News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by kstrauser on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:03PM (#12010465)
Saturday Night Live has been running parody advertising purporting to originate from real organizations for decades. I'm not a lawyer, but no one here has satisfactorily explained why this group running a fake NRA ad is a different animal from SNL running a fake McDonald's ad.

Also, assume nothing about my political views. I'm not an NRA member, but I have spent a couple of nice Saturdays shooting skeet with my son and his Boy Scout troop. My position would be exactly the same if this were a Planned Parenthood parody or if it spoofed any other politics-heavy organization.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by electrograv on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:45PM (#12010766)
Satire is and should continue to be protected by Freedom of Speech, but you should understand there are lines satire can cross to become libel, and illegal.

When a corporate or person's name/trademark is used explicitly and intentionally, freedom of speech does not automatically inherently protect the publication or media. In such a case, damages (if any) are resolved on a case-by-case basis, generally depending on the content and how indistinguishable it is from the real thing (and whether it's potentially damaging).

Saturday Night Live and The Onion are protected because both are widely known and clearly labeled as comedy/satire content. Neither is the case for this video, and as a result it's extremely likely they would fail at defending a lawsuit from the NRA if they did decide to prosecute.

P.S. My post assumed nothing about anyone's political views. The planned parenthood example was meant to provide balance via an analogical example from the other stereotypical political side.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by splawn on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:57PM (#12011204)
Its such delicious satire too. It has forced a lobby group that has an unyielding view point on the 2nd amendment to clash directly with the 1st amendment. Which in turn causes me to question my own unyielding view on the 1st amendment... Hilarious and brilliant stuff IMO, assuming this was all in the design of the satire.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by hga on Thursday June 30, 2016 @04:07PM (#12011266)
It has forced a lobby group that is perceived to have an unyielding view point on the 2nd amendment

The NRA's stance is very much exaggerated, e.g. every piece of Federal anti-gun legislation passed with their approval until the 1994 AW ban, and since the passage of the Brady Bill the year before, which eventually set up the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS), their baby, you might say, they've supported and are right now supporting legislation that uses the NICS to prevent people from buying guns from FFLs (gun stores).

To cover a bit more of their relationship with the 1st Amendment (which after looking at the Wayback Machine copies of the website, I'm not so sure is implicated, e.g. it does not come off as satire unless you know enough about the NRA's stolid style), they fiercely opposed McCain-Feingold, since it banned a lot of their political speech before elections (this was resolved in their favor in the Citizens United case).

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by Kephael on Thursday June 30, 2016 @09:46PM (#12013332)
This doesn't look like satire, they've even gone and created nrapress.org which mimics the actual NRA-ILA site. It is not obvious satire and the press release page looks absolutely authentic because they've ripped the NRA-ILA site design and are redirecting to the NRA-ILA site.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by splawn on Thursday June 30, 2016 @10:20PM (#12013481)
I suggest you watch their movie. This is what they do. Imo, its satire at its best and purest.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3s_pJw7OAU

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by whyenot on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:59PM (#12010867)
I would think a video from The Yes Men would be easily identifiable as parody based on their past actions. Even if you are not aware of who they are, it's easy to find with a quick Google search.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by simbalion on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:23PM (#12010988)
That's not a fair assumption, I've never heard of the Yes Men for example.

I'd assume they knew what they were doing, as these sorts of concerns are often on the mind of satirists. They should have included a disclaimer or something making it clear that the video was a parody.

It's reasonable to think they may have been counting on short attention spans and ignorance to spread false rumors about NRA positions.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by gozur88 on Thursday June 30, 2016 @08:46PM (#12013062)
You're assuming people will actually do that search. If it's sufficiently misleading they may assume it's legit.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by hga on Thursday June 30, 2016 @09:11PM (#12013168)
And that doesn't work for the web site, which is, after all, the only thing taken down. No mention of The Yes Men, it really tries to look legit and claims an NRA copyright etc. Even the whois info for the domain dead ends at the Whois Privacy Corp.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by emodendroket on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:52PM (#12011172)
What about the Jerry Falwell thing?
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by Fogest on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:25PM (#12010628)
But are they saying that it is paid for by McDonalds to run such an ad? Because that makes it sound like McDonalds would support the ad. But if they are just parodying a McDonalds commercial and not saying McDonalds paid for it then it is very different.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by kstrauser on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:32PM (#12010682)
I'm asking seriously: what makes that different from flashing the McDonald's logo and implying that McD's endorses it? Or Mad Magazine doing the same, for that matter? Or The Onion "quoting" political figures (eg http://www.theonion.com/blogpost/if-i-could-be-just-complete... which purports to be an op-ed written by Hillary Clinton, complete with byline and photo, with no disclaimer to the contrary).
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by squeaky-clean on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:20PM (#12010973)
Most of it is context and how a reasonable person would interpret it. Fake ads are commonplace on SNL (they aren't always for real brands), they use comedians known for being on SNL, and are often very silly.

No reasonable person watching SNL would see the Jim Carrey Lincoln MKC commercials and believe that Allstate and Lincoln were really airing a joint commercial in which Jim Carrey runs over Keenan Thompson in his Lincoln. But if they started airing those outside of SNL during regular commercial breaks things would probably be different.

It's the same thing with that Onion article. Anyone familiar with The Onion knows it's parody, and anyone not familiar will find notice pretty quickly. The article also doesn't make any false assertions or libelous claims against Clinton. It's just using her image to parody the idea of her pandering to an audience.

Also, less of a purely legal reason but, you only get in trouble if the other person doesn't like it. Brands are usually very happy to have their stuff parodied in a lighthearted way. Weird Al always asks permission before parodying a song (even though legally he does not need to), and almost never gets a no. More often than not, artists are incredibly excited to be parodied by Weird Al. To use the SNL Lincoln example again, SNL's fake advertisements had many times more views online than Lincoln's advertisements. All for free (for Lincoln)! They're getting people to watch for a minute or two a video all about the new Lincoln car, and they're not making fun of the vehicle or the company, just the strange acting in their real commercials. Jim Carrey never says "the acceleration in this thing sucks" or "the windows are too tinted, so I can't pay attention to the road", he just goes off on weird existential musings while twiddling his fingers.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by strictnein on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:44PM (#12010757)
As mentioned in another comment, a key component is the likelihood of significant confusion by those that see the content.

When you watch SNL or read The Onion and Mad Magazine, the vast majority of people understand that they're watching/reading satire.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by Fogest on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:59PM (#12010865)
As the other user who replied to you said, that is very different. When I am watching TV on a comedy network I am not confused thinking this is actually a legit McDonalds commercial while I am watching a comedy skit on a comedy network.

Now when there is a full blown website and youtube video claiming association with a company that is whole different story. How do I clearly know that the company did not actually pay for it? Am I just suppose to guess because there is no way the company would do that? That isn't how it works.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by gpm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @04:02PM (#12011240)
> Am I just suppose to guess because there is no way the company would do that? That isn't how it works.

Well yes actually, it is. But you will notice that this was posted on the Yes Men youtube channel, which is well known at this point, so you don't even have to.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by Fogest on Thursday June 30, 2016 @04:06PM (#12011257)
And that may be why the video is not removed, but the website itself is what I am questioning.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by gpm on Thursday June 30, 2016 @04:18PM (#12011339)
That's a fair response to the second portion of my comment.

Still, the answer to "am I supposed to guess" is "yes". That's the point of parody.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by mikeyouse on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:29PM (#12010660)
It literally isn't any different. Satire is satire. Protected in the US.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by Fogest on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:57PM (#12010857)
It "literally" is different. It isn't satire unless it is obviously satire. A comedy network is pretty obviously doing comedy. A random youtube video and webpage all faking being supported by a company is very different.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by mikeyouse on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:02PM (#12010878)
I take it you're not a lawyer?

From the DC Circuit of the US Court of Appeals;

But it is the nature of satire that not everyone “gets it” immediately. For example, when Daniel Defoe first published The Shortest Way with the Dissenters, an anonymous satirical pamphlet against religious persecution, it was initially welcomed by the church establishment Defoe sought to ridicule. See JAMES SUTHERLAND,ENGLISH SATIRE 83–84 (1958). Similarly, Benjamin Franklin’s “Speech of Miss Polly Baker,” a fictitious news story mocking New England’s harsh treatment of unwed mothers, was widely republished in both England and the United States as actual news. See MAX HALL, BENJAMIN FRANKLIN & POLLY BAKER:THE HISTORY OF A LITERARY DECEPTION 33–35, 87–88 (1960).

Or a little more entertainingly written:

The First Amendment Protects Satire Even When Reckless, Stupid, Or Ideology-Addled People Fall For It

(https://popehat.com/2013/11/26/the-first-amendment-protects-...)

Satire Is Satire Even When People Fall For It, Mr. Jarvis

(https://popehat.com/2016/04/27/satire-is-satire-even-when-pe...)

The Courts have found that Satire and Parody have extremely broad First Amendment protections -- for good reason.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by squeaky-clean on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:44PM (#12011120)
Satire is still satire even when people fall for it, but not when it is intentionally misleading people. The sharethesafety.org website looks very legitimate. It doesn't have a parody or satire disclaimer anywhere I can find, it includes copyright information for the NRA, links to the real NRA and Smith & Wesson websites, and the style mimics the real NRA website exactly.

I haven't seen the video yet (at work), I'd assume it's very tongue-in-cheek, but the video was never taken down. But my first impression of the website, without knowing it is parody, is that this is a real project.

It even links to a "press release" on nrapress.org, which does not seem to be a real NRA website. Though all the links on nrapress.org point to nra.org or nraila.org, which are official.

Your links agree with the parent comment.

From the first:

> (2) the test for whether something is satire protected by the First Amendment, rather than a false assertion of fact that may be defamatory, is whether a reasonable person would take it as an assertion of fact given the entire context.

From the second

> In deciding whether something could reasonably be taken as an assertion of fact rather than satire, courts look to what an audience familiar with the publication and players would understand. Said the Court:

> The article’s primary intended audience — that is, readers of “The Politics Blog” — would have been familiar with Esquire’s history of publishing satirical stories, with recent topics ranging from Osama Bin Laden’s television-watching habits to “Sex Tips from Donald Rumsfeld.”

and

> Could there be satire that is unethical because it is genuinely deceptive? I suppose so. (Hopefully not here.) But I think it would have to be a genuine attempt to deceive by a publication not known for satire

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by mikeyouse on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:59PM (#12011218)
The EFF disagrees and already defended The Yes Men against a similar takedown request / lawsuit:

https://www.eff.org/cases/chamber-commerce-v-servin

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by squeaky-clean on Thursday June 30, 2016 @06:07PM (#12012204)
Thanks for the link. Since the case was dropped, I guess we can't know for certain. It looks like all pages on the parody website have been removed, though there are screenshots in the motion to dismiss. It seems like just the pages that look like fake press releases.

I generally agree with the EFF, but not in this case. Just my personal opinion, but I can see how the text of the fake press releases are parody, but not the website. The quality of the site obscures the parody. I think the Hillary Clinton article on The Onion linked above is funny. I wouldn't find it funny if it were hosted on h-clinton2016.com

The main claims were basically that the chamber of commerce parody is not a substitute for the real thing, and the parody is non-commercial. This isn't entirely the same case. This is an entire landing page made to look like a new initiative. Having a "Store coming soon" advertisements and sign up form also make this different.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by Fogest on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:55PM (#12011194)
Is this really satire or a parody though? Could almost view this as defamation. Is it really being satirical, or is it designed to make a company look stupid and like a joke? I am seeing this as being different than satire or parody like a site like the onion would do. If the onion went and created a site that looked very legitimate, linked to the real companies sites, and no where mentioned it was fake then I would also have a problem with that. But they don't. All of their jokes are within the onion, not spread across fake sites pretending to be from other companies.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by kstrauser on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:44PM (#12011125)
Are you a lawyer? I've seen several conflicting arguments and I'm not sure whose authority to appeal to.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by mikeyouse on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:56PM (#12011199)
The EFF already defended this very same group (The Yes Men) against the very same actions when they satirized the Chamber of Commerce (an advocacy group for big businesses):

https://www.eff.org/cases/chamber-commerce-v-servin

I think they're pretty trustworthy as far as free-speech advocacy goes. There wasn't a ruling but eventually the Chamber of Commerce dropped the suit.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by lostlogin on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:57PM (#12010859)
I think you are using literally correctly. This might be the only example I've seen in years.
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by snowwrestler on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:32PM (#12011048)
> I'm not a lawyer, but no one here has satisfactorily explained why this group running a fake NRA ad is a different animal from SNL running a fake McDonald's ad.

Maybe because:

> Saturday Night Live has been running parody advertising purporting to originate from real organizations for decades.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by mkane848 on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:43PM (#12011118)
So is the implication is that if $SaturdayNightLiveRipoff that just started filming this year decides to do something similar, they don't get the same leniency simply because they're new?
Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by evan_ on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:52PM (#12011169)
I think the point the GP is trying to make is that when you watch SNL you know that there are going to be satirical commercials.

If you took a commercial parody from SNL and played it unaltered during prime time with no introduction, you would probably get in trouble even though the content hasn't changed.

Re:NRA complaint takes down Surge's 38,000 websites by mohaine on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:50PM (#12011158)
And they don't use real names. The Parody would be just good if it said "Paid for by the National Gun Association ...."