Re:The U.S. Navy’s Big Mistake: Building Tons of Supercarriers
by emptyfile on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @11:46AM
(#11902765)
I really don't have time to discuss with you, but I just have to ask, magnitude of what? Magnitude of economy? How do you measure that?
How could you possibly compare the total, unprecedented industrialized warfare of WW1 with the American civil war?
It bears no resemblance whatsoever.
But to paraphrase Stalin, magnitude has a quality all its own. Which is why I don't consider the brief Austro-Prussian and Franco-Prussian wars, while of incredible political significance, to be of great significance in the discussion I raised. Neither mobilized an entire economy much less both sides'.
(Big exception to what I just wrote: they did prove the value of the Prussian General Staff model).
Disclaimer: I do have a degree in European military history, but my scholarship, for what little it might be worth, is over 30 years out of date.