News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by WalterBright on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @07:34PM (#12005638)
Part of being a free market is people can set up a business any way they like. For example, there are neither legal nor regulatory barriers to setting up a commune (communes were popular in the US around 1900). People can set up workers' cooperatives. And your idea can be done if you can organize a bunch of like-minded individuals to try it. You don't need to change society to do it. Just do it.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by StanislavPetrov on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @07:52PM (#12005714)
>Part of being a free market

We are talking about the United States, not a free market. In the United States, the stated policy of the central bank (hint: free markets have no central banks that control interest rates and pick winners and losers) for the last 8 years is to inflate housing prices. The FED and the big banks still have trillions of dollars of worthless derivatives on their books that they have not "marked to market" because they are derived from mortgages on homes that are underwater. The FED has taken over 5 trillion dollars onto its balance sheet in the last 8 years in order to artificially inflate housing prices (not including off-balance sheet loans, guarantees, and other tangible efforts taken to prop up banks and home prices).

This is the opposite in a free market. In a free market, housing prices would plummet with demand and credit availability, and would reach an equilibrium with income. This is impossible in our centrally controlled economy that runs on debt service in which even a small bump in interest rates or a small drop in assets prices will cause the whole scheme to fall apart.

Edit: The Downvotes without replies are somewhat amusing. I can't decide if its out of ignorance of the financial system on the part of those who read the hacker news, or cognitive dissonance. I suspect a mix of both. I welcome anyone who thinks any of the above is inaccurate to chime in.

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by sremani on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @08:59PM (#12005945)
That is quite a good way of putting things in perspective about Fed and free money building up the asset bubble, which is only made worse by stricter zoning laws and NIMBY.

As far as downvotes go, HN leans left, that is not news, any conservative or libertarian views will collect the usual down votes. Strangely it happens in bunches too.

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by StanislavPetrov on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @09:16PM (#12005988)
It isn't a left or right issue, its a reality issue. We in the USA do not have a free market, where prices are determined by market forces. Whether or not this is a good or bad thing is a completely different debate. The FED does not hide the fact that it buys MBS (mortgage backed securities) to prop up the housing market. This is the opposite of a free market (and only one of many ways the market is controlled). This isn't up for debate among members of the reality-based community.

https://www.newyorkfed.org/markets/ambs/ambs_faq.html

>The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) directed the Open Market Trading Desk (the Desk) at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York to purchase additional MBS and longer-term Treasury securities (see http://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/fomccalendars.h... for the most recent FOMC statement). The FOMC also directed the Desk to maintain its existing policies of reinvesting principal payments from the Federal Reserve’s holdings of agency debt and agency MBS in agency MBS and of rolling over maturing Treasury securities at auction. The FOMC noted that these actions should put downward pressure on longer-term interest rates, support mortgage markets, and help to make broader financial conditions more accommodative.

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by dpc59 on Thursday June 30, 2016 @03:31AM (#12007095)
If you lean left you shouldn't be arguing for rent collecting oligopolies.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by progressive_dad on Friday July 01, 2016 @02:10PM (#12018379)
I believe the standard "party line" on housing costs would be something akin to Sweden. Purchasing a property for the explicit purpose of renting it is de-facto barred. Its not illegal but must be approved by your local tenant/owner association (like a condo board or home owner's association). This has the net effect of raising rents, making it extremely difficult to rent in the first place, while keeping home ownership within reach for nearly everyone due to depressing any kind of housing bubble or gentrification through property acquisition and flipping.

https://www.justlanded.com/english/Sweden/Sweden-Guide/Prope...

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by dv_dt on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:31PM (#12010202)
There is no canonical free market. Free markets require enforcement of property rights (otherwise people can run around taking each others property). Once you have enforcement of property rights - there is some form of government. Once you start talking about all the various cases for property rights enforcement - you end up with various rules to try to manage fuzzy cases and protect property.

You could claim that it's not a free market with the set of freedoms or policies that you'd like to have implemented, but to claim that the US is not a free market just because the Fed has taken some action seems like a fallacy to me. (BTW I agree with you in questioning the wisdom of that particular set of Fed actions..)

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by naveen99 on Thursday June 30, 2016 @02:47AM (#12006987)
The free market bit was irrelevant. You are being downvoted for arguing an irrelevant point. Weather free or not, communes are possible in the us, which is what you wanted.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by WalterBright on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @09:09PM (#12005968)
That doesn't have anything to do with setting up a commune, cooperative, or collective building ownership.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by gajjanag on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @10:37PM (#12006243)
How about being able to build taller buildings in order to support higher population densities in major cities?

Most cities in the US have all kinds of zoning regulations that prevent cities from reaching higher population densities: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11918230. For example, there are quite a few livable cities in the world supporting > 15,000 per sq km, most cities in the US hardly reach half that amount.

This is definitely not a free market phenomenon; I am pretty sure that in a free market (or even a market with rationally determined, not NIMBY based regulations), there would be increases in population density of major cities in the US.

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by PopsiclePete on Thursday June 30, 2016 @11:36AM (#12009266)
The NIMBY phenomenon is strong in America.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by Retra on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @07:49PM (#12005706)
You need to change society to succeed at it in any obvious way.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by virmundi on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @08:47PM (#12005909)
I down voted you and here's why. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation This is a strong coop in Spain. It is one of the most diverse. It is one of the largest corps in Spain. It is also Christian in origin. Given the general Christian background of the Western world, it's one of the most natural.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by Kinnard on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @07:36PM (#12005646)
Where is this free market you refer to?!
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by xrange on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @07:42PM (#12005678)
What would be the (say 3) biggest hurdles you see to kicking off that type of venture (and maybe give us hints as to how a freer market minimizes those)?
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by vacri on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @08:05PM (#12005766)
One would be the non-standard equity breakdown which might make getting a mortgage loan from a bank more difficult.

Another would be keeping people 'in the system' long-term, otherwise it doesn't really work (if the original landlord tires of it, what stops them from 'just reverting' to the old system?)

It's an interesting idea, but it'd be hard to test out.

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by WalterBright on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @09:13PM (#12005982)
> from a bank

There are multitudes of banks with different policies. There are multitudes of other ways to get capital. In the D community, we used Kickstarter to fund the first D conference, for example.

> what stops them

That's what contracts are for. Contracts are a central feature of a free market.

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by vacri on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:19AM (#12006729)
> Contracts are a central feature of a free market.

So, you don't think that it's a hurdle that your rent has to be split 20% to the previous tenant, 10% to the tenant before that, 15% to the tenant before that, 8% to the tenant before that, 33% to the tenant before that, and 20% to the tenant before that? Who is doing the legwork in tracking these tenants down? What happens when the combined 'equity' goes over 100%? When does the landlord bug out? Who wants to keep tabs on their 8% equity of a rental home that they occupied for a year five years ago, along with paying 8% of the upkeep for any repairs or administrative work? Who wants to chase up all the previous tenants and get them to cough up the money? How much time does that person waste if even one previous tenant won't pay (or can't)? If the original owner wants to sell the property, what happens to the tenants with equity? What if they have more equity than the original owner, can they force the owner not to sell? Can they force the owner to a reserve price? Does a new tenant have to make a contract with the owner and all previous tenants? Is there a new kind of corporate body to handle this new form of renting? Are the contracts around this new way of renting going to be easy enough for the general public to understand, or are they going to provide plenty of loopholes for sharks to operate?

I think that's enough to classify as 'a hurdle', and people need to be in the system long-term and at scale to figure out how it's going to work well. Hand-waving that problem away with "meh, contracts" doesn't solve the long-term issues.

Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by WalterBright on Thursday June 30, 2016 @01:30AM (#12006763)
None of those are barriers that the free market or the government throws in your path. For an unusual business plan, expect to have to put in the work to figure out the details.
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by vacri on Thursday June 30, 2016 @04:38AM (#12007301)
The original question was "what are some hurdles to doing this?", with a secondary "how does the free market help solve them?". It wasn't "how does the free market (or government) stop you from doing this?".
Re:Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents by WalterBright on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @07:38PM (#12005654)
It's free enough in the US to do all these things. As I said, there have been many communes in the US.