News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:45AM (#11921354)
Just remember, when the developers inevitably appear with suggestions about how to stop the hack, roll back the blockchain, or come up with other schemes to block the hackers, they are showing everyone that all the talk of blockchains being decentralised, or being beyond the control of governments or other powers... is a complete lie.

If this hack can be stopped, then it demonstrates that the currency can be manipulated, that the decentralised system is not so fault tolerant or uncensored after all, and that people out there know this.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by tinkerrr on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:28AM (#11921546)
Also remember that this isn't the first time this idea of 'lets rollback a blockchain due to a hack/attack' has been floated or even tried. The first major blockchain rollback almost completely destroyed the cryptocurrency [1]. Since then, some major hacks have happened and the community/developers rejected the idea of a rollback [2][3]. That was a hard lesson, and hopefully the current developers will learn from the short history.

Also to your point, yes, Ethereum is not as decentralized as some would like to claim, either from a stakeholder perspective, or from a mining perspective, or even from a 'who holds the power' perspective. I suspect that's what makes it so efficient though, in terms of changing protocol, or making decisions on behalf of stakeholders.

[1] http://247cryptonews.com/vericoin-lack-integrity-bailout-min...

[2] https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/official-nxt-decision-blockc...

[3] http://www.newsbtc.com/2014/12/17/opal-recovers-1-7-million-...

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by jpereira on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:36AM (#11921571)
One could argue that at this point in its history it stands to benefit more from that efficiency than it would from more robust decentralization.

When adoption is low it stands to reason centralization would be high, and so it enables them to move faster to increase adoption, and hence lower centralization as other players and stakeholders enter the game.

However it does also stand the risk of allowing the current influential parties (the developers or miners) to influence the system in their favor. So far though, I don't think this has been the case, but we'll see how this situation plays out.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by tinkerrr on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:49AM (#11921619)
There is no doubt that centralization is more efficient than decentralization. The problem comes when developers or other stakeholders don't understand or underplay this feature.

Also, centralization/decentralization is a a scale, not discrete boolean values.

It will definitely be interesting to see how this plays out. Good luck to everyone involved.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by rlpb on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:50AM (#11921624)
If there is consensus that this is a problem and shouldn't be allowed, then there presumably is also consensus for even a hard fork if necessary. As an outside observer, I don't see why this is a demonstration that the decentralised system can be manipulated, is not fault tolerant, or censored.

Since if this is a problem and will be fixed, it will presumably be by consensus. We already know that with consensus the entire system can be changed (or forked, if you like). This is no secret and there was never any claim otherwise. This is exactly what they mean by decentralised.

What should worry you is if a change happens without consensus, but there is no such indication here.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by makomk on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:01AM (#11922656)
slock.it are now implying that opponents of the proposed hardfork are probably the thief and asking people to contact them with information about the identity of anyone who organizes opposition to it: https://twitter.com/christopherhesh/status/74379447973649612... It's going to be a very interesting kind of "consensus", that's for sure.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by aw3c2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:40AM (#11922871)
Ah, vigilantism. How incredibly fitting into the whole cryptocurrency ghetto. So very unprofessional.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by AnonymousPlanet on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:52AM (#11921393)
Let's call it self delusion. A "lie" needs the intention to deceive. I think most developers of these systems truly believe that they are building the First Distributed Republic or something like that.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by infodroid on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:28AM (#11921543)
Vitalik Buterin, the co-founder and Chief Scientist of Ethereum, just called for a DAO and ETH trading halt at all Ethereum exchanges: https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4oif2x/dao_attack...
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by mpeg on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:51AM (#11921625)
Apparently all that talk of decentralisation goes out the window when you're losing money. Ha
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by icebraining on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:03AM (#11921675)
Actually, I'd say the fact that he has to publicly ask for exchanges to stop the trades, and can't simply press a button or send out an order, shows the decentralization.

Decentralization doesn't prevent coordination.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by infodroid on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:18AM (#11921731)
I think you're missing the point. The fact that one man can bring the whole of Ethereum trading to a halt with an announcement really demonstrates just how much power he has. So it doesn't matter that he doesn't have a physical kill switch if the end result is the same.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by vintermann on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:16AM (#11922146)
He wouldn't have that power in just any old circumstance. He could have the power to launch nukes, but if that power would only work if all of the world agrees, I'd still not be afraid of him.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by weego on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:23AM (#11921751)
I mean, they don't have to honor the request to do so.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by wolfgke on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:30AM (#11922211)
> I think you're missing the point. The fact that one man can bring the whole of Ethereum trading to a halt with an announcement really demonstrates just how much power he has.

The reason for this is that ethereum exchanges are not decentralized and the "program" that the owners of the exchanges execute on their brains partly allows "dynamic mental code update" by Vitalik Buterin.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by curiousgal on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:30AM (#11921776)
The announcement didn't come out of the blue. Exchanges don't want stolen funds to go through them so it is also in their interest to halt trading.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:20AM (#11921955)
...but they didn't halt trading until they were asked to, so clearly it wasn't totally in their interests?

Exchanges are in a difficult position once the 'head' of ethereum tells them to stop. It's a sign that the blockchain might be forked, so any further trades they make might be undone - they simply have little choice but to stop after being told to do so.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by mcherm on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:27AM (#11922195)
> but they didn't halt trading until they were asked to, so clearly it wasn't totally in their interests?

Not at all. This is a classic "coordination problem". It is advantageous for many participants in the overall system to take an action, but only if the other participants are ALSO taking the action. In such a case, a widely followed and popular leader is one possible coordinating mechanism. And it does not give that popular leader the ability to do ANYTHING, only things that actually ARE popular but require coordination.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:42AM (#11922264)
a widely followed and popular leader is one possible coordinating mechanism.

That's the exact opposite of decentralized. Are we going to have to redefine the word?

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by viraptor on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:04AM (#11922373)
I don't agree. Centralised control would mean one person can change anything. Decentralised doesn't mean that nobody can propose a solution - only that others have to agree on it before it goes live.

How do you imagine decentralised decisions happening otherwise? Everyone choosing their own solution without ever talking to each other and seeing what is most popular?

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by mcherm on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:09PM (#11923868)
I'm not sure whether we are redefining it... I suppose it depends on what definition you were starting with!

My idea of "decentralized" includes things like "continues to function perfectly well if any one person or small group is removed from the process" and "continues to function perfectly well if any one person or small group becomes malicious".

In this case, if Vitalik Buterin were not around to announce the problem, someone else could announce it and that would provide a coordinating signal for all of the independent players to act on. If Vitalik Buterin were malicious and decided to announce a rollback of a big spend he had done, then the independent miners and mining pool operators would (I hope) choose to ignore the announcement and refuse to participate.

I guess to me, having a centralized group or individual make decisions seems to violate "decentralized", but having one of several possible groups or individuals make announcements which signal the population to take action does not.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by vertex-four on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:01AM (#11922349)
Nobody has to follow the leader. Want to keep your exchange trading? Go ahead - nobody can stop you. It just so happens that everybody agrees this time.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by Angostura on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:47AM (#11922277)
> but they didn't halt trading until they were asked to, so clearly it wasn't totally in their interests?

I didn't stop eating excess salt until my doctor asked me to do so - and it was totally in my interest.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by TillE on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:20PM (#11923978)
A surprising number of people seem to believe in the near-perfect efficiency of markets, that every participant is making optimal decisions based on their own goals.

This is, of course, absurdly optimistic.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by pron on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:44AM (#11921834)
Why, has anyone thought that decentralization means no one has a lot of power? I figured that people who prefer decentralizations prefer feudal power over centralized power.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by forgetsusername on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:10AM (#11922403)
>and can't simply press a button or send out an order

And the governmental powers-that-be can press a button and prevent citizens from exchanging cash?

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by carver on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:29AM (#11922501)
The US government freezes bank accounts all the time.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by forgetsusername on Monday June 20, 2016 @09:22AM (#11937813)
Bank accounts aren't cash. They're a ledger of your balance with the bank.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by jonnycowboy on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:18AM (#11922442)
Yes, easily by devaluing the currency.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by forgetsusername on Monday June 20, 2016 @09:25AM (#11937828)
Governmental currency printing has zero effect on the negotiated transaction between two people, and it does precisely nothing on my ability to choose to continue using that currency. That's the underlying freedom; use dollars or blueberry scones if you want. You just need to find a willing counter-party.

The anti-fiat crowd should think for a minute on how money actually works in practice.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by curiousgal on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:01AM (#11921662)
Huh? What does halting trading has to do with compromising decentralization? You do know what "decentralization" mean right?
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by mpeg on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:35AM (#11921795)
They're now talking about essentially blacklisting the hacker's ETH address, how is that decentralised?

Halting trading is a show of force too, if they believed a single thing of what they preach they'd let the free market continue its course with the hacker walking away with the money.

Looking at your comment history it seems clear you have an agenda here, so I'll ignore the ad hominem.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by parasubvert on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:56AM (#11921880)
Decentralization doesn't mean complete lack of central control, or anarchy, it means that balance of power is in the periphery with the broader organization largely controlled by protocol and policy. Issuing an edict in a crisis doesn't necessarily imply centralization if the member nodes can ignore the edict.

In the history of organization structures, for example, Peter Drucker in 1946 wrote the "Concept of the Corporation", a study on General Motors, which was arguably one of the early detailed studies of Decentralized governance in an organization.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by Bud on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:04AM (#11922106)
The "free market"? I don't think that's what "free market" means.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by tremon on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:21AM (#11921962)
how is that decentralised? [..] Halting trading is a show of force too

Decentralisation does not preclude "force". The one really has nothing to do with the other. Unless your idea of "decentralization" is actually the solipsist view that every person is an island, and social structures hold no benefit for survival.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by codingmyway on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:38AM (#11922006)
If it takes a vast majority of participants to agree, then not really. It's decentralized, not 100% immutable. Will get harder as it gets larger but at this stage it is good to still have the ability.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by viraptor on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:58AM (#11922328)
Vast majority however means most mining pools. In practice that's not that many people making the decision.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by codingmyway on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:29AM (#11922500)
At this stage yes. That's why I don't hold ether as being solid enough yet to be a store of value, aside from the fact that it's being inflated at ~25% pa. Needs to go through these teething problems now while that is still the case.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by xg15 on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:15AM (#11923107)
Why would that be different at later stages? Bitcoin grew more centralized with time, not decentralized: The miners with the most powerful equipment also have the most ability to become even more powerful.

Why is that different for Ethereum?

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by xorcist on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:16PM (#11925280)
It's not that simple. In the end it's what users actually use that matters. Mining on a fork that sees no use would be suicidal. So miners need to follow users, or their investment is for nothing. And users tend to follow developers, at least until there is a contentious fork.

So while there is no clear single party that makes decisions, active developers have the most say.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by codingmyway on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:32PM (#11923623)
It's not that it's centralised, it's that the cost of the precedent set by a fork and rollback doesn't mean it is seen as a terminal failure.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by codingmyway on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:30AM (#11922508)
As 'fuel' for programming smart contracts it's still a valuable tool but it doesn't make writing those contracts easy.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by oelmekki on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:11AM (#11921705)
And if it can't be stopped, the argument about decentralized apps being "unstoppable" won't be that appealing anymore after all :)

It's sad, being able to write blockchain apps like with ethereum and lisk is cool tech, but we'll have to deal with the idea that once is out, it's out. Programming NASA style.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by ultramancool on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:37AM (#11923265)
> If this hack can be stopped, then it demonstrates that the currency can be manipulated, that the decentralised system is not so fault tolerant or uncensored after all, and that people out there know this.

My thought exactly. And despite putting a little money into the DAO myself, this is the kind of risk I was willing to take. I should lose my money. Miners should vote strongly against this fork.

I know in the Bitcoin community this wouldn't be accepted, not so sure about Ethereum though where the developers have a lot more control (than they should IMO).

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by vessenes on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:24AM (#11922782)
This is FUD, broadly speaking. The devs have put out a patch for miners which allows them to decide whether or not they wish to fork over these transactions. Centralization is not required for this decision, instead, distributed consensus.

The counterpoint to your statements is simply that consumers need safety with their money. It is no badge of honor to let unsophisticated technical people lose money for some extreme libertarian ideals.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by forgotpwtomain on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:00AM (#11923003)
> This is FUD, broadly speaking. The devs have put out a patch for miners which allows them to decide whether or not they wish to fork over these transactions. Centralization is not required for this decision, instead, distributed consensus.

With all respect Peter, this is not FUD and OP is raising a valid concern. Yes, the miners vote on the patch - but given the infant state of the ecosystem and the large loss incurred, even further controversy or delay in finding a resolution may cause them permanent economic harm; so it would appear that there is little leeway in the choice involved.

> The counterpoint to your statements is simply that consumers need safety with their money. It is no badge of honor to let unsophisticated technical people lose money for some extreme libertarian ideals.

Yes, that's certainly the argument, particularly that if there is majority agreement than the protocol change is justified. But this doesn't at all invalidate OP's concern that fundamentally algorithmic contract's aren't binding if such an alteration can be adopted. The case could be made that in a more mature ecosystem such case specific alterations are more potentially damaging than useful and that this is a transitional phase, yet I think the burden of proof is on the one responding.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by vessenes on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:14PM (#11925267)
>so it would appear that there is little leeway in the choice involved.

I think we agree on this. The reality is that an active choice will still have to be made by a consensus group, though. It's not a matter of something being forced down the throats of a majority by an oligarchy, it's utilizing the existing consensus mechanism.

I think OP should be well warned here as to what is binding with smart contracts, for sure. This isn't any different than risk calculations in Bitcoin, though -- early days advice was to wait six blocks for transactions over $20, because the cost of subverting the network was very low. This is part of the give and take of mining and distributed consensus with current technologies.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by vessenes on Friday June 17, 2016 @11:00PM (#11926824)
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by pYQAJ6Zm on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:49AM (#11922932)
I agree with your points. But the miners who actually have a say, if I am not mistaken, are the big ones and the pool owners. These are just a small fraction of all people running mining software.

A soft fork will undeniably require distributed consensus. It is the number of people with the actual right to vote that may be worrisome.

Perhaps the pool owners should extend their voting rights to their pool contributors, pooling votes as they pool mining shares.

(Disclaimer: I hold a small amount of ETH and participate in a mining pool.)

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by vessenes on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:27PM (#11924525)
Or, pool owners could announce their position, and you could switch pools. This has happened in Bitcoin, albeit very occasionally.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by jpereira on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:38AM (#11922005)
It looks like the developers are proposing a soft fork to block certain transactions, followed by a hard fork to allow retrieval of funds.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4oiqj7/critical_u...

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by DennisP on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:16AM (#11921943)
The only way any of that can happen is if most of the community agrees to run the software implementing the change. If you know of a way to get more decentralized than that, I'd like to hear about it.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by nullc on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:58AM (#11921429)
> all the talk of blockchains being decentralised

All the talk of /ethereum/ being decentralized.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:11AM (#11921489)
True! It's definitely a situation where the 'market cap' of bitcoin gives it some extra stability. If the DAO contained bitcoins, it would be a far smaller % of the total and there would be fewer calls to roll back the logs.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by ottodev on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:56AM (#11921646)
If there is network consensus to do the rollback, then the blockchain stays decentralised.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:34AM (#11921794)
What is 'network consensus'? It certainly isn't giving everyone a vote as to whether they think the rollback is a good idea or not. Instead, it's connected people wielding influence.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by riprowan on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:03PM (#11923432)
A majority of hashpower as "ratified" by a sufficient number of nodes and holders.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by parasubvert on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:01AM (#11921897)
Connected people always have influence in any human system, because, you know, emotions.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by 746F7475 on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:26AM (#11921761)
So can random people who agree with each other completely control everything that happens with the currency? So if there is a company who they dislike can they just decide that they have no money?
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by verroq on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:32AM (#11921786)
Majority of ethereum holders would want to rollback. That is consensus. If they don't hard fork they can keep running an old node. What is the problem?
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by caf on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:03AM (#11922667)
The incentive here isn't to pick the side of the fork you agree with; it's to pick the side of the fork you believe will win. So you can't really say that the rollback side winning means that most miners agreed with the rollback - rather it means that most miners thought the rollback side would win. There's a strong element of "self-fulfilling prophesy" here.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by 1019301911 on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:47AM (#11921842)
How do you know? Of course, it could be established using "safe" blockchain voting technology...
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by verroq on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:27AM (#11921977)
The longest fork wins.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by detaro on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:47AM (#11922036)
Isn't that basically measuring which side has more hashing power? It's not obvious to me why that necessarily represents "the majority of ethereum holders". Or am I missing a mechanism?
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by wolfgke on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:36AM (#11922239)
The hashing power is the voting power. Since it is not obvious how one could even define what "the majority of ethereum holders" even means (and who says that every ethereum holder who is a physical person has to have the same voting power? If this were the case one would simply split your ethereum "account" into many who are hold by stooges).
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by glaberficken on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:58AM (#11921885)
Majority is consensus?
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by parasubvert on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:07AM (#11921909)
It has been proven impossible to reach full consensus at scale in a fully decentralized, asynchronous system (the FLP theorem).

So, in computer science terms, consensus algorithms are about approximating distributed consensus in the face of benign and malicious threats or communication failures, which devolves to "quorum / majority" pretty quickly in a crisis.

After the crisis, some kind of compensation, reconciliation or excommunication has to happen with the portion that disagreed.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by 746F7475 on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:11AM (#11922130)
So that means if you are against majority thought you are shit out of luck. Just think of any time when majority consensus hasn't been the optimal solution.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by wolfgke on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:38AM (#11922247)
If you believe that there is a better way to find a consensus in a distributed system than majority you are free to implement a system based on it. I consider it as quite plausible that such a system exists, but cannot even imagine how it might look like.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by tunesmith on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:59PM (#11925195)
There is a better way but it unfortunately requires the system to have an understanding of what the decision is about - in other words, no longer decoupling the mechanics of the decision from the meaning of the decision.

A distributed system can easily make a majority decision that is unwise, like if the votes are based off of bad information. But if the different options of the decision could be formalized and checked/proven as part of the decision making process, based off of axioms and values that participants all agree on, then perhaps the most rational decision could be selected even if it's not what the majority was initially in favor of.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by abrkn on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:09AM (#11922702)
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by Everhusk on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:13PM (#11923900)
Also just remember, that Rome was not built in one day. Progressing mankind with a functioning DAO is most likely worth much more than even a $200M failure (worst case scenario) if you look at how it could increase world productivity/efficiency.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by ewams on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:27PM (#11924989)
The developers appear to be treating this as a dev environment - "We were starting a new team (welcome @hiddentao, @evertonfraga and @luclu) and I was pushing for weekly releases, without proper testing. Meanwhile the DAO happened, and we wanted to make a release that had support for events subscription without realizing the performance impact it would have..."

https://github.com/ethereum/mist/releases/tag/0.7.5

I realize this is the wallet development but they are absolutely related and shows the culture of this software is not as professional or thought out as it should be.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by kachnuv_ocasek on Friday June 17, 2016 @10:16AM (#11922738)
But if the hack can't be stopped, then… it demonstrates that the currency can't be manipulated…? Wait a minute.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by ThomPete on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:08AM (#11922390)
It's a size issue not a security issue or put another way the insecurity is the small size.

Once it gets bigger the security goes up as events like this affect the currency less and less.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by alvarosm on Friday June 17, 2016 @12:34PM (#11923636)
Hopefully this will make the idiot "investors" realize what a piece of crap Ethereum (and anything related) is.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by btrask on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:56AM (#11921413)
We already knew that blockchains are vulnerable to 51% attacks. There are real problems with points of centralization (including the developers), but events like this don't prove anything.

Edit: to be clear, the 51% attack I'm referring to is actually the defense of the network by developers/miners/users that the parent post is complaining about.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:13AM (#11921503)
They do if the developers suddenly come up with schemes to block the attack or hack the DAO. vbuterin has posted on reddit a plea for any DAO holders who were about to 'split' their holdings to contact him - presumably he has a way to hack the DAO more effectively and so grab the money before the attackers grab it.

But when did he know how to do this? Was it a secret that he was sitting on, or has he only learnt about it from the existing attack?

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by johncolanduoni on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:00AM (#11921437)
If this is just a 51% attack then we didn't learn anything about etherium qua etherium or blockchains qua blockchains... but we'll learn something about the lower bound for being big enough that they're not a realistic possibility.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:09AM (#11921476)
It's an interesting question - is the DAO 'too big to fail' ?

I wonder how different ether will turn out to be, will they bail it out by rolling back the blockchain?

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by buttershakes on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:23AM (#11921534)
Rolling back the blockchain would have some pretty serious ramifications, as the possibility of that becomes greater it makes sense to sell as quickly as possible into another chain to retain value.