News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by girvo on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:41AM (#12014255)
> that view is now in question

Does anyone else find it fascinating that for computers to be considered "safe" they must be as close to 100% as you can get, when the equivalent human drivers have fatal accidents every single day?

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by madaxe_again on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:48AM (#12014292)
I wouldn't say "fascinating" so much as "irritating", as this is more about journalists wanting to get a juicy story where there isn't one, rather than a lesson on human nature.

Statistically, autopilot is orders of magnitude safer than humans.

If there's a story here, it's about how the US doesn't require underrun protection on trucks, thus making them death traps, but that wouldn't be anywhere near as good for circulation as a "rise of the machines, they want to kill you" story.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by arghnoname on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:05AM (#12014351)
I don't think we can say statistically whether it is safer than humans right now or not.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by madaxe_again on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:45AM (#12014467)
150,000,000 miles on autopilot, one fatality. Humans, it's 66,000,000 miles per fatality, in the US. Admittedly the sample is small, but still, it suggests an advantage over humans.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by arghnoname on Friday July 01, 2016 @08:18PM (#12020710)
Apples and oranges. The statistic you cite is all cars and roads, as far as I'm aware. High end vehicles with comparable safety features on roads where autopilot is likely to be engaged is more comparable.

I wouldn't be surprised if autopilot is safer, but I think it is overstating things to say this is a statistical fact.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by random_upvoter on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:39AM (#12014446)
One problem of automation is that when an algorithm fails it reverts to 100% stupid mode, without any fallback. In this particular case the program didn't understand there was a truck, so the car drove full speed into the truck. As a result, the outcome of accidents with AI driving, while rare, will probably tend to be rather gruesome and this might lead to some really bad reaction.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kctess5 on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:07AM (#12014359)
"Statistically"

Source? I hear that it is imperfect software.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by taneq on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:49AM (#12014294)
What's really interesting is how, once accepted, the computer becomes 100% accurate by default and anything conflicting with it is automatically wrong.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by chriswarbo on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:37AM (#12014440)
That quote's taken from the tl;dr-equivalent at the start of the article. It seems to be summarising the following, from further down, which I think is perfectly reasonable:

> Karl Brauer, an analyst with the auto research firm Kelley Blue Book, said the accident served as a signal that the technology might not be as advanced and ready for the market as some proponents have suggested.

> "This is a bit of a wake-up call," Mr. Brauer said. "People who were maybe too aggressive in taking the position that we're almost there, this technology is going to be in the market very soon, maybe need to reassess that."

I think that's perfectly reasonable, e.g. it may take 5 or 10 years to reach some kind of approved minimum safety level, especially since such safety approval standards/processes are still being developed. Just because Tesla's cars already have an "auto-pilot mode" doesn't mean the technology's ready for widespread deployment.

Regarding "as close to 100% as you can get", that's not stated in the article. Instead, it says:

> The federal traffic safety agency is nearing the release of a new set of guidelines and regulations regarding the testing of self-driving vehicles on public roads. They are expected to be released in July.

> At a recent technology conference in Novi, Mich., the agency's leader, Mark Rosekind, said self-driving cars should at least be twice as safe as human drivers to result in a significant reduction in roadway deaths. "We need to start with two times better," Mr. Rosekind said. "We need to set a higher bar if we expect safety to actually be a benefit here."

Again, I think that's reasonable. While a fully-automated road system would probably be safer than human drivers, we're not going to get an overnight switch; the harder problem is the transition, with manually- and autonomously-driven cars coexisting.

It's not just a case of swapping out more and more cars, since self-driving cars will behave and interact in different ways (as an obvious example, looking at the occupants won't give you any information about intentions/gestures/etc.); hence it's worth waiting until a threshold higher than break-even is reached before beginning the transition.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by puranjay on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:48AM (#12014289)
If you actually replace all human drivers with all computer drivers, I'm pretty sure we'd hit the 100% safety mark.

I can't even imagine the resistance to self-driving cars once they're actually viable. Who even enjoys driving on city roads anymore? Or on highways? I drove on American freeways and it was mind-numbingly dull. Just acres of concrete all along the road with nothing interesting to see or do.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by stephenr on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:57AM (#12014325)
> Who even enjoys driving on city roads anymore? Or on highways? I drove on American freeways and it was mind-numbingly dull. Just acres of concrete all along the road with nothing interesting to see or do.

Who even enjoys writing code any more? It's just line after line of characters on a screen, with nothing interesting to see or do.

Yet another american claim that "I don't like something, therefore no one else must like it either", with the usual view that because something is terrible in America, it must be terrible everywhere.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by puranjay on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:56AM (#12014512)
I'm actually Indian. 160,000 of us died in road accidents last year.

Driving has now become a choice between the dull, automated driving I did in America, or the mad, chaotic rush I see on Indian roads.

Neither of these are enjoyable or even particularly safe

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by stephenr on Friday July 01, 2016 @04:14AM (#12014569)
Looking at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r..., India has 16.6 deaths per 100K inhabitants per year, which is close to what you stated.

Keep in mind, you're just below the world average (17) at that value. So while Im sure Indian roads are as bad as their reputation, there are worse.

I live in Thailand, on the same list (when sorted by deaths by 100K inhabitants), we're #2 (right behind Libya), with 36.2; the deaths per year for here was 24K, based on a population of just 65 million.

My point is, I know what it's like to drive on dangerous roads, and I still dispute your claim that driving is either boring or dangerous.

Even driving across the Eyre highway from Adelaide to Perth (~2700km), part of which is the '90 mile straight' - a section of road with 0 bends for 145km - is something I can look back and be glad I've done it.

If you personally don't enjoy driving, or feel unsafe driving, you personally can take actions based on that, such as taking a bus or taxi, or car pooling etc.

But don't somehow think that because your homeland has a reputation for bad roads, and America has apparently boring roads, that no one else on the planet enjoys driving.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kbart on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:52AM (#12014304)
"If you actually replace all human drivers with all computer drivers"

I drive motorcycle (and enjoy that), I doubt autopilot will come to those anytime soon..

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kagamine on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:55AM (#12014320)
There are many other vehicles on the road also needing a human to drive them, tractors, heavy machinery, buses (that are not part of a regular, pre-defined route) ++.

In the future though, it will always be your fault, because you are one person trying to prove an accident was not your fault against a big-money company. Good luck.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kbart on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:01AM (#12014337)
"In the future though, it will always be your fault, because you are one person trying to prove an accident was not your fault against a big-money company."

That's why I always wear videoregistrator on my helmet. It paid off for itself many times already.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by leni536 on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:06AM (#12014356)
>tractors

I would expect that it's quite easy to autopilot a tractor on the road. They already use autopilot in the field.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kagamine on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:09AM (#12014367)
It will be decades before farm machinery is replaced by modern tech. Decades. I would like HN users to very much stop dismissing any discussion on the topic of automated vehicles with glib reactions devoid of thought.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by Animats on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:34AM (#12014434)
Self-driving is a common feature on modern tractors. It's been available for almost 15 years.[1] Even when there's an operator in the cab, it's common to have automatic steering to keep the rows precise. The usual setup involves a pseudolite on the farm as a local reference for GPS correction.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7xc45LyhoU

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kagamine on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:17AM (#12015145)
Perhaps on modern farm equipment, but tractors last for decades and many of the tractors in rural Europe aren't even fuel injected. It will be many years until tractors and combine harvesters and the like are swapped out for newer equipment.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by Animats on Friday July 01, 2016 @01:01PM (#12017820)
There are retrofits. "If it has a steering wheel, we can do it."[1]

[1] https://www.precisionfarmingdealer.com/articles/2211-retrofi...

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by Animats on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:05AM (#12014352)
Anthony Levandowski, one of the key people behind Google's self-driving car effort, built a self-driving motorcycle for the 2005 DARPA Grand Challenge. It's now in the Smithsonian.[1]

[1] http://americanhistory.si.edu/collections/search/object/nmah...

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kbart on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:09AM (#12014369)
Nice, but robot-on-two-wheels is not quite the same as motorcycle autopiloting with human on top, who doesn't sit still and doesn't handle sudden movements well.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by croon on Friday July 01, 2016 @06:56AM (#12015058)
Though to be fair I absolutely don't see the point in sitting on a motorcycle unless you're driving it. It's not like you can occupy your time with anything else than leaning over to hold the handlebars.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by Ma8ee on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:57AM (#12014324)
I'm fine with that. Motorcycle riders kill almost exclusively themselves.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by lostlogin on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:13AM (#12014378)
To add an actual data point, in New Zealand bike rider fatalities are not the motor bike riders fault about 30% of the time and in non fatal crashes the figure is about 40%. www.transport.govt.nz/assets/Uploads/Research/Documents/Motorcycles-15.pdf
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by Ma8ee on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:44AM (#12015260)
My point was not that motorcycle drivers are worse drivers than car drivers. It's probably the other way around. But with computer drivers very soon much safer than human drivers, I'm very eager to get all trucks and cars driven by computers because it significantly reduce the risk of me or someone I care about being killed in traffic. But if someone wants to continue to steer their motorcycle themselves, I'm fine with that because it is unlikely that I'll be seriously hurt in a collision between my car and a motorcycle.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kbart on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:22AM (#12014403)
"in New Zealand bike rider fatalities are not the motor bike riders fault about 30% of the time and in non fatal crashes the figure is about 40%."

In Lithuania it's even worse, around 60% (2014 data).

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by lagadu on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:58AM (#12014330)
Not 100% because we'd still have accidents caused by sudden mechanical failures but there's no 100% effective, reasonable way around those.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by te_chris on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:45AM (#12014280)
I find it more fascinating that you don't understand why people would expect that.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by victorhooi on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:48AM (#12014291)
Please explain why you would expect it then?
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by bnegreve on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:08AM (#12014362)
Systematic bugs in self driving cars would be disastrous.

So if you see a Tesla car crashing on days with white sky, you want to know whether this can happens to you as well.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by girvo on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:59AM (#12014331)
I'd love to know your thoughts on the topic?
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by te_chris on Friday July 01, 2016 @05:40AM (#12014813)
I don't really have any,apart from that the adoption of autonomous vehicles is going to be slower and take longer than people anticipate. Human traffic systems are complicated and not easily modelled, and humans are not easily reassured when events like this happen. While statistically people may be safer with an agent driving, most people don't crash most of the time, so they're more confident when they're in control than when someone else is.
Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by kagamine on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:50AM (#12014298)
Likewise, human drivers manage to avoid accidents every single day by paying attention, reading traffic signals and reacting to a situation.

Computers have to be 100% safe because self-driving cars take control away from the user. And where does the blame lie in an accident? With the owner of the vehicle, the 'operator' at the time of the accident, the 3rd party developers who were contracted by Tesla/Nissan/BMW, or the car company themselves? Getting customer service and a dealership to admit responsibility for parts failure as it is today is near impossible.

It's fine for people to be be pro self-driving cars but it is wrong to dismiss any and every criticism of an emerging technology on that basis alone.

Re:Self-Driving Tesla Was Involved in Fatal Crash, U.S. Says by jakobegger on Friday July 01, 2016 @03:23AM (#12014409)
Where the blame lies is a question that can probably only be answered on a case by case basis in the courts.