News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by amelius on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:30AM (#11801749)
> The novel aspect of these bacteria is that they apparently do the job 10x more efficiently than natural organisms.

This makes me wonder why this solution was not found by evolution directly.

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by jerf on Monday May 30, 2016 @12:38PM (#11802032)
It's 10x more efficient for human purposes. It's not a 10x more efficient mechanism in general. Evolution has no need to produce 10x more rather energy-expensive molecules than it needs, so it doesn't produce bacteria that do that.

Which is also the answer to everybody else wondering about what happens if this gets into the biosphere. Well, have you ever been walking in a relatively natural forest area and come across the sad sight of a natural clearing being totally dominated by wild broccoli plants? No, you never have, because broccoli is completely incapable of outcompeting any natural plant. Broccoli's genes put way too much energy into producing that big beautiful edible bit that all of its competition puts into offense and defense. Similarly, the answer to the question of what happens to bacteria that pours its energy into producing alcohol while its competition is pouring its energy into producing offspring is that if you blink, you'll miss the death of the alcohol-producing bacteria. They're not going to take over the ecosystem. In energy terms you probably stand a better chance of seeing broccoli sweep the meadows of the world than having this bacteria survive in the wild.

(And when I say broccoli, I mean something like what you'd buy in the store. Not merely a rapid reversion to its historical ancestor, which could actually happen, but actual proper broccoli.)

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by pfarnsworth on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:10PM (#11804314)
> Evolution has no need to produce 10x more rather energy-expensive molecules than it needs, so it doesn't produce bacteria that do that.

You don't seem to understand natural selection. The idea of evolution producing something that an organism "needs" is akin to saying that God decided that the organism "needed" it and changed its genes.

The theory of natural selection is a completely passive process. For every generation of an organism, the genes are naturally randomized, producing various expressions of genes, and once there is selecting event, those that are not selected for will go extinct. That's what natural selection means. The idea that a giraffe "needed" a long neck is preposterous because it implies that the animal willed itself to have a longer neck. Instead, the giraffe's ancestors had a variable length neck, but given its particular circumstances, those with longer necks survived, and passed those genes on.

So there very well might be naturally occurring bacteria that produce 10x efficiently, but they haven't been selected for, yet.

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by kbenson on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:30PM (#11804372)
> You don't seem to understand natural selection. The idea of evolution producing something that an organism "needs" is akin to saying that God decided that the organism "needed" it and changed its genes.

I'm pretty sure he understands it fine, and is just using shorthand that makes it easier to describe.

There exists no approximation of a fitness function in nature that selects for this output because it's not efficient for survival, until we come along and create custom environments and select for survival based on energy output.

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by GauntletWizard on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:38PM (#11804401)
I can't decide which I find more annoying; The grandparent's misuse of terms, or the people pointing out that 'that's not how evolution works, it doesn't go towards anything, just away from what doesn't work.' I'm sure plenty of people don't get it, but it's really, really, really convenient shorthand for "Selective pressure has thus far favored" to say that "Evolution wants" or "Evolution needs". It's simple, it's unambiguous, and it's often backed up by our own human perceptions - Most of our wants and needs are based on selective pressure, so generalizing that to other selective pressures as 'wants' and 'needs' is a very natural abstraction.

(I've decided which is the most annoying: Meta-pedants like me.)

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by jerf on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:21AM (#11807045)
I've learned the hard way that using the klunky English required to be "correct" in an otherwise two-paragraph reply just isn't worth the time. If I were writing a scientific paper I'd be more careful, but HN comments don't benefit from the bloat.

I suppose I could #include<evolution_isnt_anthropomorphic> up front and then carry on.

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by steffenfrost on Monday May 30, 2016 @03:52PM (#11802795)
If this is so, then why can invasive species wreak havoc in an ecosystem?

http://ocean.si.edu/ocean-news/5-invasive-species-you-should...

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by rosser on Monday May 30, 2016 @05:25PM (#11803297)
Because those species are sinking the extra resources into out-competing the local flora a/o fauna, and successfully displacing them. That's kinda a definitional characteristic of an "invasive species".
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by stplsd on Monday May 30, 2016 @05:27PM (#11803308)
How is even related to the points discussed by parent comment?
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by gherkin0 on Monday May 30, 2016 @09:33PM (#11804094)
It's related to the parent's points by a misunderstanding.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by Terr_ on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:35AM (#11801772)
Probably because natural organisms have a more-diverse set of needs for long-term survival and propagation.

In nature we see a lot of "good enough" because there are other costs and higher-priority bottlenecks.

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by DougWebb on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:39AM (#11801789)
Because evolution is random, and not directed. 10x efficiency is what you get when you really have a designer.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by sitkack on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:54AM (#11801862)
And a single fitness function, not an environment.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by crazypyro on Monday May 30, 2016 @01:23PM (#11802215)
Small nitpick, but you can have a 'single fitness function' represent an entire environment. That's the entire concept of a fitness function: to simplify the merit of solution within an complex environment (or set of constraints/inputs/etc.) into a single figure. Obviously nature has a much complex fitness function than the efficiency of this one CO2 process. I think its more correct to say a "simpler fitness function".
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by sitkack on Monday May 30, 2016 @01:24PM (#11802223)
Correct, I should have said, "single dimension fitness function"
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by lisper on Monday May 30, 2016 @01:45PM (#11802293)
Actually, there is only one evolutionary fitness function, and that is reproductive fitness. The environment is the only variable. If your environment contains an intelligent agent that values the production of (say) alcohol, and the power to influence the selection of alcohol-producting organisms then an organism that produces alcohol can thrive. But this is true of anything, not just alcohol. Substitute "kitten photos" (or anything else) for "alcohol" and you will still have a true statement.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by smt88 on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:54AM (#11801863)
Evolution isn't designed, but it also isn't random. It's just directed by survival, which isn't always best served by maximum efficiency in specific functions like this one.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by DougWebb on Monday May 30, 2016 @12:39PM (#11802036)
Evolutionary changes occur by random mutation and, in sexual reproduction, by random genetic mixing. Whether or not those changes are successful is governed by survival, but it's not directed by survival. Survival doesn't choose specific evolutionary changes with a goal of increasing survivability.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by smt88 on Monday May 30, 2016 @06:31PM (#11803591)
This has become a completely semantic argument, but HN is a great place to argue semantics, so here we go.

> Evolutionary changes occur by random mutation and, in sexual reproduction, by random genetic mixing

The genetic changes of evolution are due to random mutation, but the ones that don't survive are not "evolution". Evolution is the subset of random mutations that increase reproduction/survival rates. If, at some point, a chimp was born with two heads, we wouldn't say that "chimps evolved to have two heads" because that two-headed chimp didn't pass on its genes. We'd say "a chimp randomly had two heads one time" and wouldn't bring it up in a discussion of evolution at all.

> governed by survival, but it's not directed by survival

To be directed by something does not always imply intentionality. Of course the most common usage of "direct" indicates something intentional, but that wasn't how I meant it. I meant "direct" in the sense that a particular landscape will direct the course of a river.

Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by bluesroo on Monday May 30, 2016 @12:38PM (#11802033)
I think what he meant was that each individual mutation is random. There isn't someone intelligently deciding what the next batch of mutations should look like.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by Sirenos on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:38AM (#11801786)
My understanding of evolution was that it wouldn't necessarily give you the best possible set of "features", only ones that aren't disadvantageous enough to put you out of the race.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by igammarays on Monday May 30, 2016 @12:54PM (#11802101)
Strictly speaking, an invention designed by evolved humans is a product of evolution.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by ommunist on Monday May 30, 2016 @03:32PM (#11802693)
Not strict enough. Genes are the subject of biological evolution, including human genes. But ideas are memes, and are subject of cultural evolution. These are two very different evolutions.
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by formula1 on Monday May 30, 2016 @12:51PM (#11802084)
Its possible that they consume at such a fast rate that it would likely consume faster than the world can produce
Re:Scientist Engineers Bacterium That Inhales CO2, Produces ... by crpatino on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:51AM (#11801852)
It probably was found. The damned thing just outcompeted (aka killed off) all the other organisms around it, then died off when there was no longer a working ecosystem to provide for some critical resource or to dispose its waste. Centuries later, invasive species from far away took over the wasteland and started over again.