News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human or Machine: Can You Tell Who Wrote These Poems? by thaumasiotes on Monday June 27, 2016 @05:53PM (#11989828)
From my perspective, sonnet #6 was easily the best technically. That doesn't mean I connected with it emotionally, but someone could.

Generally, there's a poem (more than one even) to fit any person's taste. patio11 has quoted one before, which is meaningful to him:

    I went to find the pot of gold
    that's waiting where the rainbow ends
    I searched and searched and searched and searched
    and searched and searched, and then
    there it was, deep in the grass
    under an old and twisty bough
    It's mine, it's mine, it's mine at last
    What do I search for now?
Rudyard Kipling wrote a number of poems about pragmatism, among other things; here's a verse of Dane-geld:

    It is wrong to put temptation in the path of any nation
    for fear they should succumb and go astray
    So when you are requested to pay up or be molested
    you will find it better policy to say:
    We never pay anyone Dane-geld, no matter how trifling the cost
    For the end of that game is oppression and shame
    and the nation that plays it is lost!
Here's a verse of Rising of the Moon that appeals to the same (very popular!) basic themes as jingoism does:

    All along that singing river, that black mass of men was seen
    High above their shining weapons flew their own beloved green
    Death to every foe and traitor, whistle out the marching tune
    And our army buys her freedom at the rising of the moon
All of those are high-quality poems.

The problem comes in with an upper-class movement to distinguish themselves from the rubes who appreciate good poetry by removing all the things that make it good. The problem SilasX identifies is real, and you can earn a lot of acclaim today writing awful, rhythmless, rhymeless, themeless stuff and calling it poetry. Compounding the problem, this terrible high-prestige form is what you'll learn about if you decide to take a poetry class. But we shouldn't let it ruin our view of what poetry can be.

Re:Human or Machine: Can You Tell Who Wrote These Poems? by dempseye on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @03:09AM (#11991989)
> this terrible high-prestige form is what you'll learn about if you decide to take a poetry class

While there are classes in post-modern poetry, most poetry classes are not that.

How many poetry classes have you taken?

Re:Human or Machine: Can You Tell Who Wrote These Poems? by thaumasiotes on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @03:20AM (#11992029)
Fair enough. My experience with poetry classes is limited to elementary school and middle school. Our middle school curriculum consisted of badmouthing poetry that somebody somewhere might have actually liked. The school was proud of having classes taught by a published poet.
Re:Human or Machine: Can You Tell Who Wrote These Poems? by dempseye on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @03:43AM (#11992125)
It's entirely possible that you were taught by a pseud. That's unfortunate if so.

I did a degree in English lit. The poetry classes I took looked something like this:

- Old and Middle English Poetry (Beowulf, Chaucer, etc.)

- Elizabethan Poetry

- Paradise Lost

- The Shakespearean Sonnet

- 18th Century Classicism (Alexander Pope, etc.)

- Victorian Poetry (Tennyson, Matthew Arnold, etc.)

- 20th Century Irish Poetry (Yeats, that kind of thing)

- 20th Century American Modernism

Only in the last class was there was anything like you described, and even then it only made up a fraction of the material covered.

Here is one of the most critically acclaimed poems of the last 40 years. It's perfectly easy to understand. http://www.poetrybyheart.org.uk/poems/a-martian-sends-a-post...