This, right here, is what makes me want to stand out in the street and scream like a banshee. It's not that this happens in Seattle with regularity, at least for me. But that it happens more than very occasionally is bad enough for a city's reputation. I happen to really enjoy living in Seattle and I'm tired of seeing my city be (literally and figuratively) shit on by the nose-in-the-air suburbs because we refuse, either out of compassion or indifference, in Seattle to shuffle people off onto someone else.
> acceptance of bad behaviors and almost no penalties for crimes committed by those without means -- citations are ignored, many arrests are catch and release.
In Seattle's case, it's "catch in the suburbs, release into Seattle" and that only compounds the problem. My blood pressure is starting to build so I should really stop replying, and so I shall after this: I'm PISSED AS FUCK that Redmond gets to have a reputation as a leafy suburb with well-groomed bike-and-walk trails and amazing parks while Seattle also has those things but there's a non-zero chance that you'll also witness some taking a bath in the nearby fountain so we get the rap as a run down, dirty city that people rush to escape once the workday is through. (Even though 97% of the city is just as nice and usable as the 'burbs. Our "local paper," the Seattle Times, really seems to enjoy perpetuating the stereotype.)
I'm just ranting at this point and maybe irrationally defending my city so now I'm going to go hop on my bike and enjoy some of those parks and trails and nice weather and pick up my dog from the doggie daycare and have some cold brew coffee or something.
Local individuals here will defend and make excuses for ill behavior, even to the point a few years back -- a local shelter w/ no bed space (waiting list); magically a mentally disturbed individual (inadvertently released) finds bed space due to AB109 or similar; a few days later brutally murders a local business woman who was walking between her house and downtown. When other individuals asked to understand why someone like this magically got bed space, local "homeless advocates" were apoplectic about such questions.
Here, the politics around "homeless issues" are highly polarizing. The ability to have a rationale conversation is almost impossible.
I understand the urge to rant. After 25 years here, some of those "burbs" you mentioned are looking appealing as are other areas in rural california, etc.
I couldn't agree more. I wish this opinion were more widely held. Yes, we should work to create social programs that help people who have nothing. Yes, these people are hurting enough and it's sad to just pile on the trouble.
But we encourage this behavior every time we allow it to happen with no consequences. There's a guy who's been living in a tent on my block on Folsom longer than I've been living in my apartment. What the fuck? The police don't care when I call, even though there are laws in place about this. I'm a monster if I walk over there and rip it down.
There need to be consequences, but how do you discourage someone who has nothing? They're almost inherently unpunishable.
If someone is clearly mentally ill, drug addicted, or otherwise incapable of taking care of themselves, and they violate minor laws repeatedly, something below a prison camp seems like the most appropriate option -- and I don't see why it needs to be in expensive real estate in the city.
A live/work camp wouldn't be break-even, but probably could support people for $10-15k/yr, which is much cheaper than prison or other services. Barring any other system to re-integrate people into society locally, I'd rather they be sent to camp rather than left in parks and permitted to violate laws indefinitely, or sent to jail/prison.
Since the crimes would be very minor, it wouldn't be "punishment" so much as just housing, so there's a lot of opportunity to make it both better for the participants and less expensive than any kind of prison incarceration.
That's the baseline; if private organizations want to provide them with something better, that's an option too, but there's a limit to what city/county/state government can do.
I think if you moved people out to an open facility like that, showed them the lifestyle available and then let them choose whether they would stay, you might see some success? Opportunities for them to find purpose in life, but no huge obligation to work bulk hours; shelter in an affordable region and style; support at-hand, but still the option of ignoring it and staying in control.
Yes, you are a monster if you rip down their home.
Encourage this behavior? How do we encourage homelessness by locking people up for having nothing? Do you think by putting someone in jail or forcing someone with most likely no income to pay a fine that it will all the sudden hit them that homelessness might not be the best lifestyle?
These people are doing what they must to survive. Do some of them have mental health or substance abuse issues? Probably, but the solution to those problems isn't punitive. The sort of issues require counseling and access to health care and most importantly shelter. Trying to combat homelessness by stepping up police efforts (which brings in host of it's own problems) is short sighted and wreaks of NIMBY-ism.
"They're just doing what they must to survive" doesn't justify the street behavior of san francisco vagrants any more than it justifies a hungry dog ripping the face off a kid.
Do you live in a neighborhood where you deal with the homeless and mentally ill on a daily basis and at all hours?
Do you step in shit? Are you spit on? Accosted? Have your roommates come home with phlegm and spit in their hair? Have you left your apartment to find a man's face pressed against the window, yelling "You look like you've been waiting to eat my ass your whole life"?
I'd need a yard to put the Y in NIMBY, but all I have is a feces-caked grate that I routinely kick people off of so I can open the door and get into a street that stinks of piss. Sorry if you're bummed that I'm interrupting their pill sales.
Live and let live doesn't cut it here, not for me. The idea that these people should be left alone regardless of the blight and destruction they cause to public spaces is short sighted and wreaks of "I don't actually experience this problem".
The homeless are struggling. They need help. But they're a scourge, too, and I'm sick and tired of people boo-hooing about how they're just trying to survive as the streets in this city rot from their presence, as though their being in pain makes it acceptable that they erode the quality of every public space in the city. It is not acceptable.
The solutions we have for homelessness and its associated ailments are weak, and need to be better. They need to be rooted in generosity and upward mobility. I completely agree. I'm all for huge city spending on building, and on every conceivable social program, especially for mental health.
What I am not for is turning a blind eye to the realities of homelessness' effects on the city in the mean time, and to distance the crimes and destruction from the individuals who commit them.
You do not get a free pass to fuck up the world because your life sucks.
Well, you encouraged "consequences," which usually means one of those two things.
> But we encourage this behavior every time we allow it to happen with no consequences... There need to be consequences, but how do you discourage someone who has nothing? They're almost inherently unpunishable.
So, there need to be consequences, but you don't agree with locking people up or fining them? What consequences were you referring to then?
Consequences are almost always about losing something, and you have to have something to lose it, so you can't punish those who have nothing.
This creates a bizzaro nightmare scenario where the destitute can commit petty crimes with impunity.
I won't pretend to have a solution to this. So far, I'm not sure anybody does.
But that doesn't mean I can't be mad as hell about it. I'm sick of people saying that how people act in the streets here is somehow short of reprehensible.
Send like 4000 homeless people to a small abandoned town (like old dead mining towns and such), with gear and supplies, such that they can help each other create themselves a society, simultaneously they might revive the abandoned town. If they then choose to leave, they leave. If they choose to stay they stay.
Not everyone needs to be assimilated, and us building services to help them "be successful", is the literal meaning of assimilation. Kinda like a commune or an Amish village, potentially even burning man, allow them to build themselves the society such that they are successfully able to live in.
P.S. I don't have particularly good ideas about how you keep them safe, or even if you should. It should be their society and maybe that means, allow them to make their own laws.
P.P.S. I know I'm crazy.
You can, but please don't do it here. Tirades are destructive to thoughtful, reflective conversation, which is what the site is for.
If you're hot under the collar, please wait until you cool down before posting. That goes for all of us. We have to stop being reflexive before we can become reflective.
If you have an area that pays people to leave it, how is it less desirable? Depending on the bribe amount, it could be tempting to try.
I've seen the camps along the highways when driving from the airport and heading north. It is a problem.
Big cities (especially on the west coast), as mentioned in other threads, have a problem with homelessness. SF has reported numbers around 6600 for a city of 850k, Santa Cruz reported about 3500 for a city of 60k.
The problem here isn't just homelessness, but acceptance of bad behaviors and almost no penalties for crimes committed by those without means -- citations are ignored, many arrests are catch and release.
I don't know what the solution is, but as someone living in a city with severe issues and no will to change it, I enjoy visiting some of those places mentioned on the east side.