Re:Tech Companies Fight Back After Years of Being Deluged wi...
by simonh on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @05:36AM
(#11952538)
What they are doing is the equivalent of demanding that people help with the investigation and threatening them with legal consequences if they don't.
The fact is that even if a police officer doesn't have the right to arrest you for refusing to comply, they can absolutely threaten to do so and as a matter of fact if they choose to cuff and detain you that is what will happen regardless of your legal rights regarding any information you might have.
Re:Tech Companies Fight Back After Years of Being Deluged wi...
by imh on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @11:32PM
(#11951386)
How about a nice compromise where if the person asks whether they have to comply to a request, the government has to respond truthfully? As far as I know, there are no such requirements.
Re:Tech Companies Fight Back After Years of Being Deluged wi...
by brokenmachine on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @11:28PM
(#11951370)
IMO they should be allowed to ask for whatever they want, but they must also clarify if it is a lawful order or a request.
Then it is up to the requestee to decide whether or not to comply. That is the whole point of living in a democracy and not a police state, correct? Also that is the actual law.
Tricking people into doing more than required by law is fraud in my opinion.
The police are entitled to ask for cooperation from people to help with investigations. If there is a crime in my neighborhood, should police be banned from asking me about what I saw just because they can't compel me to do so?
And if you set the boundary for what police "may ask for" == to what police may "compel you to provide" don't you think that'll lead to undesirable growth in the latter?