edit: citing the decision to allow prosecution of Böhmermann reveals how little you understand the German legal system. The article is misleading at best and not covering the legal grounds and background correctly at all.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:35AM (#12087012)
@frabbit exactly, but they did NOT yell "fire" but "open fire on the immigrants" (literally: in one instance the comment was posted beneath a picture of a immigrant child "you need a flamethrower to get rid of these bugs", with bugs might not be the best translation here) posted besides Nazi symbols.

At least for me, this makes a difference.

edit: I am going out on a limb here, but I thought exactly this was one of the purposes of RICO. Telling someone to commit a crime in a formed group is a crime and not free speech. I am a total amateur in US criminal code, is this understanding correct?

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by frabbit on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @12:47PM (#12087613)
You are correct. Legal codes in many countries criminalize the act of speech itself.

This even goes all the way back to the concept of "assault" in anglo-saxon legal traditions[1] (which is the simple threat part of the pair "assault and battery". Many of us use "assault" to mean a physical attack, but it seems originally to be simply causing someone to fear.)

Again, though, you are arguing that because something is the law then that in itself makes it moral and useful.

Those who make slippery-slope arguments about the vesting of power in the state seem increasingly persuasive when we see the turning of the act of speaking into a crime itself. For further examples of "European" countries which illustrate the dangers you could look at Ireland's blasphemy laws which still stand.

1. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/assault

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:20PM (#12087916)
I don't necessarily argue that everything is right because it is the law, I argue that THIS exact law is right. It might not be for you, but it is for me. And seemingly not only for.me, but for a lot of people in this country. Otherwise there would be a (stronger) opposition to this law. I think we might have to recognize that the German culture is different from yours (US I suppose it is) and that we simply cannot expect to agree on everything. This might be because we are grown up in the system that protects us both adequately and we therefore think it is the best one, only because it is a adequate one. This goes both ways, e.g. you are right to think your system is better while I am right to think ours is. And exactly that tolerance is what I would like to not only see but DEMAND from other people. And I believe this exact law is right in a way that it makes it harder for people that don't recognize that all people are created and to be treated equal to express and propagate their beliefs. I think you could even find a similar or maybe exact same argument for your position. I respect that but hope you have other ways to ensure no one creates a climate of fear, hatred and violence (physical and non-physical) against people that are different. This law will not be everything the German culture sets against that climate but is one piece of our puzzle.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by frabbit on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:45PM (#12088119)
> you are right to think your system is better while I am right to think ours is. And exactly that tolerance is what I would like to not only see but DEMAND from other people.

I am not interested in the personalization of the argument or grounding it in lived experience of any sort.

Objectively the system which you extoll results in censorship, in this case of criticism of a near-dictator involved in genocide against the Kurdish people.

I believe that enabling a state to censor what people can say is dangerous to democracy. I think this is adequately demonstrated through numerous historical and current examples.

Your statement of "tolerance" is meaningless because you will be unaware of other viewpoints of which you must be tolerant when they are censored.

Ironically as this discussion is deemed offensive to the moderators of HN this entire discussion has been effaced.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @02:31PM (#12088527)
I can't follow. How is this incident related to any genocide, dictatorship, erdogan... what?

I have the feeling you are just cherry picking this to troll on and not interested in talking about the different dogmatics of legal systems. I didn't want to personalize the discussion, just replace "you" and "me" with "any person from your belief system" and "any person from my belief system". It looks to me that you are not interested in thinking about other people's opinion and/or belief system. Now THAT was a personal remark.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by frabbit on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @02:56PM (#12088704)
> I can't follow. How is this incident related to any genocide, dictatorship, erdogan... what?

Really? So, you can't see the link between the German state's power to choose which speech acts can be punished and the punishing of someone for speech acts?

You cannot see the link between the Turkish bombing and starving of the Kurdish people and the historical assaults by your own country on minority populations?

I am not going to reply any more to you as you have descended to personalized abuse, but I will close with thanking you for illustrating exactly why the policing of free speech can never be allowed: there are too many people like you who are incapable of exercising tolerance and rationality, and once a lever of power and control is in your hands you will pull it.

Thank you, and god bless the USA.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:34PM (#12089453)
"The German state" is a construct in form of a organization. The people who decide are forming the structure of this organization. The concrete people who are deciding who is punished are judges. As I already stated in this discussion, we employ "Gewaltenteilung" to separate judiciary, execute and legislative. So "the state" is not able to punish anybody, it is people who punish. And they do by the rules that are set for the judiciary, which are made by the legislative and carried out by the executive. The executive has a different set of rules than the legislative and they have a different set then the judiciary. These different sets of rules are each a corrective for potential abuse of power. There is no "state" punishing anybody, it is a set of rules made by people, carried out by people, watched by people. For somebody who broadcasts that free speech is the Holy grail you act like you don't tolerate no opinion besides your own. You're basically a fanatic and revealed your own colors.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by frabbit on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:49AM (#12087125)
While abhorrent I do not believe that speech should be made illegal.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by frabbit on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:25AM (#12086902)
> could you please cite at least one instance of what these people or people in similar cases said/wrote that should NOT the punishable, but is under current law?

If I am parsing what you wrote correctly then you are asking me to draw a distinction between different types of speech which should be allowed under law.

I don't believe any should be restricted. That includes the classic "shouting `fire' in a crowded theatre" or making threats to someone. Certainly in both cases if actual physical or financial harm results then the speaker can be deemed to have caused harm and measures taken against them. But the outlawing and punishment of the act of speech in and of itself is illogical.

In effect hate speech and other laws conflate locution, illocution and perlocution[1].

The effect on the discussion of ideas (e.g. the criticism of Erdogan) in a democracy strike me as obvious, so I won't go into them further.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illocutionary_act

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by jklinger410 on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:39AM (#12086451)
Laws are not moral and right just because they are laws.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by Overtonwindow on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:43AM (#12086490)
Laws that oppress the free expression of ideas, which are not expressed to advocate direct or indirect harm or violence, are bad laws that should be broken.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:24AM (#12086888)
I don't really think that calling to arms (in this case as self justice in combination with using Nazi symbols) is expression of free speech. It is totally okay that our understanding of free speech differs, but I just don't count that as free speech. And sympathizing with Nazis by using their symbols is not okay for me, too. I might be wrong, but in a lot of countries it might not be legal to call for self justice on a whole race.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by preetbhinder on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:18AM (#12086824)
I disagree, violence is not just physical, verbal abuse can be a form of violence as well. What kind of idea is public hate speech expressing?

From the article, "Attacks on refugees are often the result of radicalization, which begins on social networks."

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by strictnein on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:23AM (#12086879)
Attacks on free speech radicalize me.

You don't restrict rights based on how others respond to people exercising those rights.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by lawless123 on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:10AM (#12086744)
" and that most of the suspects were accused of posting anti-Semitic, xenophobic, and other extremist messages"

Laws that stop this kind of "expression" have existed in Germany a while now, for historical reasons.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by brbsix on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:44AM (#12086499)
Some state intervention (e.g. drug prohibition) creates issues (in this case mass violations of civil liberties, militarization of police, vast numbers of incarcerated minorities, criminalization of medical conditions) that are measurably worse than the original problem it intended to solve. I don't know whether that's the case here, but it's worth asking. You'd better be certain that hate speech online is a serious enough problem that it is worth the cost, and you'd better have a good idea of what the cost will be.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by xiaoma on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:11AM (#12086755)
>"It is more than stupid shit, it is illegal stupid shit."

Exactly. This is like how posting negative things about the communist party leadership in a wechat group can get your house raided. Break the law, and police might show up.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by angersock on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:51AM (#12086568)
Would you feel the same way were the ban on sodomy or support of gays?
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by lawless123 on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:12AM (#12086760)
Do you feel all opinions on this are equal? That someone expressing misinformation about groups or calling for restrictions to their freedom is equivalent to someone expressing support for the same minorities?
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by angersock on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:21PM (#12087928)
I feel that whenever practices like this are made acceptable, invariably abuses follow. It is an accident of history that the people being picked on now are regarded as deserving.

I'll pose my earlier question with a different group--how would you feel were this being done to conservative Christians or Muslims? Both groups express misinformation and sometimes call for restrictions on others (covering women in public, treatment of homosexuals, this sort of thing).

We can't get everyone to get along. However, we can seek to eliminate state powers that are ripe for abuse.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by tremon on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @03:35PM (#12089003)
It is an accident of history that the people being picked on now are regarded as deserving.

No, that's not an accident. It's an evolutionary necessity: https://www.myind.net/tolerance-intolerance-and-game-theory

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:28AM (#12086932)
If you could indicate using Nazi symbols and calling to arms and self justice is free speech I would be happy to discuss further. I have a bit of a doubt that you grasp what the charge is.
Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by angersock on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:23PM (#12087947)
All of those are communicative in nature and do not involve the bodily injury of another human being--so yes, I think it's fair to consider them free speech.

I am unfamiliar with German law, so if you would like to educate me on the nuances of the charge, I would appreciate it.

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by king_phil on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:48PM (#12088154)
I think a very important nuance here is that it is not enough to just tell other people to commit crimes against people from a religion/race/color/gender/..., it must be suitable (I have trouble translating here) to be effective in that matter. The reason is explicitly the human rights, because nobody should fear to be harmed because somebody told other people to harm people from a certain gender/race etc.

There are BTW other "Äußerungsdelikte" (statement offenses, free translation), like slander and deformation. All these are based on the human right that no harm should be inflicted on you because somebody says something wrong about you (in a very simplistic way, you normally would have a lots of hours of law lectures just on this offenses, their reasoning and distinction).

Re:German police raid homes over Facebook hate speech by detaro on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:45PM (#12088118)
English wikipedia seems to have ok coverage of the relevant laws:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volksverhetzung

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strafgesetzbuch_section_86a

Specifics are hard to judge without the actual content and context of the posts, this stuff keeps courts busy.