News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by jordanb on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:11AM (#12002095)
> attaching a green card to the diplomas of foreign-born students earning STEM degrees.

HAH! I knew this was going to be in there.

Of course it's a gigantic bailout to the universities. STEM grad programs are already full of foreign nationals trying to get a slot in the advanced degree H1-B track.

This would absolutely turbocharge that: buy a degree from whatever fourth rate American university for $xxx,xxx and value is less in the degree than the golden ticket that comes attached.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by ak217 on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:20AM (#12002183)
That is a pretty myopic thing to say. One of the biggest issues for the US higher ed system is that foreign students who receive an education here often can't stay or have to face ridiculous hurdles. In many thousands of cases, you are also wrong about buying the degree: research grants to universities fund those students' tuition and stipends, in exchange for good work.

Address the inflation of university budgets at the source of the problem. Rejecting highly educated, successful foreign nationals who we have already invested money in and who want to stay here and be productive in the workforce is one of the stupidest things this country currently does. Rejecting this proposal because you think it's a bailout for universities is cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by jordanb on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:31AM (#12002276)
Currently foreign students have to weigh the possibility that they won't be able to stay against the cost of the program. And nonetheless American programs are absolutely full of foreign nationals and this is especially true of grad programs which gives one an H1-B priority.

If this program gets created universities will absolutely not have to address the inflation of their budgets because it'll be raining out of state tuition payers.

If, on the other hand, universities went back to educating mostly local kids with tax subsidies then they'd have to face a stark reckoning about their mushrooming budgets and we may have to have a national discussion about education funding. None of this sounds good to Hillary Clinton so instead she'll just try to open the sluice gates wider.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by tassl on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @12:13PM (#12002611)
As somebody that has gone through the whole process (MS, PhD, OPT, H1B, Green Card), granting green cards to diplomas of is a big mistake. While the current system adds some level of stress to the worker, I have yet to find (surely there are) a valid foreigner with some STEM degree that could not stay in the US if he wanted to. This is true for most "bad" students that I know. On the other hand, some students that trick the system (most of them, in my experience [1], chinese and indian) have had trouble to stay.

The current system gives you up to 29 months in OPT after a STEM degree (if I recall correctly, 12 + 17). During that time you can work towards H1B and Green Card; while H1B is tight with a employer, you can change employers with it. Now, if the Green Card is given to any STEM diploma, you will have a mass of unprepared, unethical students applying for and obtaining diplomas they don't deserve (because obtaining a diploma is not that difficult in the US). And I do believe this will create tensions later on with nationals.

[1] This is obviously biased. My experience in the university (and outside of it) is that there are networks that facilitate entry on universities, "success" in universities [2,3], and in interviews processes in companies. I have seen exams for the previous 10 years solved with detailed explanation; homeworks and all solutions for specific books solved, etc... with this only available to specific group. I have not seen this happening with people of other countries.

[2] http://www.cnn.com/2015/07/12/asia/china-education-agencies/

[3] http://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/college-c...

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by throwawaysocks on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:33AM (#12002291)
> In many thousands of cases, you are also wrong about buying the degree: research grants to universities fund those students' tuition and stipends, in exchange for good work.

I think your parent was primarily referring to masters programs, not phd programs.

FWIW I am pro-immigration in general, but I do worry about expensive diploma mill masters programs becoming a way for wealthy immigrants to buy preferential treatment. It's a legitimate concern with any "masters == green card" scheme.

That said, anyone who opposes such a scheme for Ph.D. students or for highly quality masters programs is insane.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by davidw on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:38AM (#12002336)
> FWIW I am pro-immigration in general, but I do worry about expensive diploma mill masters programs becoming a way for wealthy immigrants to buy preferential treatment. It's a legitimate concern with any "masters == green card" scheme.

Of course the answer to that is probably to open things up more in general, so you're not creating these perverse incentives and special channels, but it's difficult to do that. People get incensed because they worked so hard to be born in the US and consequently don't think others should have the same opportunities.

http://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2014/06/the-optimal-number...

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by jordanb on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:37AM (#12002333)
Because we have such a serious of shortage of people with PHDs?

https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-B9Hv9N6bi1w/V2WBuW96arI/AAAAAAAAE...

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by throwawaysocks on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:44AM (#12002397)
No, because as a nation we are actively investing in each funded Ph.D. we train.

If we have too many PhD's then we should decrease the number of PhD's the federal government funds. But as my original parent observed, paying hundreds of thousands to train someone just to kick them out of the country is silly.

(Also, I think downward pressure on PhD salaries has very little to do with over-supply, but that's for another article.)

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by adamnemecek on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:34AM (#12002302)
> research grants to universities fund those students' tuition and stipends, in exchange for good work.

Maybe for PhD programs but I don't think that's that common for Masters.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by Moshe_Silnorin on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:19AM (#12002163)
America has an amazing ability to attract the most high-quality immigrants, and an even more amazing ability to screw this up. Just give a green card to whomever can get a sufficiently high SAT score. This would start an insanely powerful brain drain in America's favour.
Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by crudbug on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:28AM (#12002246)
I have seen Asian students going to some third-level schools here and riding the job market with multi-level consulting scam ladder.

Having an "Elite University Group" based upon research work/ NSF funding, can surely help in determining both, the right university pool and attractive STEM talent.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by basch on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:22AM (#12002202)
can you imagine if countries had tried this instead of eugenics?
Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by defen on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @12:07PM (#12002573)
You don't think sufficiently motivated groups have figured out how to cheat on the SAT?

http://www.barrons.com/articles/sat-integrity-falls-victim-t...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2014/11/...

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by Moshe_Silnorin on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @12:09PM (#12002587)
IQ scores are very stable across time. An IQ 140 immigrant would be worth the cost of several random tests. As this would cost vastly less than a largely-useless masters degree, I'm sure immigrants would be willing to pay for a harder-to-cheat test.
Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by steego on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:41AM (#12002378)
I love the idea of making it easy for highly skilled foreigners to job shop because it's in my interest that they are paid competitively. It also imports people who create value and bring in additional tax revenue.

I'm hesitant about the idea of merely tying green cards to STEM degrees because it does seem like the sort of incentive to yield unintended consequences. What sort of protections will there be to make sure universities don't water down their STEM programs?

However, calling this a gigantic bailout to universities is an obtuse way to characterize it. A bailout is when you provide financial assistance to a failed institution. That's not what's happening here. This is a program that would attach new value to a STEM degree from a US university. Universities would certainly experience a windfall as they will be able to charge a premium for STEM programs, but don't confuse windfalls with bailouts.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by droopyEyelids on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:27AM (#12002238)
This makes me want to cry when I think of all the scummy cheating students I went to college with and the way my school refused to deal with their behavior.
Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by wwwwwwwwww on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:35AM (#12002314)
pretty much this. At my school it's an almost universal phenomenon among international students. They literally run a cheating cartel that shares completed labs, tests, and homework. They even have a guy that they buy to take their tests for them.

the school doesn't take cheating very seriously - one time a guy was on his phone looking up answers in the middle of a test. the professor told him to put it away, and he did. a few minutes later he takes his phone back out and is looking up answers again.

it really is despicable how light universities are on cheating

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by Eyas on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @11:53AM (#12002474)
This hurts quite a bit because of the correlation it seems to be making between international students and cheating. I do agree that degrees should mean something, which means anyone benefiting from such 'cheating cartel' should not reap the fruits of being called a degree holder of an institution.

But a comment like this makes me wonder if this is how I am viewed as a non-citizen graduate of a 'good school' who performed well above average in their class. Credentials like a degree are never enough to prove someone's worth/skill, of course, but this comment seems to suggest I might be facing additional pressure to prove my worth because I'm foreign-born. I was not aware this might need to be something I should be cognizant of.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by droopyEyelids on Thursday June 30, 2016 @12:56AM (#12006645)
I actually thought of the one foreign student I knew that was a really hard worker when i wrote the original comment and almost decided not to write it. But I remembered seven scum-fucks to balance him out, and the group projects where I did all the work and their names went on the final product.
Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by sologoub on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @12:02PM (#12002541)
For it to be a golden ticket, someone has to hire them at a good salary. If the person went to 4th rate school and has no skills to compete in the job market, it's not really a golden ticket and not a drain on the economy as they don't qualify for a lot of things.

On the other hand, if the person is capable and can attract and sustain a lucrative career, they'll contribute to economy and taxes.

As someone else mentioned in this thread - having the ability to job hop for foreign workers prevents the exploitative wages from sticking and reduces incentives for companies to substitute for cost reduction. H1-B was originally "meant" (a.k.a. sold) to fill in labor gaps, not reduce costs...

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @12:06PM (#12002563)
> H1-B was originally meant to fill in labor gaps, not reduce costs...

No, the people involved in making the decision knew enough basic economic to recognize that "filling gaps in supply for commodity X" and "reducing the market-clearing cost of commodity X" are exactly the same thing.

It was sold as the former, because to general public that sounds better.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by sologoub on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @01:02PM (#12002965)
Good point, will edit.
Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by DerekL on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @05:03PM (#12004802)
> For it to be a golden ticket, someone has to hire them at a good salary. If the person went to 4th rate school and has no skills to compete in the job market, it's not really a golden ticket and not a drain on the economy as they don't qualify for a lot of things.

Right. The danger is not a flood of bozos, because a green card is no guarantee of a high salary job. The actual problem is that as soon as a U.S. degree comes with a green card, the schools in America will jack up the tuition for foreign students.

Two ways to solve this: we could offer the same deal for foreign schools, or require U.S. schools to charge the same tuition and fees to both foreign and domestic students.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by naveen99 on Friday July 01, 2016 @07:57AM (#12015309)
> the schools in America will jack up the tuition for foreign students.

My understanding was out of state and international students have the same full tuition price. The difference is only in instate and out of state. Lots of wealthy people in the us pay full price at private schools. Colleges can't just increase tuition too much for international students, because there is no artificial cap on number of college seats. The college market will expand to handle more students.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by amyjess on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @01:44PM (#12003246)
Honestly, the only thing I'd change is to only do this for accredited universities, so people have to go through a real educational institution and not a degree mill like the University of Phoenix.

Other than that, this is brilliant. Not only would it get more smart people into the country, but it would also make it much harder for companies to exploit foreign-born workers. Under the current H-1B system, a company can say "you're going to work 12 hours a day every day for substandard pay, and if you complain or step even an inch out of line, you get to go back to your home country". Green cards would put a stop to this exploitation.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @01:50PM (#12003291)
> Honestly, the only thing I'd change is to only do this for accredited universities, so people have to go through a real educational institution and not a degree mill like the University of Phoenix.

University of Phoenix is an accredited university.

Re:Hillary Clinton Announces Tech Plan by umanwizard on Wednesday June 29, 2016 @01:54PM (#12003319)
Yeah, accredited by whom?

I hereby accredit the University of Phoenix. What now?