Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American
by dnautics on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:53PM
(#11837706)
I wonder if this is bad because on the net it will make society less compassionate.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Maybe. Hopefully it lets us do a better job picking our compassionate response. Someone who can't get by with a sufficient regular income needs help of a different character than further handouts - giving more of the latter is not a sign of greater compassion.
Less compassionate to those undeserving of it, sure. Isn't that a good thing? I'm not a fan of UBI but this aspect might turn out to be really beneficial in reversing the perverse incentives and dysgenic effects of current social benefits programs.
Re:A Guaranteed Income for Every American
by toomuchtodo on Saturday June 04, 2016 @04:30PM
(#11837856)
> Less compassionate to those undeserving of it, sure. Isn't that a good thing?
Only if we want to continue to have addicts and the mentally ill homeless, abused, and taken advantage of.
Who's undeserving though? Someone lazy, sure. But someone impaired through birth defect or accident or mental illness? How do you determine whether someone is lazy but claiming anxiety/depression, or actually suffering?