Not all the tech companies that were hot in 1999 were like pets.com. Google and Amazon were amazing new things back then, and other companies like Dell, Sun and Qualcomm were also high fliers on the NASDAQ. (I'm old enough to have been an investor in 1999.)
I think the most significant difference between the 1999 bubble and today's situation is that today, many of the companies with astronomical valuations are not public. For example, if Uber's valuation tanks, some employees and some rich investors will unfortunately lose money, but most people will see little effect - if you have a 401-K invested in an S&P 500 index fund, you won't care too much. And the big public tech companies that are making money, like Google, Amazon, Apple and Facebook, probably won't be affected much if all venture backed companies disappeared tomorrow (except that their labor market would be flooded with developers). The NASDAQ might take a dip, but it won't be like 1999.
Nowadays it often seems the other way around - the technology is there, but the economics are questionable. The disconnect between valuation and even the most optimistic revenue projections for something like a chat app or a picture-sharing site can reach two orders of magnitude in the wrong direction. The market for tech companies themselves has become completely disconnected from the market for those companies' products and services.
1. The ephemerality makes me feel less self-conscious about the quality of the picture. It's going away momentarily, never to be seen again, so all I care about is conveying what is happening in the moment, not getting the perfect shot.
2. It's fast. Snapchat sacrifices image quality for speed to some extent, and the interface is faster and more fluid, particularly for broadcasting a snap to multiple people.
These things combine to make sending snaps feel very conversational. When I think of sending an image by text it feels like a hassle, and i'll only do it if it's a picture I want someone to have for more than 10 seconds.
I'm not sure if this explanation totally conveys my meaning, but in using it, it is quite clear to me that there is indeed something categorically different between snapchat and MMS texting, though it is admittedly somewhat hard to pin down what that is.
It allows you to express yourself via images in a fundamentally different way. To simply photograph/record the thing happening in front of you because it was funny or amusing for a second, but not have to ask yourself the question "is this worth preserving forever?". It turns a snap into the equivalent of throwaway, idle verbal conversation.
Texts/instagram are the written letters of the digital age. Careful, considered (and if not, people think you're an idiot and look down on you). Snaps are in-person chatter. They don't have to be super meaningful or well composed, just the digital equivalent of "how about this weather we're having".
I wonder if it's mostly just network effect? Here pretty much everyone already has whatsapp so you just use that instead of registering/installing a new service/app.
But I have discussed Snapchat with the youngsters at my work. They all "get it" in a way that I don't seem to. And we use it for advertising, and it brings in revenue (our target market is aged 18-25).
Color[1]? Theranos? uBeam? Clinkle? Those crazy things are absolutely happening now, but the scale is important to know. (I don't know how the scale compares to the dotcom bubble.)
"and then going public all within a year."
1) it was founded after the tech bubble
2) it succeeded (or, at least, still operates)
3) had patents and a founding team with a string of successes in the industry
I always felt they were like a social outlet for folks to waste time and their only revenue stream was advertising.
I used to think like this too. Then I went on an overseas trip with a group of thirty baby-boomers (parents' friends). What I saw blew my mind.
Despite the fact that most people on the group could barely use a computer, they were very savvy and frequent WhatsApp users. They had created a group prior to the trip and everyone was a member, and throughout the trip the app was used to coordinate meeting times, share cool finds, joke around and exchange photos taken with the rest of the group. If a sub-group split up from the main group for a few hours, they quickly created their own group within the app, and then discarded it after joining with the main group. All within seconds. Even the several 70+ year olds in the group were using it and having a great time.
Then I realized: WhatsApp is an easier-to-use, more reliable, more secure and free version of SMS. That's why it's a big deal.
I'm not quite sure what happened to make this possible, but I think one related factor has to do with prepaid cell phone plans being more normal and less the exception, and very conscious data usage.
But I would say "like SMS, only doesn't cost money even when sending abroad" is the killer feature in my extended family.
However, sending a text message internationally — when I'm traveling to another country — is totally different and the rate is insane: $0.25/$0.50 per SMS/MMS sent. So they essentially force you to buy a special 30-day international texting bundle to be able to keep in touch with your friends back home.
The rates for data abroad from U.S. carriers are even worse: $60 for 300MB. I'm anxiously awaiting a "Whatsapp for cell data" style plan. How do you handle that?
Sure, email existed and even my grandmother started using it years ago. But email wasn't as ubiquitous to daily life.
Over here, WhatsApp is used by teachers to communicate with students, my driving instructor to set up appointments and let me know he's at the door, my parents to share random bits of their life in the family group, my friends to just meet up and have an ongoing pointless conversation, my colleagues to figure out who's in the office and when, people my various 'associations' to discuss when to meet and what to do, clients who want to know if I'm available, and so on.
The amazing thing is not WhatsApp as an app or what it's used for. It's the fact that everybody does it.
Where do they make the majority of their money? Is it advertising? or is it investments that they have made with public money? I am curious what their profits look like that their valuation is 328 Billion dollars.
There's clearly value because lots of people use it. You don't need any technical breakthroughs to create value. Possibly to monetize it but not to create it.
Btw. the underlying technology is pretty cool imo but that's besides the point. I mean they had what 30 engineers when they were bought (for about 500 million users)? Erlang yay.
To those of you like me I recommend you to read about what was happening in 95-99. The panorama was crazy, and today's context doesn't compare to the one of those days.
At the end, if the macroeconomic environment changes, who cares? Yes, paying attention to the macro is important and that may even imply changes in strategy, but should you not start a startup because there's a bubble? Even worse, should you (person who hasn't built anything but criticizes everyone who builds something) try to convince your friends not to start startups because we're in a bubble?
The main difference between today and 1999 is that digital products are actually generating value in people's lifes. Please don't compare pets.com to WhatsApp