News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by hackuser on Thursday June 09, 2016 @07:19PM (#11873119)
I found this part very interesting:

In the case of the Model S’s suspension, Tesla took care of repairs for some customers who complained to the company, on the condition that they agreed in writing not to talk about the issue or how Tesla dealt with it. The agreements, however, stirred up discussion on online bulletin boards.

Dailykanban.com, an auto industry blog, posted excerpts from what it said was an agreement. It said, in part: “You agree to keep confidential our provision of the Goodwill, the terms of this agreement and the incidents or claims leading or related to our provision of the Goodwill.” “Goodwill” is the term Tesla used to refer to any repairs or compensation it made because of a suspension failure.

The agreement posted on the blog released Tesla from any liability and barred the car owners from filing legal proceedings against the company.

---

More and more I get the sense that Musk is in firm control of everything I read about his companies.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by bigiain on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:43PM (#11873742)
FWIW, I've seen that sort of language about "goodwill repairs" for instances where a company agrees to fix things that are out of warranty - a friend signed something similar to that to get a replacement frame on a Ducati ST4 which was ~3 years out of warranty. They covered the cost of a new frame and several thousand dollars worth of labour to install, but asked for an NDA (rumours from the time suggest they didn't enforce the NDA requirement, and fixed people's bikes anyway if they refused to sign).
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by honkhonkpants on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:10PM (#11873835)
Yamaha does the exact thing with cracked frames. They present an NDA but if you refuse they replace it anyway, which of course is the right thing to do.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by lsaferite on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:13AM (#11875789)
Funny that you get quotes like "Ms. Krebs said she had never heard of a car company requiring customers to sign confidentiality agreements in exchange for repairs of potential safety defects" in the article and then here you immediately get two anecdotes of the same thing from two other automobile manufacturers. (Motorcycles are automobiles, right?)
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by joezydeco on Friday June 10, 2016 @05:47PM (#11880351)
Wouldn't an NDA also prevent an avalanche of owners making similar requests from the manufacturer?

If you happen to convince the manufacturer to give you a free fix out-of-warranty and then you tell all the other owners, you could be asking for big headaches, and probably even more lawsuits, when the rest ask for the same treatment and are denied...

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by saulrh on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:41PM (#11873475)
He kind of had to be if electric vehicles were going to have a chance. Look at the "batteries are fire hazards" shitstorm - because his company is new and interesting, the press is going to be much harder on it than they would be on any other manufacturer. Given how much I hear about Tesla, I suspect that his information control roughly balances out the muckraking into something like the truth.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by gordon_freeman on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:03PM (#11873572)
NHTSA did review all the fire incidents involving Tesla cars and found that the outside shell in the bottom was too thin and the debris broke it and damaged the batteries to cause fire. As far as I know that's a legitimate issue media has brought up and Tesla then took steps to make the shell stronger so that debris couldn't damage the batteries.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by kbenson on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:40PM (#11873928)
That's not what was reported at the time[1]. The NHTSA found no defect trend[2]. Tesla decided to make changes to prevent the problem anyway, including reinforcing that battery compartment and raising ride height when at speed, which should reduce the chance of anything like that happening again, but there's no evidence that their engineering was at fault (they indicated their cars had driven 90 million miles at the time, and only two fires were reported).

1: http://www.cnbc.com/2014/03/28/nhtsa-closes-investigation-in...

2: http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot.gov/owners/SearchResults?searchType...

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by LeifCarrotson on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:10PM (#11873834)
Sure, if by "too thin" you mean it fails under impacts from objects like concrete blocks and receiver hitches that would puncture the passenger compartment, gas tank, or probably even the oil pan of a gasoline engine.

The media loves to portray new things as dangerous. Perhaps it actually was too thin because these completely reasonable failures were able to happen, causing bad press that they ought to have guarded against with total overkill undercarriage shielding.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by userbinator on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:17PM (#11873857)
Physically damaging batteries can directly cause a fire, whereas a punctured gas tank won't unless the leaking fuel finds a source of ignition. This is a failure mode unique to electric cars with batteries located there.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by mdorazio on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:58PM (#11873997)
Wait, what? There were over 160,000 vehicle fires on highways in 2013 [1]. ICE vehicles catch on fire all the time, often even without a punctured gas tank, and definitely can catch on fire with a punctured gas tank. If you damage a vehicle's fuel source, whether it's lithium-ion or gasoline, you're going to have a bad time.

[1] http://www.nfpa.org/news-and-research/fire-statistics-and-re...

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by dogma1138 on Friday June 10, 2016 @03:07AM (#11874737)
Vehicle fires are mostly from overheating or electrical fires. The gas tank being resistant to puncture, heat, and other things is something that is actually tested, electric vehicles on the other hand are much newer and these standards aren't there yet.

Batteries can explode when internally shorted, I had quite a few of 18650's explode on me over the years (usually through a fault of my own) the explosion isn't like a party popper it can be quite big and violent, and while explosions are some what not uncommon the battery flaming out completely when internally or externally shorted is. The Tesla has a few 1000's of 18650's cells even if a small number of those short during an accident it can cause allot of damage.

Another important difference between batteries and gas is that emergency workers (and anyone who's involved in the accident) can identify when the gas is leaking out, it's also much easier to stop the gas from catching on fire as wetting the vehicle or using other fire retardants will usually prevent the gas from catching fire. On the other hand you can have an internally shorted battery pack which can catch fire or explode at any moment and you would have no clue that it can happen.

Now don't take me wrong this isn't some anti-Tesla or anti-EV scare BS, this isn't some conspiracy either but saying that there are no valid concerns about the safety of the battery pack is ludicrous. We know how petrol cars work, we've been using them for 100+ years, we know when to look for a gas leak, we know how to deal with an oil/engine fire, EV's are a whole new ball game, eventually there will be a case where a Tesla or any other EV gets into a car accident and there will be a hot terminal somewhere in that car due to a short and someone will going to get zapped, at some point one of those batteries will explode and cause casualties, and many other things will happen that will be unique to EV's.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by mdorazio on Friday June 10, 2016 @09:23PM (#11881486)
Great response, just a few small nitpicks:

Using water on a gasoline or oil fire is a bad idea (the fire spreads since gas and oil are lighter than water), so fighting vehicle fires for ICE vehicles where the fuel tank has ruptured is a non-trivial problem for firefighters. The "easy" vehicle fires are ones where just the engine compartment and maybe the interior are on fire, but the fuel lines and tank are still in tact. In some ways a battery fire is easier to put out since it won't spread the same way and responds well to water.

Exploding 18650s tends to only happen with cheap, poorly manufactured variants. Most of the time if they short they will overheat, bulge, and sometimes catch on fire. Having enough of them actually explode to cause injury to vehicle occupants is probably about as likely as a fuel tank exploding in an ICE vehicle accident. Granted, there might be a higher fire risk for electric vehicles in severe collisions that damage the undercarriage area where the batteries are stored.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by userbinator on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:26AM (#11874299)
How many of those were caused by running over things on the road?
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by chc on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:19PM (#11873866)
Given that the consequences were really bad (your car caught on fire) and the problem was easily fixed, it sounds like a reasonable complaint, even if the circumstances where it happened were pretty extreme.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by Dylan16807 on Friday June 10, 2016 @12:16AM (#11874268)
A lot of rare problems can be 'easily' fixed with thick expensive metal plating. That's not enough to make a complaint reasonable.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by semi-extrinsic on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:34AM (#11874493)
FWIW, damaging your car's oil pan is super easy, it's really soft steel. My neighbour wrecked his Audi A3 going about 4 mph down a severely potholed road.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by Avshalom on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:13PM (#11873609)
Electric vehicles had been put on the path of inevitability by the Toyota Prius over a decade before Tesla got anything on the road (well I say this fairly often but: in reality they've always been on the path of inevitability, automakers have been trying the electric car every decade or so since the birth of the car)
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by yardie on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:22PM (#11873670)
And yet Toyota sees the future not in electric cars but in hydrogen fuel cells.

Toyota does not see the future in electric vehicles. Their hybrids are a good stopgap but they aren't into EVs at the moment. If you look at their history they went from full electric (ie. Rav4 EV) to hybrids to fuel cells.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by hackuser on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:33PM (#11873909)
> Toyota sees the future not in electric cars but in hydrogen fuel cells.

Aren't the fuel cells just an alternative to batteries for storing electricity in an electric car?

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by Cshelton on Friday June 10, 2016 @01:56AM (#11874550)
Hydrogen fuel cells are used as a way to generate clean electricity, which then is used to recharge the battery whenever it is needed. Basically eliminating "range fears" to some extent. However I think this period of using fuel cells will be short lived. <10 years. But they will be everywhere in the mean time. 10 years from now I see batteries with capitcities of 4x greater than we have today with at least 2x recharging time. So an EV could go 1,200 miles on a single charge, and recharge fully in roughly an hour or two. That would instantly make all fuel cells pointless
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by LeifCarrotson on Sunday June 12, 2016 @07:44PM (#11890902)
I am not as optimistic as you that 4x improvements are possible, but I certainly hope you're right!

We'll also need major improvements in electricity generation and distribution. To charge a battery of ~300 kWh in roughly an hour, even over an industrial supply like three-phase 480V AC, would require in excess of 600 amps!

That's more than three times the maximum current a large, modern house can draw at 240V, and requires conductors over 1000 kcmil, or more than 1" diameter copper.

On an ordinary 15A, 120 VAC circuit, it would take an entire week to charge the car.

That might make fuel cells attractive. Never underestimate the bandwidth of a station wagon full of tapes, and never underestimate the energy transmission potential of a supertanker or freight train full of oil or hydrogen.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by semi-extrinsic on Friday June 10, 2016 @02:03AM (#11874566)
Japan is betting heavily on hydrogen, presumably because of concerns that they won't be able to generate enough electric power if they went all EV.

And importing electricity would be geopolitically very risky (it would have to be from China or Russia), but liquid hydrogen they can ship in from close allies such as Australia.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by lsaferite on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:21AM (#11875832)
How on earth would you import electricity to Japan? Honest question.

String wires over the Korea Strait? Undersea cables? The shortest distance from Korea to the Japanese island at the mid-point is 50km and from there to the mainland is even more (by eyeball).

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by semi-extrinsic on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:54AM (#11875989)
That's cakewalk. The NorNed 700 MW HVDC undersea cable, finished in 2008, is 580 km.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NorNed

Edit: the engineering would be relatively easy, but the politics are the problem.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by lsaferite on Sunday June 12, 2016 @09:03AM (#11887915)
Wow, that's impressive. ~450kV is hard to imagine.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by ssmoot on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:38PM (#11873727)
That really depends on the fuel cell doesn't it?
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by myrryr on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:26PM (#11874089)
Kodak didn't want to do non film cameras.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by bydo on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:53PM (#11874184)
Kodak made more money selling film (and paper, developer, fixer, and so on) than from selling cameras. Toyota doesn't sell gasoline.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by andromeduck on Thursday June 09, 2016 @11:21PM (#11874067)
Aren't Toyota's fuel cell cars basically plug in hybrids that use hydrogen instead of petrol?
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by Spooky23 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:17PM (#11873641)
I don't understand why you would want to be an apologist for Tesla.

It's unconscionable to require a NDA as a condition to performing warranty work. Between crap like this and their aggressive, litigious pushback about accident fault analysis, I'd say it's foolish to buy these cars.

I've owned Dodge, Pontiac, Cadillac, BMW, and Honda cars. Each of those companies and their dealers have plenty of noxious behaviors, but nothing as extreme as this.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by chc on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:37PM (#11873722)
Based on the original article on Daily Kanban, it sounds like it's not warranty work. The NDA appears to be attached to a discount on out-of-warranty work.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by Spooky23 on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:46PM (#11873754)
No, it sounds like a means to suppress reporting to Federal regulators to avoid a recall order.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by gpm on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:00PM (#11873802)
No, it sounds like a means to prevent them from becoming obligated to perform out of warranty repairs for free.

Suppressing reports to federal regulators was almost certainly not the intent, since the vast majority of cars will be under warranty (meaning they can't use NDAs).

This article seems incredibly biased, selling NDAs on people who are out of warranty as NDAs on people who have some specific problem. Adding in a shield to make their already really low occurrences of fires even lower, while implying (falsely as far as I know) that this was required. Etc.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by davidwhodge on Thursday June 09, 2016 @09:49PM (#11873763)
Single data point here, but I'be heard of BMW doing work or even taking back cars under NDA.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by maratd on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:00PM (#11873803)
> It's unconscionable to require a NDA as a condition to performing warranty work.

It isn't warranty work. It's out of warranty work. Any other company would tell you to get lost and wouldn't repair squat.

> I don't understand why you would want to be an apologist for Tesla.

Because of mis-information found in posts like yours. Tesla does plenty of shitty things, but the amount of lies out there about Tesla is incredible.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by ultramancool on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:06PM (#11873819)
I think the reliability of the current Model S could be a major problem - there's a good reason Consumer Reports took away their recommended rating on it even after their testers absolutely loved the car. Sure, they're fixing everything for free right now, but wait and see what happens with the Model 3, it'll be more mass market and we'll get a good sense of what they can really produce.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by hackuser on Thursday June 09, 2016 @10:16PM (#11873854)
They are in a tough spot with so much riding on every model. If GM makes a bad car, it's one of many current products and one dud in a century-long track record. If Tesla makes a flop ... they might be bought by GM (which, after all, was originally an agglomeration of smaller car companies).

And unlike a small software company, they can't just fix the problem (at least, not a hardware problem) with an update.

Then again, they may have more room for error than someone making spaceships.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by verytrivial on Friday June 10, 2016 @08:15AM (#11875806)
> “Goodwill” is the term Tesla used to refer to any repairs or compensation it made because of a suspension failure.

That is a misleading and incomplete characterization. The repairs in this case were for suspension failure, yes, but it was termed "Goodwill" because the work was performed outside the warranty period (it we are to believe Elon^D^D^D^DThe Tesla Team).

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by sigmar on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:16PM (#11873370)
>More and more I get the sense that Musk is in firm control of everything I read about his companies.

Everything? Isn't the text you quoted proof that you've read something that isn't controlled by Musk?

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by hackuser on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:32PM (#11873435)
I'd say that was the cleverest comment I've ever read, but I'm afraid the hyperbole, satire, and sarcasm might be overlooked.

I do admit that I usually think hyperbole is far too much overused here and on the Internet in general. My apologies to HN for this grievous oversight.

Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by Shivetya on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:10PM (#11873344)
What they have done is pure crap. Considering how long Tesla has been in the business this type of activity should never have occurred. It will now certainly get the NHTSA digging into more than just the suspension issue.
Re:Tesla Model S Suspension Failures Under Scrutiny by Safet... by untilHellbanned on Thursday June 09, 2016 @08:17PM (#11873379)
Though they have actually shipped a product, this Jobsian-no divulging obsession sounds like that other, recently imploded T-named startup...Th..th..eranos.

Worked for Apple because iPhone can't kill anyone. Not gonna fly, er drive, for Tesla. Tightly regulated market, good luck with maintaining that secrecy-based business plan.