News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hockeybias on Monday June 13, 2016 @01:28PM (#11895590)
I don't say this in a mean-spirited way whatsoever, but your sex is whatever sex you were born with. There is nothing complicated about that fact. With rare exception, a person comes into the world as a male or female.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by ubernostrum on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:27PM (#11896057)
First off, it's likely that "sex" is much harder to define than you'd think. Human genitals all develop from the same proto-bits, creating more of a spectrum of configurations than a stark "clearly this one" or "clearly that one" binary. And chromosomes are not super useful either; just taking stats for two conditions off the top of my head, there are probably at least 1.75 million people walking around who are genitally "male" but chromosomally "female" -- the difficulty of detection (you have to literally look at someone's DNA) masks a lot of that stuff, and probably it's even more common than we currently estimate.

Second, "sex" in legal terms (for identity documents, etc.) is rarely necessarily tied to genitals or chromosomes, and more often is tied to a set of expectations about how the designated person will appear or behave. So even though the legal system uses "sex", what they're really describing is "gender".

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by TruthAndDare on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:39PM (#11896172)
> "sex" in legal terms (for identity documents, etc.) is rarely necessarily tied to genitals or chromosomes, and more often is tied to a set of expectations about how the designated person will appear or behave.

When you put it that way, it really becomes unclear to me why it should be there at all. If we're not describing what type of biological creature a person is, and simply how they can be expected to behave, it seems like we might as well write down if the person is ill-tempered or meek, and if he or she likes to dance the waltz or the tango.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by ubernostrum on Monday June 13, 2016 @04:02PM (#11897046)
If we're not describing what type of biological creature a person is

Can you think of a reason why every single document about a person needs to note "what type of biological creature" they are? I'll give you a hint: there aren't a lot of good reasons for it :)

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by TruthAndDare on Monday June 13, 2016 @05:27PM (#11897818)
That wasn't what I was arguing.

Regardless of whether or not we're documening sex, why document gender if it is only "a set of expectations about how the designated person will appear or behave"?

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by dllthomas on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @11:49AM (#11902806)
We care a lot about how we expect other people to behave - in many cases, completely appropriately.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by nostrebored on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:33PM (#11896129)
>Second, "sex" in legal terms (for identity documents, etc.) is rarely necessarily tied to genitals or chromosomes, and more often is tied to a set of expectations about how the designated person will appear or behave. So even though the legal system uses "sex", what they're really describing is "gender".

Really? I would say genitals as a heuristic for your legal status is probably extremely accurate.

Are you denying that humans are sexually dimorphic?

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by ubernostrum on Monday June 13, 2016 @04:00PM (#11897029)
I would say genitals as a heuristic for your legal status is probably extremely accurate.

So, what sort of legal things do you think require possession of a particular type of genitals? To paraphrase the memes about gendered toys, there's nothing I'm aware of in the legal system that's operated directly by a penis or a vagina.

And really when you get into it you'll find that the things people want this information for tend to be things that aren't all that great to do (read: discriminating against people on the basis of sex, or trying to use a discrepancy between reported "sex" and identified "gender" to discriminate or deny access/rights to things).

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:45PM (#11896259)
Humans are sexually multimorphic, although a two-component principal component analysis takes care of most of the variance.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by Avshalom on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:39PM (#11896184)
The thing about "heuristics" in this case is that it's a fifty-cent word for "generalizations" and generalizations are almost universally insufficient. Especially when it comes to a legal system.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by nostrebored on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:42PM (#11896216)
What regarding the "generalization" of sexual dimorphism causes legal issues, in your estimation?
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by Avshalom on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:57PM (#11896343)
The Olympics actually gave up on sex testing once (not sure if they started again or not) because it turns out trying to lump people into two categories is an exercise nonsensical exclusion. Also both historically and currently there have been various category beyond "two" that have had legal distinctions.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_gender

And of course we've got shit going on right now in the USA like http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-north-carolina-bathrooms... where that sexual dimorphism (thanks in some cases to modern science and in some cases to the the non-binary nature of human genetics) where that "di"-morphism (morphism meaning shape or appearance) directly contradicts the theoretical intent of some law or another.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by nostrebored on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:10PM (#11896458)
An exercise in nonsensical exclusion? Men taking testosterone blockers still have more testosterone than women at the third standard deviation. There are skeletal differences in men that create an advantage in a number of high-impact sports.

"Third gender" is bullshit precisely because it tries to create a preexisting dichotomy that doesn't exist. I'm not a masculine caricature. My wife is not a feminine caricature. The people you meet day to day aren't walking gendered cliches.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by Avshalom on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:15PM (#11896522)
You wanted examples where genitals where an insufficient distinction for the legal system? You're free to argue about why they were insufficient or whether they should be/have-been sufficient but there they are.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by nostrebored on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:33PM (#11896725)
Mmm. I moved the goalposts in my second reply to 'where sexual dimorphism is insufficient'. Sorry if that created confusion.

I still maintain that genitalia are a very good heuristic for determining someone's sex.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:48PM (#11896281)
It fails to account for edge cases, and much like software engineering, in law edge cases are 90% of the work.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by nostrebored on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:52PM (#11896314)
Which edge cases? Providing a specific example would be enlightening, because as I see it the denial of sexual dimorphism typically co-opts the lives and lived experiences of intersex people or people with AIS to further the goal of a completely distinct group.

There have been legal issues regarding intersex people being mutilated at birth, but that "edge case" has been sorted out.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:11PM (#11896475)
Pre-operational transsexual people and transgendered people who decide against surgery but live as a gender different from their birth one anyway are two edge cases where genitalia are a poor indicator of what their legal status should be. As for intersex people, how does the blurring (aka "denial") of sexual dimorphism diminish progress towards recognition and improving quality of life for them? If co-option does not detract from their lives and their struggles, what is the problem with co-option? Equality is not a zero-sum game, except maybe for those who discriminate.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by nostrebored on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:25PM (#11896640)
I fail to see how when for all intents and purposes when they are men who adopt the social construct of femininity how their legal status is in any way poorly indicated. Intersex people are still sexually dimorphic. Genitalia is one of a number of ways that someone's sex is determined. Viewing them as the sole way is a mistake, sure there are things like AIS, but even in the case of intersex people, their genitalia and secondary sexual characteristics typically develop in a normal fashion.

Co-option does typically detract from their struggles. By using intersex people as a tool to push a political agenda you detract from the serious issues that surround their legal and medical troubles.

You can't pretend that the actions you take while pursuing a political agenda don't have positive or negative consequences. When equality in the case that you're advocating for comes at the cost of the groups you're purporting to help, or the groups that you use as part of your political narrative, then something is probably wrong.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by ubernostrum on Monday June 13, 2016 @09:27PM (#11899140)
I'm still waiting to hear what part of the legal system requires specific genitalia to operate, since that's the only reason I can think of for needing legal documentation to care about what genitals someone has.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by Avshalom on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:29PM (#11896669)
"Viewing them as the sole way is a mistake"

! ! So you completely agree with us.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by DasIch on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:39PM (#11896175)
Why rely on a heuristic, when you can do better?
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:22PM (#11896018)
Your legal sex (gender is a much more appropriate term) is whatever your legal documents say you are, regardless of whatever sexual indicators (anatomical and genetic) you have.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by seanp2k2 on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:33PM (#11896125)
Sure, but consider how that's determined in the first place.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:13PM (#11896495)
Prescriptively or descriptively? Because how it's done isn't always right, and what's right isn't always how it's done.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by themartorana on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:24PM (#11896032)
Do you believe a person has the right to change it? Some people are born with both male and female genitalia - as many as 1 in 2000. There are also chromosomal differences that show up - not XX or XY. Here are some of the frequencies of this:

http://www.isna.org/faq/frequency

I agree with you that biologically, the majority of people are born with a well-definite biological sex. But the fact that there is an actual biological set of people that aren't XX or XY, however, means not even in birth is gender guaranteed to be deterministic.

"I think, therefore I am" lends itself to gender identity, for me, anyway. Biology isn't 100%, and identity is even less so. Let people be what they want. I don't see where non-sex-identifying is really troubling.

Edit: thinking about it more, is gender on documents used as one measure against fraud? Or as a way of protecting against potential sexual crimes? We have sexually separated things like bathrooms and prisons, and I wouldn't advocate for mixed-sex prisons (is there an argument for that I don't know?) so sexual identity and gender can't go away completely, right?

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by nostrebored on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:39PM (#11896181)
First, the phrase you're looking for is sexually deterministic.

6 out of 10,000 babies are born without fully formed limbs. Is describing homo-sapiens as bipeds with four limbs no longer correct then? Where is the brink of acceptability for you?

I find disputing the notion that human beings are sexually dimorphic to be an overreach.

There are in fact arguments that transgender inmates should go to the prison that matches the gender that they identify with. This has (obviously) gone poorly a number of times so far. Another argument you can make is that self identification of gender skews statistics regarding violence by sex. For instance, even if 0.3% of men are transgender, given the huge disparity in violence by sex, you will see the differences start to narrow.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by dragonwriter on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:44PM (#11896249)
> But the fact that there is an actual biological set of people that aren't XX or XY

And that, e.g., people who have Swyer syndrome (missing sex-determining-region-Y on the Y chromosome) are XY but more "female" in phenotype (and in development, with the usual course of treatment.)

> I wouldn't advocate for mixed-sex prisons (is there an argument for that I don't know?)

I'm not sure what the case against it is supposed to be; AFAICT, the main basis for segregation is implicitly (no one ever comes right out explicitly and makes this argument in full, but usually just makes vague handwaving toward sexual interaction and power dynamics that implies it without actually making an argument) based in the presumption that everyone is a cisgendered heterosexual, and that sexual drive and activity only occur with the availability of members of one's normally preferred sex, so that if you segregate by sex you avoid temptation for sexual interaction and associated power dynamics, violence, etc.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:03PM (#11896403)
IMHO if you're going to segregate prison populations in order to reduce violence, segregate prisoners by aggressiveness and violent tendencies, not by sex. Putting dominant, aggressive men together with passive men just because of their gender makes less sense than putting together men and women in the same prison.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by legodt on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:16PM (#11895964)
Sex and gender are separate concepts. Sex is a basic biological function that is no longer relevant to ascribe anything to beyond that. Gender, a social construct, has been tightly wound up with sex for so long now that breaking down the binary is important to moving forward. Male and female in a pure sex perspective are no longer relevant to gender identity in progressive society.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by ambrop7 on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:23PM (#11896024)
That is a reasonable way of looking at this, but the question is which concept belongs on your documents. The corresponding field on my (EU-based) passport says sex not gender - don't know how it is in the US.

Your sex is something that is fixed and can be verified (as noted, with very rare exceptions). By this logic, your gender is your own decision. So I think sex has a better place in ID documents. Also I think having the biological sex on your documents can be useful medically - surely you want emergency responders / doctors to be able to tell your biological sex, for medical reasons.

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:40PM (#11896192)
Agreed for the most part, but if sex is something that can be verified, why would having sex on your ID be all that useful to emergency responders and doctors? Can't they...verify it?
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by TruthAndDare on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:48PM (#11896280)
I don't think you can do, or have time to do, a genetic test as an emergency responder, if that's what you mean. But is that really why we put it on documents anyway?
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:53PM (#11896316)
Genetic tests are unnecessary for emergency responders, as physiological sex is what matters to them, and if physiological sex is easily verified, then they can verify it on the spot.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by TruthAndDare on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:24PM (#11896036)
> Sex is a basic biological function that is no longer relevant to ascribe anything to beyond that.

No longer? Was it previously but isn't any more? What happened to make this so?

And why would gender have any function? Can't we just disregard it?

Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by Avshalom on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:33PM (#11896126)
As to the second paragraph: in a "perfect" world yeah gender would probably be meaningless and yeah we could disregard it. But in the real world if you have one group of people that says "I don't 'see' gender" on the one side and the North Carolina legislature on the other side: the first group loses. Every Time.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by legodt on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:44PM (#11896247)
We are past the point where reproduction is the goal of our identity and existence.
Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex by TruthAndDare on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:51PM (#11896302)
Really? That notion seems alive and well to me. Maybe it's not important to you.