News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by infodroid on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:18AM (#11921731)
I think you're missing the point. The fact that one man can bring the whole of Ethereum trading to a halt with an announcement really demonstrates just how much power he has. So it doesn't matter that he doesn't have a physical kill switch if the end result is the same.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by vintermann on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:16AM (#11922146)
He wouldn't have that power in just any old circumstance. He could have the power to launch nukes, but if that power would only work if all of the world agrees, I'd still not be afraid of him.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by weego on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:23AM (#11921751)
I mean, they don't have to honor the request to do so.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by wolfgke on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:30AM (#11922211)
> I think you're missing the point. The fact that one man can bring the whole of Ethereum trading to a halt with an announcement really demonstrates just how much power he has.

The reason for this is that ethereum exchanges are not decentralized and the "program" that the owners of the exchanges execute on their brains partly allows "dynamic mental code update" by Vitalik Buterin.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by curiousgal on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:30AM (#11921776)
The announcement didn't come out of the blue. Exchanges don't want stolen funds to go through them so it is also in their interest to halt trading.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:20AM (#11921955)
...but they didn't halt trading until they were asked to, so clearly it wasn't totally in their interests?

Exchanges are in a difficult position once the 'head' of ethereum tells them to stop. It's a sign that the blockchain might be forked, so any further trades they make might be undone - they simply have little choice but to stop after being told to do so.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by mcherm on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:27AM (#11922195)
> but they didn't halt trading until they were asked to, so clearly it wasn't totally in their interests?

Not at all. This is a classic "coordination problem". It is advantageous for many participants in the overall system to take an action, but only if the other participants are ALSO taking the action. In such a case, a widely followed and popular leader is one possible coordinating mechanism. And it does not give that popular leader the ability to do ANYTHING, only things that actually ARE popular but require coordination.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by joosters on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:42AM (#11922264)
a widely followed and popular leader is one possible coordinating mechanism.

That's the exact opposite of decentralized. Are we going to have to redefine the word?

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by viraptor on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:04AM (#11922373)
I don't agree. Centralised control would mean one person can change anything. Decentralised doesn't mean that nobody can propose a solution - only that others have to agree on it before it goes live.

How do you imagine decentralised decisions happening otherwise? Everyone choosing their own solution without ever talking to each other and seeing what is most popular?

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by mcherm on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:09PM (#11923868)
I'm not sure whether we are redefining it... I suppose it depends on what definition you were starting with!

My idea of "decentralized" includes things like "continues to function perfectly well if any one person or small group is removed from the process" and "continues to function perfectly well if any one person or small group becomes malicious".

In this case, if Vitalik Buterin were not around to announce the problem, someone else could announce it and that would provide a coordinating signal for all of the independent players to act on. If Vitalik Buterin were malicious and decided to announce a rollback of a big spend he had done, then the independent miners and mining pool operators would (I hope) choose to ignore the announcement and refuse to participate.

I guess to me, having a centralized group or individual make decisions seems to violate "decentralized", but having one of several possible groups or individuals make announcements which signal the population to take action does not.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by vertex-four on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:01AM (#11922349)
Nobody has to follow the leader. Want to keep your exchange trading? Go ahead - nobody can stop you. It just so happens that everybody agrees this time.
Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by Angostura on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:47AM (#11922277)
> but they didn't halt trading until they were asked to, so clearly it wasn't totally in their interests?

I didn't stop eating excess salt until my doctor asked me to do so - and it was totally in my interest.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by TillE on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:20PM (#11923978)
A surprising number of people seem to believe in the near-perfect efficiency of markets, that every participant is making optimal decisions based on their own goals.

This is, of course, absurdly optimistic.

Re:Critical Update on DAO Vulnerability by pron on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:44AM (#11921834)
Why, has anyone thought that decentralization means no one has a lot of power? I figured that people who prefer decentralizations prefer feudal power over centralized power.