News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by lordnacho on Friday July 01, 2016 @06:36AM (#12014986)
There's an ongoing offshoring of certain divisions anyway, something the article alludes to with the Polish IT staff. That kind of thing is Brexit independent.

Michelin stars are not synonymous with having good restaurants. Something like a good steakhouse is not captured my Michelin, which is a very narrow definition of good food. There's also the requirement of variety, which London does extremely well: food from many different cultures, at different price points.

It's also not that clear that Brexit will force finance away from London, which is well entrenched.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by varjag on Friday July 01, 2016 @06:49AM (#12015032)
> Something like a good steakhouse is not captured my Michelin, which is a very narrow definition of good food.

Michelin rates all kinds of places, including sushi bars, Chinese takeaways and steakhouses.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by lordnacho on Friday July 01, 2016 @11:05AM (#12016628)
Yes, but most cities have only a handful of Michelin places. There's no reason to think a city with a few rated restaurants will have more numerous or varied restaurants.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by JumpCrisscross on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:05AM (#12015337)
> Something like a good steakhouse is not captured my Michelin

My hometown steakhouse, Alexander's, carries a Michelin star

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by jakozaur on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:06AM (#12015099)
Yes this is global trend, that a lot of financial people will be moved out of global hubs (like New York, London) and be employed in smaller cities such as Jaksonville, Madrid or Warsaw: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/e1ece4fa-17ac-11e6-bb7d-ee563a5a1c...

Though Brexit hasn't caused this and staying in EU won't prevent it from happening (probably cheaper housing would help the most). However it may accelerate some of this trends.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:08AM (#12015109)
> It's also not that clear that Brexit will force finance away from London, which is well entrenched.

Maybe not all, but a lot.

Over the last few decades London has captured a lot of business that has to be conducted within the EU for regulatory and legal reasons. One example is clearing trades; London clearing houses have captured about 80% of clearing activity from exchanges all across Europe. there are many others. Another is the LSE/Berlin stock exchange merger which was going to see the German exchange hosted and operating from London. That deal will not now happen. Unless London keeps it's financial services 'passporting' arrangements, much business conducted in London will have to be conducted within the EU.

London will not keep it's passporting rights though. The EU is built on four fundamental principles. The free exchange on good, services, capital and workers. These are inextricably linked. Since canceling the free movement of workers was the defining issue of the referendum, we will lose all four. Thus the referendum result in incompatible with membership of the European Economic Area or any similar agreement. Think about it this way. Is it fair for London to have the right to conduct business on behalf of EU businesses in London, but EU workers not to have a right to work in those London businesses? If London businesses can trade in the EU under EU rules, then EU companies should be able to set up business in London under EU rules but won't be able to because London won't be part of the EU. That's how the EU thinks about these things. They would see such an arrangement as a fundamental betrayal of their own citizen's rights.

Finally, according to EU law no member country can negotiate trade agreements with the EU, or other EU countries, or countries outside the EU. That means by law, we cannot even start to negotiate any deals with anyone until _after_ we officially exit the EU, which will probably 2 years after invoking Article 50. These deals can take many years, it took Canada 7 years to negotiate the latest deal and that's still waiting on ratification by all member governments which is likely to take another couple of years. Our economy will be operating under bare minimum WTO rules with no special provisions with anyone anywhere for _years_.

Our best option may be to exit the EU, then immediately apply for European Economic Area membership under default terms. Since we're already compliant with all the regulations, we should be able to fast track that, but it would still probably take 2 years or more during which we will be cut out of large swathes of the EU financial services industry. That business will have to be conducted somewhere, but it won't be in London. It would also mean totally betraying many key issues in the referendum though.

So this all doesn't mean London will stop being a center for finance, but when we talk about a large, double digit percentage of business leaving London it's not because people want to take that business elsewhere, it's because they will be legally obliged to.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by gjm11 on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:31AM (#12015202)
> Since canceling the free movement of workers was the defining issue of the referendum,

I don't think there's any valid inference from "X is what a lot of people thought they would get by voting Leave" to "X is at all likely to happen if/when the UK leaves the EU".

A lot of people thought that by voting Leave they were voting for an extra £350M/week that would go to the NHS. Nigel Farage admitted within an hour of the result that that was never going to happen, and I haven't heard anyone from the Leave camp saying anything different.

A lot of people thought that by voting Leave they were voting for the UK's businesses not to have to comply with EU regulations. But I think the most likely paths forward involve the UK continuing to do that, in order to be able to continue trading on favourable terms with the EU.

A lot of people thought that by voting Leave they were voting for much lower immigration. A bunch of senior people from the Leave camp have made it clear that that is unlikely to happen.

You talk about "totally betraying many key issues in the referendum", but that's already happened, and it's pretty clear that in so far as there was any coherent plan on the Leave side it was always intended to happen.

(... But: A lot of people thought that by voting Leave they were giving a big fuck-you to The Establishment and communicating their dissatisfaction with the state of affairs in the UK. That, they managed just fine.)

I'm not, for the avoidance of doubt, saying that if/when the UK leaves the EU we will still have free exchange of goods, services, capital and workers, or that London will keep its passporting rights. We might well lose those things. But we can't tell that we will just because keeping them would mean not giving Leave voters what they thought they were voting for. Leave voters aren't going to get a lot of what they thought they were voting for, and they never were.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:36AM (#12015483)
Good post, I agree with it all, but on this:

> I'm not, for the avoidance of doubt, saying that if/when the UK leaves the EU we will still have free exchange of goods, services, capital and workers, or that London will keep its passporting rights. We might well lose those things.

We are guaranteed to lose those things at least for some time, because we can't even begin to negotiate getting them back until we're out of the EU.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by gutnor on Friday July 01, 2016 @09:03AM (#12015648)
If the UK negotiate to be part of the EEA within 2 years of activating Article 50, then it will be a smooth transition.

The other unknown that parent did not mention is how hard will the EU make those negotiation. Everybody economical interest is that the EU accept, even politically punishing an ex-member for leaving is going to have consequences in the EU and internationally ( Eurosceptic movement have been boosted by the treatment of the people in Greece and other countries)

However, that's a bit similar that the whole referendum but applied to Europe in general, EU may well take crazy decision. See for example how Junker is talking about the UK as if it has spit in his face (remember that's a narrow victory for Leave mostly based on outright lies), then meeting the Scottish PM forgetting the referendum from 2 years ago and even saying the "Brexit will not be an amicable divorce" and anyone knows that amicable in the context of a divorce does not mean friendly, it is only amicable by comparison with the destructive mess of going through legal proceedings.

edit: The number of EU people living in the UK is more than 3 millions, that's more than the 7 smaller member of the EU, that's more people than the difference between Leave and Remain (disclaimer: that also includes me) That's what make me the most uncomfortable with Junker, he does not care about the people, he just react like a kid because the UK is making him look bad.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @09:32AM (#12015855)
> If the UK negotiate to be part of the EEA within 2 years of activating Article 50, then it will be a smooth transition.

As I have tried to explain, negotiating to join the EEA while still a member of the EU is illegal under EU law. They can only start that negotiation after actually leaving the EU, not after triggering Article 50.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by gutnor on Friday July 01, 2016 @09:57AM (#12016024)
What is your legal status after triggering Article 50 ?

Are you still considered a full member of the EU, meaning you retain all your rights including voting ?

Lots of things are illegal for member state, basically everything that the UK needs to do in the 2 years period is illegal for a member state. Remain have been bad at campaigning but forgetting to say that -actually- they won't be able to initiate any trade negotiation until basically the day all their deals expire seems like a major blunder. If that's indeed the case, the UK will have no choice but not trigger Article 50.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @10:47AM (#12016427)
> Are you still considered a full member of the EU, meaning you retain all your rights including voting ?

Yep.

And to your other points, yes again. Article 50 is a political and economic suicide pill.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by makomk on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:01PM (#12018297)
Absent Article 50, surely everything the UK needs to do in the 2 years period would be legal for an EU state, because Greenland managed it? The trick is/was that EU rules (fairly obviously) allow the EU states to negotiate changes to the agreements binding the EU together, including negotiating an exit whereby one of them leaves the EU but retains some access to the internal markets.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by kintamanimatt on Sunday July 03, 2016 @08:30AM (#12025804)
I'm struggling to find a source for this. Is there anywhere I can read more about this?
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Monday July 04, 2016 @05:09AM (#12029572)
http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36684876

The BBC concludes that the trade commissioner is technically correct, which as we all know is the best kind of correct.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by kintamanimatt on Monday July 04, 2016 @06:37AM (#12029867)
Thank you, that's exactly the kind of source I was looking for. I was completely unable to find anything with the Google queries I was using.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by krona on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:54AM (#12015294)
> A lot of people thought that by voting Leave they were voting for an extra £350M/week that would go to the NHS.

If anyone of voting age believes that, they are undoubtedly an idiot.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by gjm11 on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:20AM (#12015406)
In so far as you're right, I think the evidence is that there are a lot of idiots around. (I wouldn't be so harsh myself.)
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by bodyfour on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:29AM (#12015196)
> Another is the LSE/Berlin stock exchange merger which was going to see the German exchange hosted and operating from London. That deal will not now happen.

DAX is in Frankfurt, not Berlin.

What will be interesting is if the deal does go on, but happens in reverse. It might provide an easier path for LSE-listed companies with a heavy European interest to move to DAX.

> we cannot even start to negotiate any deals with anyone until _after_ we officially exit the EU, which will probably 2 years after invoking Article 50

The two year window post-A50 is specifically for such negotiations. However I'm also pessimistic since I don't think 2 years is enough nor will the EU want to extend it (which would need unanimous support for member states)

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by sveme on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:13AM (#12015379)
> The two year window post-A50 is specifically for such negotiations

Actually not, the two years is just for getting the divorce right. Most experts indicate that a new arrangement can only be found after the divorce is complete. Though all that probably depends on what kind of leverage rEU wants to keep in dealing with the UK.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:41AM (#12015509)
I think before the referendum everyone assumed the 2 years was to negotiate a new deal. Certainly all the pro-Leave campaigners seemed to think so. I'm a bit shocked that the remain camp didn't point this out earlier. It seems to me neither side really had any good idea of what exit actually would involve.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by SyneRyder on Friday July 01, 2016 @09:44AM (#12015938)
The 2 years is also a maximum time period. On that date, the EU treaties no longer apply to the UK, whether negotiations have been concluded or not. The only way to extend that is if the EU unanimously agrees to continue negotiations.

http://www.lisbon-treaty.org/wcm/the-lisbon-treaty/treaty-on...

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by makomk on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:24PM (#12018500)
I think the reason everyone assumed that was because that was the general consensus. The idea that the EU and UK can't negotiate new trading terms until after the 2 years is up seems to be something the European Commission pulled out their ass in the last day or so.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by bodyfour on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:39PM (#12019086)
No, I think you're confused.

What they've said is that they're not willing to negotiate BEFORE the 2 years is TRIGGERED. i.e. they don't want the UK to foot-drag on triggering A50 and prolonging the process indefinitely. Basically, "shit or get off the pot"

The EU position is that if the UK is really going to trigger it, then they should do it as soon as the next PM is installed.

Again, the 2 year window is explicitly for these negotiations. It has not started yet, though.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by makomk on Friday July 01, 2016 @06:38PM (#12020199)
I'm not confused, it's just a mess. No negotiations before the two years is triggered was the original EU position. The EU (or at least their trade comissioner) has come up with a new escalation, claiming that the UK also can't negotiate any post-Brexit trading terms as part of the exit negotiations, that they have to leave the EU first before they can start negotiating on how to trade with the EU: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jul/01/cecilia-malm... This is bad not just for the UK, but also for EU states reliant on trading with the UK.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by gonvaled on Saturday July 02, 2016 @01:57AM (#12021555)
Everybody is pulling things out of assess: Cameron backtracked in his promise to trigger Article 50 immediately after the referendum. And the EU is interpreting fuzzy law however it will please.

That's what happens when goodwill gets trashed, and trust thrown out the window.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by sasvari on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:30AM (#12015448)
just nitpicking: DAX is a stock market index consisting of the 30 major German companies trading on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange [0], so you can't just move to DAX.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DAX

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @09:28AM (#12015817)
Thanks you, I was getting confused between Börse Berlin and Börse Frankfurt. Inexcusable, as I used to work for Equiduct which is owned by Börse Berlin.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by chillydawg on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:15AM (#12015139)
We may simply never leave the EU in the first place. I think parliament won't vote to leave because they're not idiots and we won't leave.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by TheOtherHobbes on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:46AM (#12015269)
Given the last couple of months, I think there's no evidence at all to support the assertion that British politicians aren't idiots.

Ignoring the legalities, the Leave vote crossed the Rubicon.

The EU has always tolerated rather than enjoyed the company of the British establishment. So the EU is happy to see the back of the UK.

The British establishment still thinks it's the 19th century, so it's happy not to have anything to do with the 21st.

The biggest loser will be the City - which is beyond ironic considering the UK has literally spent the last few decades retooling its economy around the City. Now it's about to throw that away.

We're not great at much else. The things we are good at - culture, R&D, farming, tourism - all work better in the EU than out.

In practice, immigration is a meaningless non-issue.

Getting rid of Polish plumbers won't suddenly reveal thousands of competent English plumbers hiding in a cupboard somewhere. It takes time to train people up, and the biggest source of training money has been the EU.

It takes time to rebuild manufacturing, and the biggest source of funding for rebuilding manufacturing has been the EU.

It takes time to improve education, and the biggest source of funding for improved education - especially at postgrad level - has been the EU.

We could move towards becoming a startup economy, but if all the VC money moves to Europe, we won't have the money to do it natively.

The Leave vote is possibly the single most stupid decision in all of British history.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by Kurtz79 on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:40AM (#12015504)
"The EU has always tolerated rather than enjoyed the company of the British establishment. So the EU is happy to see the back of the UK."

This assertion is almost as myopic as those from the Leave campaign.

The UK is one of the richest and most populous countries in the Union, even without considering the repercussions on other members, Brexit will mean a serious blow for the EU in terms of trade loss and budget financing.

I don't think anybody in the EU should be happy of seeing UK's back, regardless of their opinions of its leaders.

It is really a lose-lose situation.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by gonvaled on Saturday July 02, 2016 @02:01AM (#12021561)
The UK has really closed the rubicon. For the EU, enough is enough.

> Brexit will mean a serious blow for the EU in terms of trade loss and budget financing.

The UK can get a norwegian deal: same trade, same budget, no UK blocking.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by eru on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:42AM (#12015518)
> The EU has always tolerated rather than enjoyed the company of the British establishment. So the EU is happy to see the back of the UK.

The Germans and more market oriented Europeans further east liked the British as a counterweight to the statist French, I think.

More importantly, can the EU actually kick out Britain, if Britain decides not to go forward with the leave?

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by SyneRyder on Friday July 01, 2016 @09:50AM (#12015976)
In this Guardian article, they say the only grounds for suspending an EU member are a breach of EU values, such as freedom & democracy. Maybe they could invoke that on grounds of ignoring the referendum, but it might be a precedent the EU don't want to set:

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jun/25/article-50-b...

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @10:48AM (#12016443)
> Maybe they could invoke that on grounds of ignoring the referendum

The referendum is only advisory under British law so they'd have no legal basis on which to do that.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by Kurtz79 on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:47AM (#12015537)
It would like saying that the referendum was useless and the will of the people is meaningless.

It would fuel civil unrest and favor far-right parties.

As much as it pains me, it is not really an option.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @11:35AM (#12016948)
Holland and Denmark both had EU referendums and went back for a second referendum with revised terms which passed. The British people decided to join the EU in a referendum, decided to leave the EU in a referendum and absolutely have the right to vote to stay in it again in another referendum.

The whole process is stupid, but perfectly democratic.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by krona on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:06AM (#12015345)
> These deals can take many years, it took Canada 7 years to negotiate the latest deal and that's still waiting on ratification by all member governments which is likely to take another couple of years.

You seem to be insinuating that is Canada's fault for taking 7 years (actually, 5.5) to negotiate a trade deal with 28 member states simultaneously.

Needless to say, CETA is more likely to be vetoed by either Czech Republic, Bulgaria or Romania, than ratified.

Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by simonh on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:42AM (#12015517)
My apologies for any such implication, I was only intending to point out how long and difficult such negotiations are likely to be. Blame really wasn't in my mind.
Re:After ‘Brexit,’ Finding a New London for the Financial Wo... by gonvaled on Saturday July 02, 2016 @01:49AM (#12021538)
> It's also not that clear that Brexit will force finance away from London, which is well entrenched.

There is a good case for the EU to forbid banks doing EUR operations (at least those intended to trade with The eurozone) outside the EU.

The UK will probably intensify operations with tax heavens (or become a tax heaven itself), so the EU will be well advised to supervise financtial transactions to/from the UK.