News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Brexit Possibility by xg15 on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:47PM (#11995274)
To stay with the metaphors, what if the hunters at some point decide to break off and make their own tribe? The other members of the tribe will be forced to join the new tribe, because they wouldn't be able to survive on their own.

Similarly, my fear is that a world in which a few elites provide everything for a large "idle class", people of that idle class would have no practical rights against that elite.

I agree with you that the current "work ideology" won't be usable in the future and in fact seems contradictory. However, I think seeing centralisation as the solution could lead to an even worse society.

Re:The Brexit Possibility by kbenson on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:58PM (#11995372)
> The other members of the tribe will be forced to join the new tribe, because they wouldn't be able to survive on their own.

The analogy breaks down here, because the hunters can't realistically leave. They aren't really hunting as much as gathering the scraps of all the villagers and combining them into a tasty new meal, along with a little hunting on the side. Leaving the village means they might not have as easy access to the scraps, and game is much more scarce and hard to hunt than gathering scraps.

> Similarly, my fear is that a world in which a few elites provide everything for a large "idle class", people of that idle class would have no practical rights against that elite.

I'm not sure it's a large idle class compared to a small elite. The idea, if it works, is not that nobody works, but that they can focus work where they want. Some people are fine doing menial (or unfulfilling) work and using the extra money on the side, others want to devote all the time to what they love. Or maybe, people will naturally flow between these states over their life. None of us really know how it would work, since we haven't had a system like that before (and I would argue that getting from here to there might actually be harder than making there work).

Re:The Brexit Possibility by FussyZeus on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @12:52PM (#11995323)
Our basic human rights already protect us against that sort of thing though. Basic income implemented well (as just literally giving people money to survive) has no control-ability attached to it. Compare that to our current system where food stamps can only be used for certain kinds of food, or where rent subsidies are only available in certain kinds of housing. I would argue a basic income would increase personal freedom, not decrease it.