News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by Roritharr on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:49PM (#11837678)
Once again no answer to the main Question: What to do with people that blow their UBI by the 2nd of each month on SAAS Startups?

Let them starve? Go without Shelter?

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by brador on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:55PM (#11837715)
Pay out UBI daily? The technology exists, no reason not to do it that way.

Also the only way to make a basic income work is through a land or land value tax. Else you get massive inflation.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by prawn on Sunday June 05, 2016 @01:56AM (#11839820)
I agree that paying daily would have benefits. Give someone with poor impulse control a lump sum, and it can disappear quickly (new TV, car, big night out, etc). The daily equivalent might resist that a little, though they could still be baited into loan arrangements.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by mac01021 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @06:10PM (#11838365)
How does the redistribution of wealth by using taxes on personal spending or on earned income to fund UBI cause inflation?
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by brador on Saturday June 04, 2016 @06:30PM (#11838466)
In difficult times people stop spending money, even with UBI. This means less income to spread around, the solution, print more money = inflation.

Second, under UBI a proportion of the population stops working and this increases over time as robots replace workers. Reducing earned income, lowering UBI cash availability. Solution? Print more money = inflation.

With a land value tax you get a known relatively unchanging set amount of $ based on land value. Balancing the inflation/deflation curve.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by chimeracoder on Saturday June 04, 2016 @06:51PM (#11838568)
> In difficult times people stop spending money, even with UBI. This means less income to spread around, the solution, print more money = inflation.

This is... not really correct. It's true that expansionary monetary policy is often practiced in times of economic recession, but that's not really because there's 'less income to spread around'. And the reason expansionary monetary policy is practiced isn't to give people more income. (Printing money doesn't give individuals more income - if you want to do that, you need expansionary fiscal policy - that's the goal behind tax cuts).

So what does printing money do? Expansionary monetary policy reduces the costs of loans and investments. The goal is to spur long-term investment projects by making capital cheaper, which serves to jump-start the economy. But that has no direct connection to people's personal income. They're interconnected, sure - everything in the economy is, at some level. But the connection to inflation (and the connection to printing money) are completely different things.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by brador on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:18PM (#11838695)
Under UBI the payment and coverage of UBI would be one of, if not the, largest expenditures of government. Vital to getting votes will be keeping the amount received steady and high. And that might mean printing money if necessary.

With land tax the system is self correcting and balanced. With the taxes you mentioned you'd eventually get the inflationary spiral as a market correction.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by chimeracoder on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:38PM (#11838786)
> Vital to getting votes will be keeping the amount received steady and high. And that might mean printing money if necessary.

Maybe, but that's very different from what you said, which is that '[difficult times] means less income to spread around, the solution, print more money = inflation'.

> With land tax the system is self correcting and balanced.

Er, no - if anything, a property tax would reinforce inflation.

> With the taxes you mentioned you'd eventually get the inflationary spiral as a market correction.

Maybe you meant to respond to someone else? I didn't talk about any taxes. I only mentioned tax cuts as an actual example of expansionary fiscal policy to address the 'less income to spread around' problem, not as a proposal for funding income redistribution.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by mac01021 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:51PM (#11838845)
> Expansionary monetary policy reduces the costs of loans and investments

How does it do that? Suppose I want to borrow $1M to build a factory, but nobody (banks, venture capitalists, whatever) can afford to invest in my endeavor.

So the fed prints a bunch of money, causing 5% inflation. Now the bank can more easily afford to loan me $1M, because that $1M is worth less.

But now I need a $1.05M loan to build my factory.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by gnaritas on Saturday June 04, 2016 @10:59PM (#11839412)
> How does it do that?

By lowering interest rates which encourages borrowing and thus spending and thus economic activity.

> So the fed prints a bunch of money, causing 5% inflation.

Printing money causes monetary inflation, but does not directly cause price inflation so you don't need 1.05M to build your factory. Printing money can eventually lead to price inflation if too much money is printed for too long, but that doesn't mean all money printing causes price inflation as that lever can be turned both ways. Lower interest rates to spur spending and get the economy moving again and then once out of danger raise them again.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by mac01021 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @10:19PM (#11839315)
Why was I downvoted? I was just asking a question about monetary policy, hoping the GP (who clearly knows more than I) would come back and answer it.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by adynatos on Sunday June 05, 2016 @04:12AM (#11840088)
what about the people that blow their daily ubi five minutes after getting it on a saas startup? let them starve or go homeless?
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by teddyh on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:52PM (#11837695)
From the article:

> Some people will still behave irresponsibly and be in need before that deposit arrives, but the UBI will radically change the social framework within which they seek help: Everybody will know that everybody else has an income stream. It will be possible to say to the irresponsible what can’t be said now: “We won’t let you starve before you get your next deposit, but it’s time for you to get your act together. Don’t try to tell us you’re helpless, because we know you aren’t.”

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by riskable on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:47PM (#11837932)
The problem here is the assumption that everyone on Medicaid, Social Security, etc is capable of spending money responsibly. Take away their benefits and hand them some cash.

This will result in millions of vulnerable seniors and mentally disabled individuals being scammed out of their money each month. Whether it be "tech support" scammers or local fraudsters or even simply not being able to budget money (at a basic level) these folks will be in trouble.

I live with (and care for) a mentally disabled individual (IQ: ~60) that receives benefits through Social Security, Medicaid, and other government programs. If it were not for our help in managing these benefits she would spend her money (which is supposed to be for food/living expenses) on Amazon on $100 anime-themed coffee cups and similar widgets the moment she receives it.

Not to mention the fact that she will never understand how to sign up for such services or know who to trust when receiving services. If someone in a lab coat told her they were a government doctor and she "had to pay" for her upcoming appointment she'd likely just hand over all her money. There's no way to "educate" her out of this problem. I've taught her all sorts of things... many times and I'll have to teach her again and again.

It's not so dissimilar to walking an old person through accessing a web app/site over and over again ("no, that's the search bar"). Handing vulnerable people money every month won't solve their problems.

It's a great idea for the economy in general though! Just don't do away with government services for the needy. Especially medical care.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by galdosdi on Saturday June 04, 2016 @06:09PM (#11838359)
This is a solved problem (at least, it's solved about as well as you could expect we could do). Social Security has the notion of a REPY or "Representative Payee" for recipients deemed unable to spend their own money, a trustee who manages it on their behalf. It's similar to (but not the same as) the concept of a legal guardian.

All in all, the Social Security Administration has a huge amount of experience with all the details and problems involved in efficient day to day administration of a massive payments program like this, so there's no reason not to just reuse the existing bureaucratic infrastructure and just swap out the eligibility rules.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by greedo on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:37PM (#11838784)
And if you retain the SSA, one of the biggest arguments for UBI (dismantling wasteful government agencies) gets defenestrated.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by galdosdi on Saturday June 18, 2016 @10:42AM (#11928816)
Actually, SSA is very efficient.

SSA spends just a fraction of a percentage point of the benefits it distributes on administrative costs (ie, the existence and operation of SSA itself). But even the vast majority of that is for the means-tested SSI Title 16 program, not the simpler Title 2 SS programs. Since a UBI is much simpler than either of those, SSA could easily save even more -- there would certainly be plenty of consolidation and maybe downsizing possible after passage of UBI. But there's no reason to throw away the common infrastructure for payments that already exists.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by ars on Saturday June 04, 2016 @11:26PM (#11839489)
I would expect the SSA to be the ones administering the UBI plan.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by dnautics on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:53PM (#11837706)
I wonder if this is bad because on the net it will make society less compassionate.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by dllthomas on Sunday June 05, 2016 @04:38AM (#11840153)
Maybe. Hopefully it lets us do a better job picking our compassionate response. Someone who can't get by with a sufficient regular income needs help of a different character than further handouts - giving more of the latter is not a sign of greater compassion.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by brbsix on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:07PM (#11837758)
Less compassionate to those undeserving of it, sure. Isn't that a good thing? I'm not a fan of UBI but this aspect might turn out to be really beneficial in reversing the perverse incentives and dysgenic effects of current social benefits programs.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by toomuchtodo on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:30PM (#11837856)
> Less compassionate to those undeserving of it, sure. Isn't that a good thing?

Only if we want to continue to have addicts and the mentally ill homeless, abused, and taken advantage of.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by prawn on Sunday June 05, 2016 @02:07AM (#11839849)
Who's undeserving though? Someone lazy, sure. But someone impaired through birth defect or accident or mental illness? How do you determine whether someone is lazy but claiming anxiety/depression, or actually suffering?
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by adynatos on Sunday June 05, 2016 @04:32AM (#11840137)
how is that different from telling lazy bums today to get a job, but without extra layers of complexity?
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by yulaow on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:56PM (#11837718)
I have another (hope not stupid) fundamental question: do we have to give people a different UBI based on their location (aka cost-of-life)? If no, it will be pretty hard to find a right value. If yes, should we also change it as soon as they relocate?
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by trishume on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:03PM (#11837747)
My preferred answer (although others may differ) is that it should be the same for everyone. If you can't afford to live where you are now, move somewhere cheaper or get a job. If you're jobless and can't afford an expensive city that means the economy is telling you to make room for someone who can make productive use of the limited space in an area that many need to be to work together.

If you want to stay near family and friends, find a nice cheap place an hour or two away, if you want a shorter commute that's a luxury, not a necessity, and you should work for it.

Basic incomes are for the minimum needed to live a decent life, living in a specific expensive location is a luxury you should have to work for.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by zo1 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:30PM (#11837855)
>"If you can't afford to live where you are now, move somewhere cheaper or get a job. If you're jobless and can't afford an expensive city that means the economy is telling you to make room for someone who can make productive use of the limited space in an area that many need to be to work together."

That's exactly how it should work, even in a system with no UBI. Sadly, people see the state as the grand fixer and enabler of everything.

Eventually, we'd all realize that certain places simply cost more to live in due to reasons outside of everyone's control. E.g. maybe it's hard to create affordable safe housing in a very earthquake/tornado prone area. Or hard to deliver fresh healthy produce to a city in the middle of nowhere like a desert. I exaggerate, of course, but these minor details still affect prices to a certain extent. We can't have cosmic-justice.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by mac01021 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:06PM (#11837754)
That doesn't seem like a huge issue to me. Give everyone the same amount and then let them work harder to live where they want or relocate to a place where the UBI exceeds the cost of living.

There are already neighborhoods now where most people, including me, cannot afford to live, and I don't see it as a tremendous injustice.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by dcosson on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:59PM (#11838004)
I think this is a critical problem to solve with UBI. If you give people in expensive areas more money, more people might crowd into cities, intensifying the affordability crises in places like SF and NYC. Plus there are strong incentives to cheat the system and lie about your address, or even to live homeless in the most expensive cities to collect the higher UBI payments, etc.

So ideally we'd avoid this and everyone would get the same amount of money. But, if we continue to let city prices shoot up, we might end up in a place where people want a job but can't get one because they live somewhere cheap and can't afford to move to the city where all the jobs are on their smaller basic income payment.

With or without basic income, we're clearly on an unsustainable path of letting cities get so much more expensive so quickly.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by zanny on Saturday June 04, 2016 @06:46PM (#11838551)
It isn't nearly as much of a problem if you have your necessities covered by UBI and can spend your time however you want. It gives you all the time to be innovative that you need, and if there were actual meaningful work to be done going undone in cities, owners would subsidize the costs of moving rural workers in to attract talent.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by trishume on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:58PM (#11837725)
Have them stop paying for SAAS Startups next month?

Many existing welfare systems fail in this same scenario. For any feasible welfare plan it is possible to invent scenarios where someone can torpedo themselves. The goal should just be to make it harder for external forces to hurt people, and maybe a bit more difficult to torpedo yourself.

At some point welfare programs must say something along the lines of "if you take help we give you and set it on fire, that's past the line, go find a charity or psychiatrist to help you"

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by toomuchtodo on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:00PM (#11837732)
> "if you take help we give you and set it on fire, that's past the line, go find a charity or psychiatrist to help you"

Ideally, social service workers could still help these folks.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by brbsix on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:00PM (#11837733)
This question is out of scope. UBI is meant to be unconditional income (to be allocated as each individual sees fit), not unconditional food, shelter, or other necessities.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by chimeracoder on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:02PM (#11837742)
> This question is out of scope. UBI is meant to be unconditional income (to be allocated as each individual sees fit), not unconditional food, shelter, or other necessities.

Well, if it's being paid for by eliminating programs which do provide food, shelter, and other necessities, then it's not really out of scope to ask how we're going to provide those.

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by vasilipupkin on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:02PM (#11838628)
You could have a special program for those who can be shown to be mentally incapable of managing their ubi. If you don't pass the test, but accidentally waste your ubi and have no other income, there can be a loan program to be repaid at reasonably high interest rates out of your future ubi
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by vasilipupkin on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:05PM (#11838635)
And yes, if you are mentally capable but choose to waste your ubi, and can't repay the loan, we would let you starve. Same if you take your food stamps today and throw them in the river - we would let you starve
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by dclowd9901 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:40PM (#11838799)
More realistically than administering some kind of test would be to force people to opt out of basic necessities care. So a person's UBI would be portioned off for food, health, state living facilities etc. so they would always have the bare minimum to survive. If I happened upon a person in need I would merely need to simply bring them to the nearest grocery store and their food needs would be taken care of. Since its opt out, they likely won't have the facilities to opt out.

My biggest concern is how you logistically provide money to people. What do you use to distribute it? Some sort of state owned bank? What about identification?

Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by dnautics on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:52PM (#11837693)
Same question is valid for food stamps, EITC.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by kylec on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:53PM (#11837704)
Essentially, yes. It should encourage them to make better choices in the future.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by zoul on Saturday June 04, 2016 @05:43PM (#11838235)
How is this different from our current situation with pensions?
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by seanwilson on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:07PM (#11837757)
If you created a department to give out money for emergencies, the number of people applying and the amount of paper work required would surely cost less than the current system for benefits?
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by patrickg_zill on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:09PM (#11837767)
Give them a $2 a month vps/cloud instance and ensure that Jekyll is installed on their laptop.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by JorgeGT on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:36PM (#11837883)
Why would one need a vps if using Jekyll?
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by patrickg_zill on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:32PM (#11844294)
They have to test deployment, of course!
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American by yetanotheracc on Saturday June 04, 2016 @06:26PM (#11838450)
Put them in prison for all I care.