News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by 3pt14159 on Monday June 20, 2016 @07:39PM (#11942480)
Ethereum isn't doomed. I don't think it will ever have as much backing as Bitcoin because of institutional buy-in; but the world needs programmable smart contracts. Some rich soon-to-be-dead billionaire tech nerds want to be able to do something every year without worrying about a judge taking that away from them. Individual will is what cryptocurrencies are about. Bitcoin in terms of international payments and store-of-value; and Ethereum in terms of contracts and computing.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by timmytokyo on Monday June 20, 2016 @08:03PM (#11942595)
Ethereum is doomed, and not just because it's based on a poor design. It's doomed because it just shot its credibility to shreds by protecting a single, uniquely privileged contract. Forking proves that the ethereum network cannot be trusted as the neutral contract arbitrator it was designed to be.

The idea of smart contracts is an interesting one, and perhaps another project will come along and do it better. But Ethereum won't be that project.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by heliumcraft on Monday June 20, 2016 @09:35PM (#11942915)
Based on a poor design? according to who? It's the most advanced blockchain out there by far and wide! This was a single contract with a flaw, it's like saying the whole internet is doomed because some website got a SQL injection.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by dkarapetyan on Monday June 20, 2016 @09:50PM (#11942976)
I don't think "most advanced blockchain out there" is actual praise. Systems, especially systems that are meant to serve as a substrate for more advanced systems must be simple to understand and reason about. Making the foundation turing complete is indeed poor design.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by heliumcraft on Monday June 20, 2016 @09:55PM (#11942989)
If your goal is a calculator, then a computer is a poor design indeed.

Ethereum is meant to be a platform and goes far beyond what Bitcoin can do.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by Retra on Monday June 20, 2016 @10:10PM (#11943046)
Turing completeness is not an implication of poor anything. All it does is remove certain kinds of generality from your proofs. You can still prove things, you just have to be careful stating what the assumptions are.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by dkarapetyan on Monday June 20, 2016 @10:38PM (#11943124)
So you mean to tell me that taking away the ability to write generic programs to validate contracts is good design? See Rice's Theorem (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rice%27s_theorem). Once you have turing completeness verifying any non-trivial program property starts requiring grad school experience and real proficiency with writing and verifying proofs. Most people, including programmers, do not have the training nor the discipline to actually do what you suggested.

In practice the assumptions you mention turn out to be assumptions about totality and termination of certain building blocks and so you are back to a restricted subset of the language which should have been the original language to begin with but instead of automatic verification you have turned the problem into manual labor. Thinking about this more I agree with the naysayers. Etherium was a good experiment to show people what they should not put into a smart contract system.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by tamana on Monday June 20, 2016 @11:15PM (#11943241)
So instead of hiring a juris doctor lawyer to review my contracts, I'll hire a PhD computer scientist ;)
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by wila on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @04:34AM (#11944350)
.and that PhD computer scientist will have a contract that he/she cannot be held responsible for anything bad that happens with the code he/she writes. Written by a juris doctor lawyer. :)
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by dkarapetyan on Monday June 20, 2016 @11:39PM (#11943324)
Correct. Programmatic contracts should have democratized the entire business but instead this new scheme creates a new class of "lawyer".
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by wolfgke on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @07:25AM (#11944922)
I strongly prefer "laws" that are based on mathematics/computability theory than on social conventions.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by crispyambulance on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @08:14AM (#11945101)
I think this is the core flaw in the mindset of Ethereum adherents: the very idea that it is even possible to have "Laws" which are completely objective to the point of mathematical logic and that these could/should be enforced, literally, by a computer running a program.

We are thankfully very very far from a system of Laws which are anything like that. Such a system might be great in certain "sandbox" environments for manipulating resources that have carefully controlled interactions with the outside. But to have arbitrarily complex "smart contracts" running in the affairs of the real world? no thanks!

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by dkarapetyan on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @11:51AM (#11946601)
We are in agreement. It's unfortunate that the initial implementation was a blunder.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by im3w1l on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @03:05AM (#11943979)
So, just write your contract in a non-turing complete subset of it. Just because the power is there doesn't mean you have to use it if you don't want to.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by Grue3 on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @03:30AM (#11944057)
According to the article, you need to write interfaces that accept a function and call it somewhere down the line. At this point you already cannot guarantee the lack of recursion, simply because the supplied function can call your function again. It is simply not possible to write a code that always halts, unless you never even call the supplied function.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by Retra on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @06:54PM (#11950124)
There's a difference between general recursion and bounded recursion, and you can very easily constrain recursive functions to terminate, especially if you're in control of the data they must pass around.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by dkarapetyan on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @03:58AM (#11944175)
You just made my point. The Ethereum designers have offloaded all the hard work onto others. What value do I get out of this platform if I'm doing all the hard work?
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by amaks on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @12:24AM (#11943489)
Please read http://hackingdistributed.com/2016/06/17/thoughts-on-the-dao....

Solidity language makes very hard to write safe code:

Is Ethereum/Solidity Suitable for Secure Smart Contracts? It's clear that writing a robust, secure smart contract requires extreme amounts of diligence. It's more similar to writing code for a nuclear power reactor, than to writing loose web code.

Yet the current Solidity language and underlying EVM seems designed more for the latter. Some misfeatures are:

A good language for writing state machines would ensure that there are no states from which it is impossible to recover. A good language for writing state machines would make it painfully clear when state transitions can and cannot happen. A good language for maintaining state machines would provide features for upgrading the security of a live contract. A good language for writing secure code would make it clear that there are no implicit actions, that code executes plainly, as read. The current language does not fulfill any of these commandments, and in fact, the last one, involving implicit recursive calls, is what did The Dao in.

The SlockIt team even had the designer and implementor of Solidity perform a review of their code. If he cannot get something like The DAO to be secure, no one can.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by viraptor on Monday June 20, 2016 @08:26PM (#11942690)
I think you're thinking of use cases that would definitely be stopped outside of ethereum world:

> Some rich soon-to-be-dead billionaire tech nerds want to be able to do something every year without worrying about a judge taking that away from them.

You can do things like this, but the law either already covers this, or will adjust. If you gain money, you're expected to pay the usual tax on that gain. First few may get away with it, but once it becomes popular, audits will start.

> Individual will is what cryptocurrencies are about.

Same as above - inheritance tax.

Essentially it's this xkcd situation: https://xkcd.com/1494/ Just with wealth gain and tax office instead.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by Tinyyy on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @12:29AM (#11943505)
The point of Ethereum is to provide something that is different from the real world. If not, it is simply fiat, except that it is 1000 times more inefficient and burns up loads of electricity.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by viraptor on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @07:16AM (#11944884)
It has to affect the real world at some point. If it doesn't, what's the point?
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by 3pt14159 on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @09:20AM (#11945363)
You cannot rely on the law to treat your wishes long after you are dead. The largest park in Toronto (High Park), for example, should technically not be owned by the city because the person that bequeathed it to the city said that it would revert to some other organization if a catholic was ever elected mayor, but that never happened.

As for XKCD - where something happens is no longer clear cut. If someone creates a etherium contract during a year in Argentina while SSH'd into a computer in Hong Kong it starts to become very difficult to enforce the law.

I'm not even talking strictly about tax evasion I'm talking about subversion of the states restriction on individual action - and I agree that this isn't a good thing across the board. I don't like the idea of billionaires hiding their influence and wealth, I just think it is inevitable.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by bendbro on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @01:14AM (#11943643)
As long as you never convert into traditional currency, how will they know you participated in a transaction?
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by viraptor on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @07:15AM (#11944880)
As long as you never convert, what use is it? (and that's assuming your country doesn't require you to declare cryptocurrency gains)
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by bendbro on Friday June 24, 2016 @06:16PM (#11973930)
Some people are willing to trade goods and services for Bitcoin, just like they would dollars.

I don't think it's relevant what the person receiving the Bitcoin does with it after (converting directly to dollars, holding, or buying other goods/services), since those are the same things people do with regular dollars anyway.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by jacques_chester on Monday June 20, 2016 @10:34PM (#11943118)
> Some rich soon-to-be-dead billionaire tech nerds want to be able to do something every year without worrying about a judge taking that away from them.

Billionaires still have nexuses with the physical world. The machines which execute their code, for example, can absolutely be affected by court orders. So too can their homes, their cars, their planes, their drones and of course their person.

There's a brand of techno-utopianism that assumes that if it's virtual, it's magically immune from the whole mechanism of law. This has never been true. The law asserts itself to be omnipresent in all human affairs and -- unlike a computer program -- the law's power is accepted at face value by billions of people and underlined by men with guns and dogs.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by lsc on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @04:06AM (#11944216)
>the law's power is accepted at face value by billions of people and underlined by men with guns and dogs.

emphasis mine. I find that last bit, though, to be super interesting; "enforced by men with guns" has always been a big part of the rhetoric of any discussion of law, anarchist, or libertarian thought.

But... I'm not sure I've ever seen dogs mentioned in that context.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by jerf on Monday June 20, 2016 @07:48PM (#11942525)
A contract-based blockchain seems very likely to me. But there's no reason that has to be Ethereum. Having had the chance to sort of ponder this over the last couple of days, I can't help but come to the conclusion that Ethereum is indeed fundamentally flawed and probably entirely unsalvageable, for all the reasons given in that blog post and more. The eventual contract-based blockchain that succeeds is going to look a lot more, well, engineered, for lack of a better word. Probably a lot more proofs of various things. Fewer features that are all individually much stronger.

In fact, there's little reason to believe that something this complicated would be done correctly the first time. Remember... Bitcoin is not the first digital currency either!

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by JorgeGT on Monday June 20, 2016 @08:13PM (#11942636)
> Some rich soon-to-be-dead billionaire tech nerds want to be able to do something every year without worrying about a judge taking that away from them.

But apparently it only takes a fork to freeze/reverse their contracts. I would take my chances with a traditional foundation, Alfred Nobel's is still running smoothly since +110 years ago, yearly executing its "code".

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by kalleboo on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @06:01AM (#11944667)
> want to be able to do something every year without worrying about a judge taking that away from them

Except we're just about to prove that an institution can decide to nullify a Ethereum contract with the soft/hard forks. In the very best case that will a cabal of miners with unknown intentions (and clearly they're not too invested in the Libertarian "code is contract" angle of the network) instead of a democratically constructed judicial system.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by peterbonney on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @08:36AM (#11945180)
"without worrying about a judge taking that away from them"

Unfortunately the ultimate arbiter of the courts' authority is not a piece of code or a piece of paper, but the courts themselves. If someone disputes the authority of a contract (smart or otherwise) that dispute will ultimately be settled in court. Even if the contract contains language claiming that it is not open to interpretation by a certain court or set of courts, the validity of THAT language will ultimately be interpreted by... a court.

There is no degree of technical cleverness that can supersede the authority of a sovereign entity. You can hide things from a sovereign, move things out of the reach of a sovereign, but you can never overrule a sovereign's authority within its own borders.

Re:Ethereum is Doomed by 3pt14159 on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @09:14AM (#11945334)
In which border does the Etherium contract reside and who should the court order name?
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by naasking on Tuesday June 21, 2016 @09:33AM (#11945440)
Which ever border the "victim" files, and if the judge rules against you, your assets in that region can be seized.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by altoz on Monday June 20, 2016 @07:47PM (#11942520)
RTFA. The idea of smart contracts isn't dead, but Ethereum looks like a terrible platform for it, given that it's very hard to audit the smart contracts on it.
Re:Ethereum is Doomed by whiddershins on Monday June 20, 2016 @08:09PM (#11942620)
I agree with your sentiment but downvoting because the guidelines specifically ask that you not say things that imply a commenter hasn't read the article.