News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by dominotw on Sunday June 12, 2016 @10:08PM (#11891346)
This is hilarious

https://www.glassdoor.com/Reviews/Employee-Review-Theranos-R...

  Advice to Management
 You are doing a good job. Stay in better touch with the 
 employees. I think most people do feel appreciated but 
 there are also some that are disgruntled and unhappy for
 other reasons. I see these people spreading negative energy.
 You should seek them and try and fix the problem.
Is it common practice among upstart companies to pad their reviews on glassdoor. I've been using those as references for my job search, I know better now.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by randycupertino on Monday June 13, 2016 @12:12AM (#11891697)
My old job made us write positive reviews on company time. Basically anywhere that says, "keep doing what you are doing" as the advice to management and/or the reviews are ALL either 1 star or 5 star reviews, you know they are fake.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by avn2109 on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:59PM (#11896356)
When they make you write reviews, the trick is to write a very glowing one, including several perks that you wish you had but don't. e.g. "Great company, love the 20% own-projects time and work-from-home Fridays." This has all kinds of good effects:

1) It subtly anchors execs and HR to accept your perk as reasonable, especially because the people paying attention to Glassdoor are far removed from your manager and don't actually know if you have those perks or not. "Since our company already does it, it must be a good idea," thinks the exec.

2) Your coworkers see the reviews and assume the perks are true but unevenly distributed, thereby further ingraining the perks in the company zeitgeist.

3) If you are eventually found out, nobody will ask you to write reviews any more.

and 4) Candidates, including good candidates, will come to interviews and say things like "I've heard you have 20% time, that's a great idea, tell me more about it." This fans the flames in favor of your perks.

I used this technique as part of a wildly successful give-us-more-perks agitation campaign in my previous job.

Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by new_hackers on Monday June 13, 2016 @09:23PM (#11899122)
You sir or madam are and evil genius! My hat off to you!
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by tim333 on Monday June 13, 2016 @09:28AM (#11893643)
I note on the reviews the "Helpful" click count gives some indication as to how relevant they are. I see

> Everyday brings new challenges, and you are able to approach these challenges with autonomy and creativity.

gets Helpful (1) and

>"House of Cards comes crashing down"

...A front row seat and education how to adulterate documents and strategy!

gets Helpful (76)

Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by fennecfoxen on Monday June 13, 2016 @04:52AM (#11892461)
> I've been using those as references for my job search, I know better now.

Eh, that just means you can't take the reviews at face value. Ignore the obviously disgruntled employees, treat fluff reviews as a small yellow flag, and look for the real dirt not so much in the angry reviews but in the disappointed ones.

Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by bduerst on Monday June 13, 2016 @07:43AM (#11892992)
It's like dealing with Amazon reviews, which are also gamed.

You look at the low ratings, and if they're coherent and make sense to you then take them seriously. If more then one make the same claims, then it's probably true.

Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by ryguytilidie on Monday June 13, 2016 @09:55AM (#11893866)
Well that plus I've had two separate situations where I left a negative review and was threatened until I took it down. Not sure you're going to see many unbiased views there...
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by dhimes on Monday June 13, 2016 @10:12AM (#11894008)
How were you threatened?
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by ryguytilidie on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @03:09PM (#11904498)
One threatened to tell my current boss that I had been a bad, disruptive employee, even though he admitted that he knew that this was untrue. So he basically threatened to try and get me fired from my job because I reviewed my experience working at his company.

Other one threatened to sue me because I had signed a non-disparagement agreement after a layoff.

Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by dhimes on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @04:26PM (#11905052)
Wow, that is incredible shittyness.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by alaskanloops on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:41PM (#11896208)
They were able to identify you?
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by ryguytilidie on Tuesday June 14, 2016 @03:10PM (#11904501)
Yep. Small team one time and a coworker of mine who knew I wrote it told the company on the other one.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by Yhippa on Sunday June 12, 2016 @11:56PM (#11891636)
What do you mean by pad the reviews? Coerce employees into giving mostly favorable ones?
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by pekk on Monday June 13, 2016 @12:09AM (#11891683)
I won't name names, but one thing I've personally seen is HR initiatives encouraging employees to write reviews, not necessarily coercively.

If well-known companies are doing that, it's not unlikely that some companies are directly instructing HR personnel to write favorable reviews.

Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by eli on Monday June 13, 2016 @01:11AM (#11891836)
What's wrong with encouraging employees to post reviews? When you sign up as an employer, glasdoor gives you a sample email to send that asks for honest reviews.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by miander on Monday June 13, 2016 @01:27AM (#11891875)
Because it creates an implicit expectation that your review should be positive.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by iamdave on Monday June 13, 2016 @01:59AM (#11891945)
Yeah, I'm kind of torn on this. I was asked at a previous company to write a review on GlassDoor (I never did).

Let me rephrase that last sentence: GlassDoor was brought up literally at every monthly update meeting.

But back on target, I'm torn: On the one hand I understand the need to actively recruit and attract talent to join your workforce and I definitely understand GlassDoor is something used by many people to benchmark their expectations on working environment, management and peers. I get that completely.

Where I break off though is when you have to ask your employees to write a review (even if you're adding the qualifier "Be honest, we wont penalize you") instead of creating an internal feedback environment that can go into recruitment, retention and employee/manager review platforms.

I would say there's already a power imbalance inherent to the workplace, especially if you're in one of those "at-will" states. So putting in front of your employees "Hey, can you go write a review of working here on this site?" understandably makes some people shift in their seats.

Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by bduerst on Monday June 13, 2016 @07:47AM (#11893002)
Go with your gut on this one. Obviously being part of a tribe means trying to attract the best talent to ensure it's success, but it sounds like you don't necessarily want to join a tribe that's "encouraging" signals to a market when there wouldn't normally be any.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by eli on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:04AM (#11891958)
I don't really see how. If I'm unhappy, I'm not going to lie just because I want to anonymously live up to an unspoken expectation.

Unless you think people fear being ID'd... but that's a problem with the whole model.

Anyway, I'd imagine many glassdoor reviews were generated this way. If employers didn't ask, it would be mostly bad reviews from ex employees. Few others would bother.

Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by deepGem on Monday June 13, 2016 @08:18AM (#11893104)
The same would apply to App Store reviews also then. Essentially the review system is broken.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by new_hackers on Monday June 13, 2016 @09:25PM (#11899131)
They wil sometimes remove reviews that are too negative. They removed mine of my previous employer.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by enraged_camel on Monday June 13, 2016 @12:14AM (#11891705)
Post fake reviews.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by askafriend on Sunday June 12, 2016 @11:41PM (#11891595)
They are absolutely padded and padding is even encouraged at some places. Even companies like FB do it.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by sgnelson on Monday June 13, 2016 @02:20PM (#11895997)
It'd be great if someone collated the data for the reviews and pointed out which companies tend to have the most "fake" reviews. It'd be a bit difficult to do so, but I can think of at least a few ways to try (date and frequency of reviews, "corporate speak," median length of reviews, distribution of "stars", distribution "helpfulness", writing style analysis, etc.)
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by mathattack on Monday June 13, 2016 @06:05AM (#11892691)
Glassdoor reviews are still helpful - you just have to take the averages with a grain of salt, and filter any that seem to have been written by a PR flack.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by daveguy on Monday June 13, 2016 @09:58AM (#11893892)
That filter should consider every review that looks like it was written by PR as a 1 star. Adjust accordingly. Theranos appears to have about a 1.1 star average with that adjustment.
Re:Walgreen Terminates Partnership with Theranos by mathattack on Monday June 13, 2016 @06:01PM (#11898079)
Yes indeed!