(My 401k is managed by Vanguard)
I think the important thing to understand about this space is that a custodian is required by law, and that their fees they take are (conceptually) separate from the fees your funds charge.
These 401k plan providers charge fees. Typically fairly substantial fees (like 1%) and typically the fees are well-hidden. By "well-hidden" I mean that it probably takes a knowledgeable researcher months to find out what the fees are -- I've certainly never known the fees for any plan I've ever had.
This startup purports to compete by charging fewer fees 401k plan provider fees.
Sounds like the USA's Openednded mutual funds are even more dodgy than the uk equivalents (unit trusts)
employer matching was separate, you and the employer add money, then you choose what to do.
IMHO, 401k should go away and the deductible limits on IRA should be raised to compensate and let people do their own thing.
Guideline is trying to be the Vanguard of 401(k) custodians.
The second hand info I have from a startup (that I worked at) negotiating with a 401(k) provider leads me to believe that are basically 2 common 401(k) setups in the industry.
In the least bad case, the company pays a bunch of money to the custodian in exchange for the custodian giving the employees access to good funds (vanguard institutional shares).
In the more bad case, the company pays the custodian nothing, and the employees only get access to funds that kick money back to the custodian. As you might be able to guess, these funds typically have quite high fees.