A CoL adjustment for San Francisco isn't the problem, but rather the fact that San Francisco costs so much to begin with.
UBI would have a similar effect - maybe you still want to have a job, but you can choose to accept a somewhat lower paying job to live somewhere nice. It would also put less pressure on places like San Francisco.
Being less dependent on jobs is a good thing. We should allow this migration to happen naturally, rather than subsidizing people to stay where they are.
That isn't a problem. You get a concentration of people collecting a basic income who move into a low cost area, then they have money to buy housing and food and so on so there are jobs needed to construct housing and sell food, so then some of them get those jobs. Then they have even more money which leads to even more jobs etc. and soon enough the low cost area isn't so low cost, but that isn't a problem anymore because now they have jobs.
So now you force these poor people out of homes that they used to be able to afford into even poorer areas with worse job security. This is assuming that they're even able to acquire new jobs. And it would only get worse with automation.
A basic income that doesn't scale based off of CoL is one that's bound to fail in the face of automation.
A UBI causes the cost of living to rise in the short run. If you readjust the UBI the cost of living will rise again and again.
Cities like San Francisco will become more attractive because they not only have more jobs they also pay you more UBI. The more people move in, the higher the cost of living if housing supply is constrained. Readjusting the UBI then makes the city even more attractive. At the same time small cities become less attractive because not only are people moving into the city but their UBI is shrinking too.
A basic income would allow you to move to some town in Oregon or Colorado without having to worry about starving to death until you can find a job as a bouncer or the like. Once you do the presence of people like you creates some other jobs for plumbers and carpenters etc. The idea that this is going to turn every Podunk town in America into San Francisco or New York City and leave the poor with nowhere to live is clearly untrue.
I don't know what the solution is here but if in this hypothetical reality, the garden state didn't supplement but California did then I'd move to California in a heartbeat. I am sure I'd be broke even with any supplement in San Diego but at least I'll be broke in San Diego.
Edit: I cannot support any discrimination in basic income based on "ability to work". I'd rather the whole thing fail. I'd rather we never have basic income implemented at all than this bastardization go through. Personally, I'm all for death panels. We should not try to keep everyone alive at all costs. If I get in a freak accident and it'd cost me $10M+ to keep me alive with little to no chance of a full recovery, please let me die.
Something we need to discuss separately from universal basic income is the need to reduce cost in healthcare. I'd gladly support expanding Medicare to everyone without having to qualify. We would need significantly greater penalties for Medicare fraud and add incentives for whistleblowers and make it easier to report fraud. I'm OK with "lite" Medicare that drops expensive procedures and lets patients suffering from rare cases fending for themselves in order to cut costs especially if there is little chance that the patient will ever recover fully.
The other thing I'd support is removing medical licensure from the law. People would still be free to visit only AMA-approved physicians, but there's no reason to give that guild a monopoly on providing health care. The artificial caps on medical school seats, imposed by the AMA, is one of the biggest reasons for the absurd cost of medical care in the US.
>I don't know what the solution is here but if in this hypothetical reality, the garden state didn't supplement but California did then I'd move to California in a heartbeat. I am sure I'd be broke even with any supplement in San Diego but at least I'll be broke in San Diego.
Sure, and when the people of California realize that they're attracting all of the deadbeats from around the country, they'd be forced to adjust.
First, the AMA does not control the number of medical school seats in the country. Accreditation of US medical schools is done by the LCME, part of the AAMC. With some research, you'd find that the number of medical school seats is growing each year.
Second, the limiting factor for physician training is NOT medical school but residency. In point of fact, the US imports residency trainees from overseas - we're not constraining ourselves artificially but instead of surplus training positions.
Through a historical fluke, residency training depends on funds allocated by Congress through Medicare funding.
I understand your frustration at healthcare costs, but please research these issues.
Further, the LCME is run in equal parts between the AMA and the AAMC. http://www.ohsu.edu/xd/education/schools/school-of-medicine/... See "Who serves on the LCME?"
I can also support removing the ama-fia's control on licenses but I'm afraid we'll just replace it with something similar when it comes to which providers are eligible to reimbursements from the new single payer healthcare system.
I am guessing so would a lot of other people, which would create an opportunity of a lifetime for California landlords, adjusting the rents to the point where UBI would only offer marginal incremental benefit.
There's a good argument to be made for a larger sum for the disabled who cannot work. But I'd be extremely opposed to any regional adjustments. If individual cities and states want to supplement the UBI, then that's up to them, but people moving out of high-cost areas and into low-cost ones is part of the natural ebb and flow that keeps the cost of living reasonable. And can you imagine what a CoL adjusted UBI for San Francisco would look like? A massive ripoff of the rest of the country.