News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by tomglynch on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:52PM (#11881365)
The complaint by Fanify is ridiculous. It's very clear the app "violated Apple’s requirement that all in-app payments be routed through iTunes" so you can't pay through paypal.

Sounds like poor planning by Fanify to submit the app only 10 days before their planned launch, when they clearly didn't bother following Apple's T&Cs.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by softbuilder on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:08PM (#11881423)
It does sound like poor planning, given the known realities of the app store. But I've never understood why Apple feels entitled to a cut of in-app purchases. They aren't providing any added value and in some cases (like w/ Kindle) they seem to be begging for an anti-trust suit.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by sokoloff on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:15PM (#11881447)
One reason is that without it, there'd be nearly no paid apps. Every app would be free with some minute amount of functionality (to pass the review process) and an in-app purchase to unlock the "pro" version, with Apple getting nothing.

Apple built a platform and wants to extract value from that platform. It seems perfectly reasonable to me.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by LanceH on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:28PM (#11881697)
Nothing except the very large margins on the hardware.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by sokoloff on Saturday June 11, 2016 @06:51AM (#11882996)
A good rule of thumb is that a consumer electronics product should retail for about 2.5x the COGS (cost of goods sold). That's pretty much where the iPhone sits.

I don't see evidence of excessive margins on hardware; I see a company that's planned for and executed on proper margins.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by softbuilder on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:37PM (#11881542)
>Every app would be free with some minute amount of functionality

Maybe. But that already happens w/ free and "pro", etc.. I expect that the marketplace would sort that out. When everything is a come-on genuine offerings start to have more appeal.

>Apple built a platform and wants to extract value from that platform.

Sure. No problems with that as long as there is some value they are providing. At least in the case of a paid app, once that sale is made Apple shouldn't be involved unless they are doing something useful.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by danso on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:15PM (#11881444)
> But I've never understood why Apple feels entitled to a cut of in-app purchases.

You mean besides maintaining and securing the entire distribution network and ecosystem that makes such apps profitable in the first place?

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by mkching on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:33PM (#11881712)
The second half of this is particularly important.

Apple keeps iOS desirable to an enormous number of end users who are willing to spend money on apps.

They benefit from this by selling a lot of iPhones, but the developers benefit as well by having a market to target.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by kuschku on Friday June 10, 2016 @10:22PM (#11881679)
They may charge for that service, if they wish.

But they can’t get a cut of in-app payments, especially for Kindle stuff.

Also, what if I say for every user who buys an autogram card they get premium of the app for free?

Is that enough to get around them getting a cut?

This is a big legal issue.

Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by Razengan on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:20PM (#11881468)
Uhh hosting your files and providing the bandwidth for potentially millions of downloads?
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by paulcole on Friday June 10, 2016 @11:34PM (#11881914)
Value in my opinion is to the customer. I trust an IAP won't rip me off, do something weird, etc.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by chris_wot on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:20PM (#11881467)
Don't you find the App Store review process somewhat arbitrary and opaque though? Have they really improved their processes in terms of responsiveness?
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by agmcleod on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:23PM (#11881487)
The time to review & release is definitely faster. I wonder if quality will suffer because of it. One time when I had a rejection, I asked for some more details and got a fairly automated response. So it does feel a bit inhuman unfortunately.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by sthielen on Saturday June 11, 2016 @01:23AM (#11882208)
I think this is part of the new changes as well. I was dealing with a rejection a few days ago because of the new IPv6-only restriction and someone from App Store Review actually called me and we discussed and resolved the issue over the phone. After only ever communicating with them via contact forms and automated responses, I was in disbelief. Speaking to a real person from App Store Review was so absurd in my mind that it may as well have been God calling to discuss my prayers.
Re:Apple Starts to Woo Its App Developers by agmcleod on Saturday June 11, 2016 @09:21AM (#11883357)
Oh wow, that's rather awesome :D