News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by JoshTriplett on Saturday July 09, 2016 @01:29AM (#12060253)
Copyright belongs to the person tweeting, not to Twitter (they just get a license from the person tweeting). And fair use specifically mentions "criticism, comment, news reporting, [...] scholarship, or research", several of which apply to reporting on deleted tweets from prominent public figures.

This isn't a copyright issue at all; it's exclusively a ToS issue. Twitter can choose to prevent someone from using their API. They'd have a harder time forcing the takedown of the existing content.

Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by simbalion on Saturday July 09, 2016 @03:49AM (#12060595)
It's a 1st amendment issue. If someone says something in a public forum what they said becomes public domain.
Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by jonknee on Saturday July 09, 2016 @01:46AM (#12060296)
Yes, and what do you think of the person who deleted a tweet will say about you using their copyright? I would argue it is a copyright issue because by deleting content a user is saying they don't want anyone to access it. Why would Twitter then want to turn around and allow access to it through an API?

As a user I think this is the right tack to take. There is no possible advantage for Twitter to have sites that make the delete feature not really work.

Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by wpietri on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:32AM (#12060401)
Copyright is the right we give to content creators so that they can financially benefit from their work. It is not a generic "I control everything I have ever said" power.

In particular, "fair use" specifically doesn't require people to get permission from a copyright holder:

http://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/fair-use/what-is-fair-u...

Discussing the tweets of public figures is clearly "commentary and criticism", which would give things like PostGhost "substantial non-infringing use" (which I believe is the relevant legal threshold).

Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by thaumasiotes on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:53AM (#12060462)
> and what do you think of the person who deleted a tweet will say about you using their copyright?

How could this possibly be relevant? Copyright won't give them any grounds to stop you from saying "he's trying to walk it back now, but he said <embarrassing statement> earlier".

Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by Dylan16807 on Saturday July 09, 2016 @01:52AM (#12060306)
> Why would Twitter then want to turn around and allow access to it through an API?

Then? No, this is about getting it through the API while it's still up.

Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by jonknee on Saturday July 09, 2016 @01:59AM (#12060320)
Obviously, but with the restriction you also delete it when it's no longer in the API. It would be ridiculous if Twitter helped developers to embarrass/blackmail their users.
Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by cyphar on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:55AM (#12060470)
If it is stored for purposes of commentary or news reporting, then it would fall under fair use and neither Twitter nor the original author have any power to stop you from republishing the tweets as long as it is considered fair use.
Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by Dylan16807 on Saturday July 09, 2016 @03:31AM (#12060560)
You can't undo saying something to a hundred thousand people. You can demand everyone forget, but it won't work.
Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by edoceo on Saturday July 09, 2016 @11:14AM (#12061584)
Big Brother, 1984
Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by roywiggins on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:00AM (#12060321)
When someone's an verified user, they're a public figure and have an outsize impact on the Twitter discourse (they tend to have a lot of followers). The things they say are inherently newsworthy. If the archiving is done for the purpose of scholarship or commentary it sounds like a compelling argument for it being fair use.
Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by thwarted on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:15AM (#12060355)
I think that one of the things that an account should have to trade in for being a Verified Account is the ability to delete tweets. Being a public figure and having the notoriety that is implicit in having a Verified Account, the account should have to stand by what it tweets, or at least not be able to modify the public record and break references to its content.
Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by exolymph on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:58AM (#12060479)
I like this idea, but I think a big function of the checkmark is reassuring people that an account belong to who it says it belongs to. For example, @realDenaldTrump is not verified (even though people still fall for it).

That said, Twitter administers the checkmark in puzzling and thoroughly non-transparent ways.

Re:Post Ghost Shutdown: An Open Letter to Twitter by thwarted on Saturday July 09, 2016 @01:19PM (#12062324)
I think a big function of the checkmark is reassuring people that an account belong to who it says it belongs to

That is in fact the only reason Verified Accounts exist, and is the reason that non-celebrities or people otherwise lacking notoriety can not get Verified Accounts. It's not worth Twitter's effort to make my account, or any random user, Verified, it seems. But as Twitter's role continues to expand in the public sphere, it is really the public who gives out Verified Accounts (through making someone famous), and the public should have requirements, such as a certain level of consistency, from the accounts it gives the power/influence of the Verified Account to.