News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by JustinAiken on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:57AM (#11792098)
Sometimes a comparison to Nazis is wholly appropriate.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by clinta on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:03PM (#11792360)
A comparison with Nazis is often just a Reductio ad absurdum, and it's particularly effective and useful because despite how absurd it sounds, it actually happened.

If you think the reduction is inaccurate, then argue the point, but just dismissing it by calling it Godwin's law, in my mind, admits that you don't have an effective counter-argument.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by sbov on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:08PM (#11792615)
No, in the vast majority of cases it's a strawman or slippery slope argument.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by blahedo on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:18PM (#11792174)
True, and in some ways I feel that the "warning" aspect of Godwin's Law gets used to dismiss the actually-relevant Nazi comparisons when they do happen. It can be frustrating.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by Shivetya on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:02PM (#11792353)
Sadly it is so overused in politics is diminishes the impact of the word and obscures the original meaning. It seems to be the anti-intellectual grown up equivalent to "YOUR MOM".
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by rdiddly on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:07PM (#11792609)
It's not trying to discourage all reference to Nazis; only the sloppy, frivolous ones. It's too easy to shout "Nazi" and let the word do your work for you. But I would think a rationally supportable comparison with Nazis in any given situation would be appreciated, not to mention necessary to avoid repeating history.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by corecoder on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:08PM (#11792139)
Sometimes it's hardly the majority of times, though.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by return0 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:51PM (#11792825)
Except that none of the people who make the comparison have any experience of nazism.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by dredmorbius on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:16PM (#11792961)
False.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by dredmorbius on Sunday May 29, 2016 @05:28AM (#11795663)
I'm quite aware it's gauche to comment on your own comment's voting patterns, but the tendency for HN readers to downvote inconvenient truths becomes rather patheticly amusing.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by return0 on Sunday May 29, 2016 @03:14PM (#11797776)
False less than 1% of the time (unless you have better data)
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by eprime on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:13PM (#11792154)
Could you give an example of an appropriate comparison?
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by tryitnow on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:28PM (#11792444)
Rwanda, Bosnia, Latin America death squads, the Confederacy, Andrew Jackson's March of Tears, the list sadly goes on and on.

Your question is a bit odd. History is chock full of examples of genocide, ethnic cleansing, slavery, etc.

This is the problem I have with Godwin's Law - sometimes a comparison to Nazis is entirely appropriate.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by malka on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:03PM (#11793496)
None were turned into an industry of death the way the nazis did
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by RileyKyeden on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:36PM (#11793653)
This is why the picohitler is such a handy unit of measurement.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by orblivion on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:44PM (#11792291)
I think it's important to remember that Hitler didn't exactly run with the Holocaust as his campaign. So if you compare the relatively benign climate that brought him to power, and see something similar today, it's worth bringing up.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by ikeboy on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:02PM (#11792352)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mein_Kampf

"If at the beginning of the war and during the war twelve or fifteen thousand of these Hebrew corrupters of the nation had been subjected to poison gas, such as had to be endured in the field by hundreds of thousands of our very best German workers of all classes and professions, then the sacrifice of millions at the front would not have been in vain."

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by orblivion on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:13PM (#11792388)
Then why was the holocaust such a shock to people? Perhaps they just didn't read the book.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by Retric on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:14PM (#11792393)
Note the scale '12,000-15,000' is ~1/1,000th of the actual death total in the Holocaust. It's the difference between 'first shoot all the lawyers' and 'just nuke their city's.'

Soviet great purge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Purge killed ~1 million people, holocaust killed 10x that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chinese_Famine killed ~15 million to 43 million, but that's poor policy not gas chambers.

Closest direct comparison is Pol Pot which 'only' killed ~2 million people.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by themartorana on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:04PM (#11792592)
It's funny that you don't hear Mao's name in many discussions of genocide. Is it that different that so many died one step removed from a direct order instead of on direct orders? Or that he had the good of the people in his heart even as tens of millions perished?

Gas chambers were policy. I guess we greatly forgive incompetence, even as it's forced on people through brutality.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by clevernickname on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:49PM (#11793123)
I find it strange that people proudly identify as "communists" without much stigma when the ideology was responsible for more death and suffering than national socialism. I guess it's a lot harder to remain ignorant of the Holocaust than of Stalin's purges.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by danharaj on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:11PM (#11793241)
Communism isn't one ideology. That's why it's called Marxim, or Leninism, or Stalinism, or Maoism, or anarchocommunism, or autonomous marxism, etc...

And furthermore, ideology itself doesn't do anything, it's purely abstract. It's entirely possible for two people to adopt the same exact ideas and do things they mutually disagree about.

There are communists who like Mao and stalin. I think they're gross because of it. I follow communist lines of thought that rejected all those dictators out of hand almost immediately.

This sort of genetic fallacy is kind of weak.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by clevernickname on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:15PM (#11793271)
Would you extend that same generosity towards someone that identified as a facist? Or would you assume they are a jingoistic racist etc. and associate them with Nazi Germany and company?

That's my point. One suffers guilt by association and its name itself has become a meaningless insult, the other does not and the mere suggestion that one could be against it draws to mind images of Cold War loonies. When in fact, both are (relatively speaking) sound families of ideologies.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by danharaj on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:18PM (#11793574)
> Would you extend that same generosity towards someone that identified as a facist? Or would you assume they are a jingoistic racist etc. and associate them with Nazi Germany and company?

I've never met a fascist who didn't want to seize power and execute people like me.

There are communists who, surprisingly, don't want to be dictators. Fascism definitionally requires totalitarian control over society. So do offshoots of Marxism like Leninism (don't worry it's """"transitional""""), but you'd be surprised how little time i give tankies either.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by clevernickname on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:01PM (#11794313)
>I've never met a fascist who didn't want to seize power and execute people like me.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-fascism

Nothing in there implies genocide, as far as I can tell. Anti-immigration policies that could be perceived as "racist", perhaps, but no genocide! And that's a left-wing slur, not a label that many would choose to use themselves.

>There are communists who, surprisingly, don't want to be dictators.

How can one take the means of production from the capitalists and give them to "the people" without "seizing power"? More generally speaking, how could you ever expect communal ownership and absence of a state to scale with the size of modern societies? And if you don't have these qualities, is it really communism?

The two of you are putting words in my mouth, when I never claimed to be a fascist or a Nazi sympathizer or what have you. But from my perspective, communist strains range from horrifyingly totalitarian and contradictory, to laughably naive, to so close to the status quo as to be meaningless. At least fascist ideologies are forward and internally consist, and sadly, I think, closer to the true nature of the world than we would like to admit.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by Retric on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:02PM (#11794574)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascism is not the same as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-fascism. Part of Fascism's basic tenets is to create a one party state and rule over a large empire. Only way to do that is remove every other party and then start a war.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by clevernickname on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:10PM (#11794597)
If "communism" can mean "whatever the hell I want it to mean when it's convenient" then I think we can speak of neo-fascism and other philosophies in the same breath.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by hartpuff on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:57PM (#11793462)
>>>I find it strange that people proudly identify as "communists" without much stigma

Do you also find it strange that white people proudly identify as "Americans" without much stigma, even after centuries of racial atrocities by white Americans?

> That's my point.

Your point - as is the point of everyone who trots out the "Communism" is worse than Nazism old chestnut - is to minimise what the Nazis did. And there's only one reason people do that.

The only surprise here, compared to every other Nazi sympathiser online making the same hackneyed "point", is you didn't claim Stalin killed 50/60/100 million people (any number higher than Hitler will do).

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by clevernickname on Saturday May 28, 2016 @09:08PM (#11794329)
>Do you also find it strange that white people proudly identify as "Americans" without much stigma, even after centuries of racial atrocities by white Americans?

Evidently many do, having experienced no shortage of white guilt and self-hating anti-American sentiment in my life.

>Your point - as is the point of everyone who trots out the "Communism" is worse than Nazism old chestnut - is to minimise what the Nazis did.

I wish to do the opposite of minimizing what the Nazis did. I wish to knock naive Che hat-wearing millennials down a peg.

>And there's only one reason people do that.

If you're going to call me a Nazi, I think all I can do is stick out my tongue, call you a commie, and close the tab.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by hartpuff on Sunday May 29, 2016 @06:29AM (#11795835)
> If you're going to call me a Nazi, I think all I can do is stick out my tongue, call you a commie, and close the tab.

Call me a commie if you like, I'm not ashamed to admit I sympathise with Communist principles (class and race/gender equality, for example) - unlike you, quacking like a fascist but too embarrassed to openly admit it.

The only people I see online making the effort to argue Nazism was not as bad as "X" are Nazi sympathisers/fascists. I mean who else would bother?

If you want to 'take down' a stupid and ridiculous caricature of what a Communist is ("Che wearing millennial" or whatever) you can do it without mentioning Nazis at all.

Instead you chose to take the 'at least the Nazis weren't as bad as the Communists' route. Your other posts here defending fascism don't exactly scream "Not a Nazi-sympathiser" either, so I don't know who you think you're trying to kid.

What happened after the Russian, Chinese or Cuban Revolutions doesn't negate the beliefs behind and reasons for the revolutions themselves (equality and 'the people'), any more than what happened after the American Revolution - almost 100 years of slavery, aggression and "Manifest Destiny" (cf. Lebensraum), followed by another century of racial persecution and overseas aggression/imperialism - negates the ideas and beliefs behind that revolution (equality and 'the people').

What happened in Germany after 1933, however, went exactly according to the Nazi playbook. What happened in Italy and every other fascist country, likewise, went exactly according to fascist principles.

Nobody becomes a Communist because they believe in purges or gulags; and nobody becomes a Nazi or a fascist because they believe in good roads, advanced rocketry or trains running on time.

That's why Nazis and fascists have a stigma attached to them - because the principles behind both are reprehensible to most people.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by clevernickname on Sunday May 29, 2016 @03:58PM (#11797944)
>and nobody becomes a Nazi or a fascist because they believe in good roads, advanced rocketry or trains running on time.

Actually, they do. The Nazis were admired both before and after the war for their tremendous infrastructural, technological, and social advances (for the races and classes they protected, obviously).

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by wcummings on Saturday May 28, 2016 @07:12PM (#11793986)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor killed 2.4 to 7.5 million
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by ikeboy on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:16PM (#11792405)
From what I've been told (certainly not an expert), people thought he wasn't serious at first. Then he took over the country and everyone was afraid of him. They also had a large brainwashing/ propaganda campaign to convince Germans to support them.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by jacobush on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:02PM (#11792580)
Clearly Trump can't be serious about everything he says either.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by ikeboy on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:30PM (#11792725)
The worst thing he's said is he'd kill families of terrorists, which is bad but nowhere near Mein Kampf.

Also, he hasn't written them in a book, it's an off the cuff threat, which makes it less serious, in my opinion.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by jacobush on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:57PM (#11792852)
Given a choice, do you think Hitler would have taken to a book or off the cuff remarks and Twitter? Also, how many terrorists are there which the US could assaninate? Multiply that with 10 to accomodate with a family and you may up with a number not far off from the 10000 Hitler proposed.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by soundwave106 on Saturday May 28, 2016 @07:30PM (#11794051)
Hitler and the NSDAP was way more organized than Trump. The party had a well defined manifesto and their ideological bent was pretty clear. Hitler attempted to gain power through a coup before trying the legit route.

Certainly there is definitely some routes of comparison between the rise of fascism in 1920s/1930s Europe and the right-wing-populist Trump phenomenon. However, in my mind the past politician that best approximates Donald Trump is Silvio Berlusconi. ("You never know", of course, but at this time I think some of the right wing political groups in Europe are better targets for 1920s-30s European fascism comparisons.)

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by jacobush on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @03:32PM (#11817434)
Agreed on Silvio. Much closer.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by jackweirdy on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:28PM (#11792217)
The growth of Fascism in pre-1930s Italy. Or perhaps Spain. Mussolini or Franco.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by tigershark on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:13PM (#11792391)
Mussolini created fascism in 1919, Hitler was inspired by him and after became much more dangerous. Francisco Franco took power much later. "Fascism" etimology is from "Fasci di combattimento" the political party founded by Mussolini.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by hartpuff on Saturday May 28, 2016 @05:09PM (#11793534)
> "Fascism" etimology is from "Fasci di combattimento" the political party founded by Mussolini.

No it's not. It derives from the word "fasces".

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by alberto_ol on Monday May 30, 2016 @05:11AM (#11800384)
the word 'fasces' does not exist in Italian. From the Italian Treccani dictionary fascismo s. m. [der. di fascio]. – Movimento politico italiano che trasse origine e nome dai Fasci di combattimento fondati nel 1919 da B. Mussolini
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by hartpuff on Monday May 30, 2016 @06:44AM (#11800661)
> the word 'fasces' does not exist in Italian.

The word "fascism" does not exist in Italian either. We're using English and anglicised words.

The "Fasces" is a group of rods tied together with an axe, dating back to ancient Italian/Roman times, and comes from the Latin fascis ("bundle").

The word fascism no more derives from a political party (which simply pulled the word out of nowhere, did it?) than the words "democrat", "republican" or "communist" do.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by maxerickson on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:51PM (#11793435)
I've seen it said that Mussolini was somewhat inspired by the US mobilization for WWI. Don't have the historical perspective to evaluate that though.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by jobigoud on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:41PM (#11792504)
The fact that it came before doesn't preclude it from being compared…
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by jackweirdy on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:09PM (#11792623)
Thank you for comparing Mussolini and Hitler and proving my point :)
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by astazangasta on Saturday May 28, 2016 @01:16PM (#11792406)
Comparing modern fascist movements to the fascist movements of the twenties, for example. The growth of right-wing movements in Europe and America following a steep economic downturn seems fairly ripe, as does the emergence of racial narratives, the use of hateful demagogery, etc.

Trump/Hitler comparisons are fair game, because what is going on bears a strong resemblance to what happened in Nazi Germany.

If we really mean "never again", that means understanding where the Nazis came from, what they are, and who is following in their goose-steps.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by icebraining on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:30PM (#11793032)
By economic downturn, you're talking about the Great War. I mean, there are plenty of people terribly afflicted in the current western world, but it's hard to argue that the scale of the horror even approaches what was lived in those years, for soldiers and civilians alike.
Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by JustinAiken on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:12PM (#11793247)
Personal - one of my friends grew up in a crazy-religious family where they'd literally burn "evil" books every week.

Politics - No, Trump is not the same as Hitler, but there are valid comparisons or parallels; see the videos of his supporters confusing Hitler quotes for his (then again, Trump himself tweeted a Mussolini quote)

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by DanBC on Saturday May 28, 2016 @04:15PM (#11793274)
> see the videos of his supporters confusing Hitler quotes for his

I loathe Trump, but that trick works with just about everyone. You take some famous person (Richard Dawkins is a favourite) and find some Nazi / Communist quote and create an image macro.

I'm mildly surprised a troll hasn't had t-shirts and buttons printed, and given them away at rallies.

> (then again, Trump himself tweeted a Mussolini quote)

That's a bit more worrying.

Re:I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning by Keyframe on Saturday May 28, 2016 @02:27PM (#11792709)
Modern anti-fascism.