I interned at four separate companies when I was younger. I would have never even conceived the idea of doing something like this. Besides the fact that it's three months (seriously, they couldn't wear dress clothes for three months?), a company is not a democracy. I think this might be a side effect of my generation being told they can change anything they want in the world just by signing a petition.
Oh what a load of crap
Generous? Companies use interns for cheap labour (sometimes free). There's nothing generous from their part
I find it very hard to believe they are doing nothing of value whatsoever. Really hard
Not paying interns seems to be a USA thing though.
As an intern I worked with C software, both in Linux and Windows, of course I had less experience and needed "more" supervision, but it was far from worthless. My code ended up in actual products sold by the company. And yes, I was paid for it.
See how much Google pays their interns.
There are lots of intangible benefits too, but I can well imagine that in a straightforward reckoning the net value is close to zero, especially for short internships.
I don't think it's healthy for any social group (not just companies) to be as inflexible as today's companies have grown. A bit of friction and disagreement is a low price to pay for adaptability.
And of course, this kind of inflexibility is symptomatic of entrenched power imbalance which leads to wealth inequality which causes its own host of societal problems. To be clear, I don't think correlation is causation here: the company isn't at fault for creating wealth inequality, but I do worry that we're busy ignoring warning signals that might bite us all in the a if we're not careful.
Which, according to the original source, is exactly what they did with the supporting argument that at least one employee didn't follow dress code, resulting in them being shut down with no answer:
> I felt the dress code was overly strict but I wasn’t going to say anything, until I noticed one of the workers always wore flat shoes that were made from a fabric other than leather, or running shoes, even though both of these things were contrary to the dress code.
> I spoke with my manager about being allowed some leeway under the dress code and was told this was not possible, despite the other person being allowed to do it. I soon found out that many of the other interns felt the same way, and the ones who asked their managers about it were told the same thing as me.
It definitely sounds like management would prefer to force the lone employee to follow dress code than to allow everyone else to break it.
They did, they had lost a leg, which the interns didn't know beforehand.
> management didn't want to share that private information?
Except they shared that information… after firing all the interns:
> We were told to hand in our ID badges and to gather our things and leave the property ASAP. […] just before the meeting ended, one of the managers told us that the worker who was allowed to disobey the dress code was a former soldier who lost her leg and was therefore given permission to wear whatever kind of shoes she could walk in.
I think the interns were excessive in making a petition just for changing the dress code, because that can be interpreted as a hostile move, and the company was excessive in firing them, because that's tyrannical and destroys morale.
Pretty much everyone involved here was being a dick.
So no not everyone involved here was a dick, there was a brat on one side that decided to effectively unionize the internets over shoes and a company that would not be able to function if a petition means that employees not to mention interns get whatever they want.
Day 1 - petition for shoes. Day 3 - petition for bagels. Day 7 - ????
You can't cave to pointless demands of interns especially after you already said no to them, you don't need to give them a justification when your boss says no arguing continuing on arguing with them is usually pointless unless the circumstances changed.
Passing around a petition to force the hands of your managers would never lead to good results, this isn't about employee rights this isn't about unions this is about young people acting up because likely no one to that point ever said no to them because they were too afraid.
I've seen what happens in schools lately at least in higher education where teachers seem to be afraid of their students rather than the other way around, I somehow feel lucky that I was at the borders of this generation before things went out of head and I remember when being rude to a teach or disruptive in class meant a call to my parents and a whole lot of trouble to me.
We somehow went from standing up when the teacher enters the classroom and showing respect to showing the middle finger and getting angry parents defending their kids because they are special.
We went from higher education being a place of critical thought where people were challenged with multiple views and paradigms to a place of safe spaces where students can rally because a teacher hurts their feeling when they talk about touchy subjects.
It seems that over a few decades we went from a society that aimed for the stars and challenged everything to an infantile group that things that cuddling each other is the most important thing in life because everyone is special in their own way.
And I'm really happy that these for lack of a better word "kids" learned this the hard way and early enough that they might still snap out of it, no one owes you anything not even an explanation, life isn't a democracy at best it's a meritocracy you are valued based on what your actively bring to the table not merely because you exist.
But then amusingly, your plaintive comment on "how things are" quickly turns into an impassioned rant about "how things should be" - which funnily enough is just how things used to be. Maybe you learnt the rules, you did the hard yards, you are just starting to get ahead, and now these upstarts are trying to change the rules.
Your whole argument turns on respecting the power structures of the status quo. It seems so horribly entitled to suggest that because the current power structure of organisations support dictator style management, that one cannot try to find ways to undermine that power structure. Organising, complaining, publicly naming and shaming, are just some of the levers to pull to try to readjust the current power structures in your favour.. and why wouldn't you? What manager respects and rewards quiet acquiescence?
But companies are not governments, the voice you have in what's going on in the company is tied directly to your value to said company, or if you are an investor then to just how much of the company you actually own but as most employees are not investors and even those who get stock usually get non-voting stock it doesn't matter.
Employees have voices but they do not make the decisions unless they've been granted the permission to do so. Companies with flat structures and lack of hierarchies don't tend to work out, it's very nice when everyone is equal and everyone is their own boss but it also boils to a mess where no one is responsible for anything and people end up doing what they want instead of what the company needs them to do.
If you actually have concerns about the company and you are debating something that would have an actual impact on the companies outlook every good manager would hear you out and take your opinion under advisement.
Discussing company policy which has nothing to do with how would the company perform is a silly battle. Going against the backs of your managers and stirring up trouble is a stupid thing to do and if you are not in a good position to begin with mostly because you do not represent any substantial value to the company you should not be expected to keep your job.
Over 10 years I've oddly enough worked only for 2 employers, the first one I left mostly because the work I did didn't interest me and when they tried to make me offers to stay including starting a new team/department I told them I appreciate it but i don't think that the company should focus on that field (they did it anyway about 3 months after I left and closed up that department after less than 1.5 years), I've been with my current employer for over 6 years.
And I never had problems telling any of my managers (including the CEO) that they are wrong or that something is incorrect but I do form pretty good arguments and I pick my battles if I need to spend 2000$ more on IT gear for everyone of my teammates I rather build a business case around that than pick a fight about the quality of the beans in the coffee machine. (Also quite important is not to only make a good solid argument, is to do so respectfully and not waste their time over nonsense or things that are out of their control in the first place.)
What the woman in the article did was equal to fighting over italian roast, she didn't even made a business case for why the policy should be changed, no she fought a policy by making a list of people that do not want to wear dress shoes.
If anything has failed her here it's her education system that up till now didn't tought her that a petition is worthless, that if you want to something to change you build a position of substance and argue that one.
Instead she probably got through high school where you can make a petition to bully a teacher that dares to teach you matters that make you uncomfortable and then went to college in which the teachers were so afraid of their students that they probably deserve combat pay.
P.S. I don't think that it's fair to equate the current management style of most companies to dictatorships, if you manage to create a better structure that can be applied to any company larger than 2 people which is substantially different well then you going to make quite a bit of money both because you have created a successful company and that every management school out there would probably love to pay you to lecture there. I'm sure that the likes of the London Business School are already holding their breath.
"Nothing is wrong with the current management structure we have"
Completely indefensible. There is plenty wrong. No small part of what is wrong is to do with the way people's egos and prejudices get turned into policy and power. And there are a whole world of options between dictatorship and direct democracy. Everything else you describe past this point is, once again, a description of how things are, not how they should be. Your experiences are a description of how to function under an inopportune power structure.
Just as it is fair to say that the manager decided that this act was insubordination and needed to be punished by a firing, it is also fair to say that if there is a company policy which does not effect revenue but does effect quality of life, then it is perfectly reasonable to organise with your fellow workers to change it. The only error from the interns here was about not gathering enough power to actually see through the change.
"If anything has failed her here it's her education system that up till now didn't taught her that a petition is worthless, that if you want to something to change you build a position of substance and argue that one."
Fully agree with this, but as a starting point of not understanding the way something works, testing it, finding the edge cases and breaking it down is a good start. Do you not do this with every new tool you use? Besides, the real issue you alluded to before is that they basically didn't get that by signing a petition they were organising. The boss understood this and his over the top response is indicative of why organising needs to be protected in law (in a fair and balanced way).
PS. "I don't think that it's fair to equate the current management style of most companies to dictatorships".
Fair enough, oligarchy then.. When the choice is 'my way or the highway', and when they are telling you how to act and how to dress, how else would you describe it?
An intern decided they were going to try and force a companies hand and was fired. Not much to see here.
if companies fear the actions of their employees, why hire them in the first place.
Sounds like an abusive relationship to me
That's the key. The actual issue at hand probably didn't matter as much as the fact that the lowest of the low had figured out how to work together outside the official hierarchy. That made it a threat not to policy, not even to the people who could have simply said yes or no, but to the hierarchy itself. What happens when you attack the hierarchy? Scorched earth, baby.
Yes, it was a bit entitled of the interns to expect a change in the dress code. A simple "no" would have sufficed if that were the real issue, but it wasn't.
They certainly can, they just don't want to.
Given the current legal and regulatory environment, any good corporate counsel or HR person sees that as a step towards organization, and will stamp it out.
http://www.askamanager.org/2016/06/i-was-fired-from-my-inter...
With the facts given, both the advice columnist and commenters don't seem to be particularly sympathetic to the interns.