My wife has "significant debt" from college and medical school (roughly 200k) that she will pay off over 20 to 30 years (or whatever it is). However she earns a good salary for what she does. As a result the cost of the education is similar to a cost of doing business. When I met her I had to loan her a few thousand dollars so she could make her rent (when she had just graduated and got her first job out of school). Now she does fine. Even with the loans. She choose the profession and was lucky to be able to graduate keeping in mind economic realities.
Her ex husband on the other hand has debt from going to law school but was not able to land (for various reasons) a good job which allows him to pay off his debt (he is now living with his parents).
Saying college is expensive (ok it is) is like saying buying a house with a 30 year mortgage is expensive. It depends on the details. Having to take out a loan to pay for something (college or a house) that you will use over a lifetime isn't really that outrageous. What is is not making the proper career choices or having some bad luck so that you can't pay back the money you have borrowed.
There are ways to achieve good outcomes in the current system, but that is not the same as systemically maximizing good outcomes for society at large.
I think the most efficient way to do that is to go back to giving significant direct funding to public university systems so they can offer low to no tuition education options. This puts competitive pressure on private universities and would have an overall downward effect on tuitions.
Well a good start might be simply avoiding majors that you know will go nowhere, don't you think? Like music, art and certain liberal arts. Even when I went to school it was known to be hard to get a job in those fields. But yet people still choose them and tried to "follow their passion". My passion was to learn something where I could earn a living. And I am having plenty of fun doing that.
Of course you can't predict the future. But you can certainly improve your chances by giving some thought to what is not a good choice and hasn't ever really been.
It would do far more good to first get tuition costs under control and then maybe use the direct funding path as a way where influence on public universities could be had. However, I think society ends up stronger if there's something of a firewall preventing politicians from putting too many specific policy requirements attached to that funding.
With remunerative degrees, you can at least make the argument that selective schools gate selective employers, and so expensive colleges can be a necessity. But it's harder to make that argument for music or art.
The question isn't whether you should study art. It's how much of a premium you should pay to study it at an elite school.
In any case, you seem to be narrowing the domain more and more here, from "education is difficult for people to afford", to "education is difficult for artists to afford", to "education is difficult for artists who went to elite schools to afford."
The article, on the other hand, is saying that even if you do make enough to get by, it's still hard to pay for school.
Put yourself in the mind of a 16 year old (I'm a parent to one, so I might have an easier or a harder time doing that). Kids mostly have no idea at all what their career is, but they're all attuned to the admissions/status game.
I'm not narrowing the argument, so much as I'm trying to support the argument that fewer kids should take on large debt (and stress!) getting into elite colleges; more should go to lower-tier or even community colleges until they have a better idea what they want to do, and then transfer to the Right School when they can make an informed decision.
Again, I might have an idiosyncratic view of this, since I didn't really go to college at all (I went for a single summer semester when I was 19).
What you seem to be saying is that only the rich and well-off should pursue those fields, while the poor and middle class keep their heads down to "earn a living."
Can't you see how that policy will impact your life negatively? I would hate to live in that world. Wouldn't you?
Hemingway did not spring to life a great writer. He might have only completed high school, but high school was enough to get him a reporting job at age 18, and it was a reporting job that sent him to Paris, where he found Gertrude Stein, Ezra Pound, James Joyce, F Scott Fitzgerald. I would call that an education.
The original point I tried to make was this: by expecting all poor and middle-class kids to spend their formative years preparing for practical, low-risk careers -- at the expense of their artistic "passions" -- we are depriving ourselves of their creative output.
Things were different 100 years ago. If Hemingway didn't go to college, it was because he didn't need to. He was lucky enough to live at a time when you could work as a journalist at age 18 having no greater qualifications than a high school diploma and a few articles published in the school newspaper.
What would Hemingway do today? Following gist's advice, he would go to college and study computer science or biomedical engineering. Or maybe he would substitute San Fransisco for Paris, and instead of A Farewell To Arms we would have another social-some-shit to add to the cannon of timeless iPhone apps.
But study journalism or English literature with a view towards becoming a reporter or (gasp) a fiction writer? Out of the question. You know those majors won't go anywhere. You need to earn a living.
...isn't the real failure right here, in the constant infantilizing of our young? Shouldn't we be expecting our society to produce semi-capable adults when they come of age? It's not like people have to be so unworldly at the tender age of 18.
http://roppskyline.pbworks.com/w/page/6550634/Growing%20up%2...
Great saying (I think Israeli) - "the army is a system built by geniuses to control idiots". Because they generally recruit 18-20-year-olds, and yes, 18-20-year-olds are idiots. So the institution puts them through the kind of regimentation that the Spartans did to exert some kind of control.
That's a variation on a line from Herman Wouk's World War II novel The Caine Mutiny, in which one character says that the Navy is a system designed by geniuses for execution by idiots.
I heard the phrase from my mom (Israeli, grew up in the 60s-70s). Not sure the saying is widely adopted in Israel or just she or someone agree knew read the book; apparently it rang true with people's experiences :-P
I strongly suspect that if you took the exact same amount of money as is spent on education today, financed it using either public debt or taxation or some mix, and direct funded more education through public universities, education would run more efficiently, and society and businesses would benefit economically more than individually loading people down with educational debt.
https://www.admission.ucla.edu/prospect/budget.htm
Depending on circumstances $25k to $52k for next year with a 10% increase over the next three to four years...
http://trends.collegeboard.org/college-pricing/figures-table...
Do we want to filter who goes to a top-tier university by those who are able to spend money there or by how well they perform? Doesn't society benefit the most if we are able to send the highest performers to the best universities without unrelated financial criteria knocking them out? And before someone points out financial aid - many potential people may self-disqualify before even getting to the point of applying.
Even if people can afford it, charging that $100k takes away capital that a bright recent graduate might have been able acces to bootstrap a startup. I think across multiple facets, there are a large economic costs we pay by charging high tuitions to students.
Is it ideal? Far from it. But it's also not an insurmountable obstacle for most who are qualified to attend. The public education systems fails lower-income students long, long before they get to university level.
1: The ex husband is a great example of how someone can go into tremendous debt that cannot be discharged through bankruptcy and still come out with nothing.
2: The rapidly increasing price of higher education compounds the risk of making the wrong choice. A mistake that could tail you for decades could instead be with you to the grave.
My point is sure the game has gotten tougher but just because it is doesn't mean you blame the game you just outwork the other person.
Sounds like a race to the bottom in the ever decreasing marginal productivity of labor in 21st century capitalism.
Of the system requires you be a bad parent, it is not sustainable.
Lawyers were misled by a lot of law schools, and their tuition skyrocketed. With automation impacting some aspects of that field, demand has dropped, and so several classes worth of students have been screwed.
I'm not familiar with the medical field, but in theory the same thing could happen there.
Nobody can see the future, so barring that, for many, taking on that level of extreme debt does not make sense.
Generally a good idea to be skeptical of what someone selling you something is saying, right? I question whether any of these people who went to law school did much research or thinking (or if their counselors at schools did) in advance of such a major decision.
Other professions not so much. It would be hard to imagine for most people that a good deal of work in law wouldn't even happen in courts. Stuff like documentation and range of other things are hard to see while you are picking the course.
That is credit creation right there. It allows the pulling forward of demand to capture labour over a lifetime for credit creators (not intermediaries) - the banks.
Until we tackle money creation housing and college, two essentials - that's why they lend into them - will always reflect the total potential income over a person's working life.
If we double productivity rentiers will get the same % of your labour. This means everyone will always and forever be under the thumb of usurers.
By design.
For whatever it's worth, the idea that the "American Dream" requires a college education is itself a little weird.
Yes, all those people having to live incognito to avoid collection agencies or even fleeing abroad (http://money.cnn.com/2008/10/23/pf/college/student_loan_fugi...) certainly do not figure it as a concern.
(I didn't go.)
Having kids is obviously a deeply personal decision and don't think I'm second-guessing you, but college funding is probably not a dispositive concern.