Re:Oregon Court Allows a Person to Choose Neither Sex
by hx87 on Monday June 13, 2016 @03:03PM
(#11896403)
IMHO if you're going to segregate prison populations in order to reduce violence, segregate prisoners by aggressiveness and violent tendencies, not by sex. Putting dominant, aggressive men together with passive men just because of their gender makes less sense than putting together men and women in the same prison.
And that, e.g., people who have Swyer syndrome (missing sex-determining-region-Y on the Y chromosome) are XY but more "female" in phenotype (and in development, with the usual course of treatment.)
> I wouldn't advocate for mixed-sex prisons (is there an argument for that I don't know?)
I'm not sure what the case against it is supposed to be; AFAICT, the main basis for segregation is implicitly (no one ever comes right out explicitly and makes this argument in full, but usually just makes vague handwaving toward sexual interaction and power dynamics that implies it without actually making an argument) based in the presumption that everyone is a cisgendered heterosexual, and that sexual drive and activity only occur with the availability of members of one's normally preferred sex, so that if you segregate by sex you avoid temptation for sexual interaction and associated power dynamics, violence, etc.