News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Brexit Possibility by FussyZeus on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:24PM (#11995048)
This is an excellent read, and the only thing that I really want to add is at this bit:

> Each of these factors is critical: a universal basic income alone offers some degree of financial security, but it does not offer dignity to the recipient, or any return for society beyond a reduction in guilt.

It's time we re-thought the idea that you need to work for your fill. Speaking as a strong capitalist, it's simply not the reality anymore. To put it in the context of the tribe working to survive that most people think is a good metaphor, this is akin to having 3 incredibly good hunters in the tribe who catch enough food to feed the tribe 4 times over yet still requiring the other men to go hunting and not letting them eat if they don't catch anything on a given day. Why? We have the resources to feed everyone, and all the lower ends of the economic classes doing all the busy-work they could possibly do in a day cannot generate the kind of wealth that workers at the upper end create with a regular work day on a bad day.

The notion that you MUST do SOMETHING to earn your money is quickly becoming a barrier to efficiency, and with automation on the rise, it's only going to get worse. Simply "getting a better job" is not a sufficient answer for the vast groups in the population that we're set to unemploy.

Re:The Brexit Possibility by brotox on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:59PM (#11995385)
I won't argue whether we must work, but I will instead argue that the author should think long and hard about his view on 'dignity'.

I doubt the author would claim that a wealthy rentier who spends their days creating art and debating philosophy was lacking in dignity. So why is dignity suddenly a problem if the person is very poor?

That sentence let us know a lot about the author and his view on the very poor; but it didn't actually tell us anything at all about the poor, or their "dignity".

In the meantime, I'll make a note that if the author believed his writings, he'd move to Britain. He is not going to do that. Because he is just taking a silly stance to get attention. It's a dumb hot-take, written by a shallow, bigoted jag-off. It sucks that this thing is on HN.

This is, by a wide margin, the worst thing I've read on stratechery. And thanks to the bigotry of that dignity comment, it will be the last.

Re:The Brexit Possibility by monkbent on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @01:41PM (#11995795)
Tell that to my family and friends who live in the rust belt and absolutely feel this way. I wrote that from personal experience.
Re:The Brexit Possibility by xg15 on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:47PM (#11995274)
To stay with the metaphors, what if the hunters at some point decide to break off and make their own tribe? The other members of the tribe will be forced to join the new tribe, because they wouldn't be able to survive on their own.

Similarly, my fear is that a world in which a few elites provide everything for a large "idle class", people of that idle class would have no practical rights against that elite.

I agree with you that the current "work ideology" won't be usable in the future and in fact seems contradictory. However, I think seeing centralisation as the solution could lead to an even worse society.

Re:The Brexit Possibility by kbenson on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:58PM (#11995372)
> The other members of the tribe will be forced to join the new tribe, because they wouldn't be able to survive on their own.

The analogy breaks down here, because the hunters can't realistically leave. They aren't really hunting as much as gathering the scraps of all the villagers and combining them into a tasty new meal, along with a little hunting on the side. Leaving the village means they might not have as easy access to the scraps, and game is much more scarce and hard to hunt than gathering scraps.

> Similarly, my fear is that a world in which a few elites provide everything for a large "idle class", people of that idle class would have no practical rights against that elite.

I'm not sure it's a large idle class compared to a small elite. The idea, if it works, is not that nobody works, but that they can focus work where they want. Some people are fine doing menial (or unfulfilling) work and using the extra money on the side, others want to devote all the time to what they love. Or maybe, people will naturally flow between these states over their life. None of us really know how it would work, since we haven't had a system like that before (and I would argue that getting from here to there might actually be harder than making there work).

Re:The Brexit Possibility by FussyZeus on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:52PM (#11995323)
Our basic human rights already protect us against that sort of thing though. Basic income implemented well (as just literally giving people money to survive) has no control-ability attached to it. Compare that to our current system where food stamps can only be used for certain kinds of food, or where rent subsidies are only available in certain kinds of housing. I would argue a basic income would increase personal freedom, not decrease it.
Re:The Brexit Possibility by apalmer on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:39PM (#11995214)
once again this is ideology over reality. Yes, at one level there definitely is factual that the top hunters can supply the rest of the tribe with all necessary resources. The problem is one of motivation... Why should they?

It is the most basic of driving forces behind trade at the conceptual level, and society itself at its most fundamental and basic. IF your world view cannot handle this most basic of questions, it is just ideology and not even a sensible one at that.

Re:The Brexit Possibility by FussyZeus on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:49PM (#11995293)
On the note about the social issue: I recognize the primary obstacle is the social stigma we attach to "people on benefits" or "the welfare queens" and all that other nonsense, it doesn't make the situation any less clear. We spend vast amounts of money subsidizing through inefficient programs the people who are either incapable or unwilling to take care of themselves. We're going to pay for it either way, either by just giving them what they need to live a relatively healthy lifestyle, or by forcing them to live an incredibly unhealthy one and then subsidize the prisons to hold them or the hospitals to keep them on the edge of life.

The question we need to answer as a society is whether the latter option which is much, much more expensive is worthwhile to do just to keep this imagined requirement going. Frankly I think if all the counter arguments boil down to "that's just the way we are" I would reply with "that's not good enough for me, because we can change."

Re:The Brexit Possibility by djrogers on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @01:39PM (#11995779)
> The question we need to answer as a society

The problem is that society is made up of individuals, so if you can't answer the 'why should they' question for the individuals it doesn't matter what society at large decides.

Re:The Brexit Possibility by RobertoG on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:55PM (#11995352)
"Yes, at one level there definitely is factual that the top hunters can supply the rest of the tribe with all necessary resources. The problem is one of motivation... Why should they?"

I don't think that is a good metaphor.

It's more like: all our ancestors worked hard to build what the tribe have, but a few people just decide they should have most of it because they know how to hunt a little better.

Or, not even that, because they are the grandsons of a guy that, maybe, hunted a little better.

Re:The Brexit Possibility by FussyZeus on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:44PM (#11995251)
You're assuming I mean everyone gets the same amount of food, in other words forced equality of the results of a minority, and that's nothing but slavery under a different guise.

No, the idea is that everyone gets a livable wage as a base. You're guaranteed enough money to have a place to live, food to eat, and whatever else the given society thinks is required to "live." To get more than that, you're expected to contribute. The upper economic workers I mentioned would have the same lifestyle they have now, we'd still have the rich as well because they have earned it, even if all they did to earn it was being born in the right family, it's still theirs.

What I'm arguing for is not tearing down high earners, it's simply using our resources to uplift those who aren't high earners to a degree where they aren't starving in the street. People starving in the street are very expensive as it is, keeping them in a basic home with running water and food is far cheaper than having them continuously in and out of the ER's which they can't pay for, all for the weird and hand wavy idea of "motivating" people to not end up like them (which is surprisingly easy to do, by the way.)

Re:The Brexit Possibility by apalmer on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @01:29PM (#11995688)
No, your missing my fundamental argument. Lets break it down to fundamentals.

Definition 1) Society at its most fundamental is a group of individuals who enter into some kind of social contract in order to increase their own personal benefit.

Definition 2) Trade at its most fundamental is exchange of goods or services in order to increase personal benefit of each party.

Scenario) Population is split into two Groups. Group A is small and is responsible for production of all Goods and Services. Group B is large and does not produce or control any Goods and Services but destructively consumes Goods and Services.

QUESTION: Why would Group A partake in a social contract with Group B when by Definition 1 this decreases personal benefit for individuals in Group A?

Re:The Brexit Possibility by FussyZeus on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @01:50PM (#11995861)
This is a very accurate breakdown but the simple fact is Group A is already in that relationship. Whether they choose to subsidize Group B via the hospitals, inefficient social programs, and jails or they choose to subsidize them via basic income is what's to be decided.

Group A has already agreed to a subsidy in the form of what I listed above because it's appealing to not have people starving to death in the streets.