News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Wildness of Children by pappyo on Monday May 30, 2016 @10:20AM (#11801459)
TLDR; The modern school was built in accordance with an industrial age mindset; children are raw materials and a school produces a functioning member of/worker for society. However, this institution stifles the child's "wildness" or open-minded learning that allows her/him to connect with the world, and become an eternally curious, more balanced human beings.

I agree with the author's premise that the current (US public) school model is not conducive for a child's future. The school's churns out students so they can be ready for JOBS (or get into a college that will help you get JOBS). It's been easy to fall into that trap with capitalism as the driving force behind everything. Capitalism has been evolving over the centuries, forcing workers into more specific disciplines then ever before (seriously, how many of us have 3 or 4 word job titles?).

However, that isn't to say structure doesn't have it's place. The author didn't to a good job of drawing some sort of line where structure is needed. A line is helpful here. That line should look like what we want our schools to ultimately achieve for our children and society. Are we a society of workers? Or do we want to be something else?

Re:On the Wildness of Children by dominotw on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:29AM (#11801742)
Living in any society automatically means you have to curtail your 'wildness'. Its 'society-tax'.

The way you define yourself(eg: family man, software engineer ect) is definition of your relationship with the society. And anything that is defined is not 'wild'.

Re:On the Wildness of Children by jeremiahwv on Monday May 30, 2016 @01:58PM (#11802347)
This is precisely the myth of our culture that the article is trying to debunk.

Instead of considering "wildness" as the observable actions of an individual (in our culture generally equated with "out of line"), consider "wildness" as the state-of-mind -- or the embodied, subjective experience of an individual -- in which that individual experiences themselves as a completely sovereign individual enmeshed in a web of relationships with other completely sovereign individuals.

There are many such wild humans living in our society even now. If you're looking for the guy running through the city in loincloth beating his chest and grunting gutturally, you won't find them.

You will find them if you look for people walking through the world almost like everyone else, except their eyes sparkle like the stars.

--------

And regarding your second point about having a role meaning that something is not wild: In the actual "wild", out there in the natural ecosystems of the world, roles and wildness existing very much hand in hand. Through a certain lens, biological diversity is exactly the separation of life into distinct and complementary roles.

Wildness is not a rejection of role. Wildness is the the complete and unreserved embodiment of who-you-are (your unique and undeniable role/roles) and the expression of that in relationship to everyone else.

Re:On the Wildness of Children by dominotw on Monday May 30, 2016 @05:30PM (#11803321)
>This is precisely the myth of our culture that the article is trying to debunk.

So I can go murder someone I don't like because I am a 'wild human'. Personal freedom is different from social rules. You are not "wild" if you live in a society in any capacity.

Re:On the Wildness of Children by jeremiahwv on Monday May 30, 2016 @09:51PM (#11804143)
I'm not sure how you got there from where I was.
Re:On the Wildness of Children by dominotw on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @08:36AM (#11806165)
eh sorry. That was a thoughtless comment on my part.
Re:On the Wildness of Children by pappyo on Monday May 30, 2016 @12:05PM (#11801909)
I agree, but we as a society should still have a say in how we curtail our wildness. It would appear that our say has been taken away, or at least hijacked, recently.
Re:On the Wildness of Children by dominotw on Monday May 30, 2016 @12:12PM (#11801945)
>It would appear that our say has been taken away, or at least hijacked, recently.

Taken away by who though? There is no secret cabal called 'society' out there. You are the society. society is pure reflection of your actions, your thoughts, your relationship with others.

Society gives us security, no one is forcing people to send their kids to these 'wildnesss killing schools' but we do it because it gives use security and makes us feel safe. And that is the price you have to pay for that security, the security that your mind seeks. The conflict we think we are in with the society is merely a conflict within ourselves, the conflict of self that seeks both security and freedom .

Re:On the Wildness of Children by ryanmarsh on Monday May 30, 2016 @01:18PM (#11802194)
Trade offs between "wildness" and "functional" are fine unless the schools degrade to a point at which the innocence lost is no longer worth the meager functional value provided to society or the individual. We're all aware of the position of Americas schools relative to other industrialized nations. Where is the cutoff?

Put differently, in a society of the future where "humans need not apply"[1] perhaps we might find a little more wildness to be of some redeeming value.

1. https://youtu.be/7Pq-S557XQU

Re:On the Wildness of Children by qazwsxedchac on Monday May 30, 2016 @04:21PM (#11802954)
It's not a new idea, John Myers O'Hara expressed it well over 100 years ago: http://www.unz.org/Pub/Bookman-1902nov-00229:19
Re:On the Wildness of Children by draw_down on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:53AM (#11801859)
Yes, this strikes me as the pedagogical equivalent of the Paleo diet.