The good news is that the Olm end-to-end cryptographic ratchet that Matrix is in the process of deploying (https://matrix.org/git/olm) is built using the same algorithms as Signal Protocol's ratchet (although it's an independent implementation) - so we're hopeful that at least technically the window is open in future for using Matrix to defragment all the services who have adopted Signal Protocol (WhatsApp, Google Allo, FB Messenger, Signal itself etc) without compromising the E2E privacy. Right now this is total sci-fi, and won't likely happen (whilst preserving E2E crypto) without cooperation from FB, Google etc.
However, we hope to get Matrix to the point where they see that the longer term benefits of participating in a healthy open ecosystem outweigh the short term benefits of trying to lock users into a silo - just as email eventually interoperated over the early internet. That's a while off, but this is still the goal.
The best way to make sure this happens is to play with Matrix in its current form, and help us write bridges (e.g. https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-appservice-bridge/blob/...) to interface as many silos as possible into Matrix. The more bridges, the more useful Matrix is, and the higher the chance of building an ecosystem which eventually Google, FB and friends will find attractive.
On the client side, it depends on the client you're using. Many native Matrix clients and many bridged clients give the option to store local history (whether it was originally encypted or not). Smarter clients will store it encrypted at rest by whatever mechanisms the OS and hardware provides.
This is why I will not use or recommend Signal. Moxie's anti-federation stance is unacceptable to me. It's replacing one problem with another.
Beyond federation, I would also like the solutions to have good features and usability. Right now I'm bouncing between a few walled systems:
1. Telegram - really fast development pace, poor crypto, E2E encryption is only for chosen chats and single device.
2. Signal - slow to deliver messages, not multi-device and has usability bugs and issues. I update it somewhat regularly and try using it, but still go back to Telegram because basic expectations aren't met.
3. Wire - I discovered this recently and like the feature set (it's a lot richer than Signal). It claims to use the Signal protocol and has support for voice and video too. All chats are E2E encrypted (unlike Telegram where non-secret chats are by default not encrypted on the device or on Telegram's servers), and it has multi-device support with message sync (only from the time the device is joined to the account). Clients are available for different mobile and desktop platforms. But this one also has poor usability in getting started with it and has simple things missing - like no message delivered or message read indicators (the latter could at least be present as a user selectable option for privacy). I don't know how slow this is to deliver messages, but it's definitely not as fast as Telegram is. Not knowing if a message reached or not is unacceptable in this era.
I'm still waiting for some more strong solutions to appear in this space. Seeing that more platforms are adopting the Signal protocol, it would be great to have some standardization in user identification and federation. I actually do not want any of these solutions to be completely free and wish they would provide some way to help them monetarily (at least for the people who do want to help them). I feel repelled by the "free forever" and "we'll sell premium things later, like stickers" parts. That also brings suspicions about the motives of the company/developers and the future viability of the application or platform. At least allow people to donate to you so that you feel some kind of return obligation for all users!
I have a feeling that federation is one of those Good Things that reduce the potential user base until it isn't good any more.
What you won't be able to do is federate with the official servers.
Oh, and there's also a WebSocket transport (used by the Desktop client) that doesn't involve Google. That just doesn't provide a pleasant experience on mobile.
I'm sorry, but is this a joke? "To not use a centralized server that you can neither audit nor trust, you have to recompile the client, but that's easy?"
This smacks of "oh, PGP for email is fiiiiiine." To say nothing of the silliness of the inability to federate.
Don't casually disregard him because you or others can't understand basics of doing what it takes to alter and run a service in your own private space.
I don't need Signal to communicate with knowledgeable people. We need something to communicate with everyone else.
The moment you open the door for federation, the protocol is written in stone forever. All it takes is one server in the federation network with a substantial user base that chooses not to update. (See SMTP).
OWS decided that relinquishing the ability to force updates (i.e. away from a broken cryptosystem) would sacrifice too much in the way of security to be consistent with the project's goals.
Did you just coin that? It appropriately captures what is going on, but without having the positive connotation that comes from a 'walled garden'. I love the phrase.
As an example outside of messaging, I have a fitbit and 'digital prison' so aptly describes what happens with my personal health data. I can't get my heart rate data out of their prison, because the fitbit warden doesn't see it fit to grant me the privilege to access my raw data.
Which is exactly why people go to them.
> while in reality you go there because it's the most crowded place.
Directly true of social networks (where the "crop" is "people you can interact with through the network"), perhaps less directly true of some other walled gardens (though network effects are a thing.)
But also directly opposite of what you'd expect from a "cult compound", which people go more to escape what is most popular, than to experience what is most popular.
Agreed, I thought of this point while sending my comment but wasn't sure how to put that in words. So maybe it's the "most crowded garden party".
Part of cult indoctrination is giving up personal and private information, documents, secrets and property to participate and become part of the whole. Meanwhile, leaders profit from the property and information given up and use secrets to blackmail or breakdown an individual's identity so they become dependent on the group.
Here's a list of actual cult characteristics [1]. The comparison is an idiotic one to make.
Or at least your data can't.
[0] http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/eagles/hotelcalifornia.html
A lot of people like to sideline complain about that, but tech is no longer its own customer -- there are billions of users who have different preferences than us and they are a lot more lucrative.
I've seen people that ritualistically open certain apps to talk to certain friends and networks of friends, but have no idea what apps they are using beyond the background navigation needs of "the one with the fuzzy green icon on my last page" and "the blue one with the annoying notifications".
Locked in platforms are a consequence of network efforts, not a "preference" for some mystical "guaranteed experience": the experience and the platform don't matter if the social interactions aren't there.
The diaspora of communications platforms hasn't hit home to the average consumer yet, and it's currently background inconvenience that people are using five to ten different apps to communicate these days in some cases, but that doesn't mean average consumers are entirely ignorant of the situation either. (To some extent that's why OS-level notification systems have become so important to the average consumer; at least when you have a half-dozen messenging apps all the notifications arrive in the same place.)
This trend makes me very sad... IM networks are getting more centralized as ever. I don't feel thankful for this kind of development. End-to-end encryption should not be a feature of the service provider, but the client. The way this works with Whatsapp/FB/Google just requires us to believe that their proprietary client is actually doing what it promises. And for me that I don't have a smartphone they just don't even promise anything.
I just wish I could use XMPP or Matrix with my non-nerdy friends. There was this time Google seemed to not be evil with GTalk/XMPP, but then... The business cynicism that dominates this industry, allowing people to claim that they "connect people" at the same time that they put everyone in digital prisons, makes me really want to leave computing and go live in a cave.