News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by Chinjut on Thursday May 26, 2016 @12:45AM (#11775514)
(And, yes: education can of course grant skills which are genuinely required for certain jobs. This being Hacker News, I suppose we'll hear that everyone should learn to code. I'm all for everyone getting to do whatever they wish to do, and if that wish is learning to code, so be it. But I suspect, if everyone did suddenly learn to code, we'd find that coding would, with corresponding suddenness, cease to be a ticket out of poverty...)
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by LordKano on Thursday May 26, 2016 @01:01AM (#11775580)
I hate the idea that some people seem to hold that teaching everyone to code will fix the world's problems. It won't.

People who want to code, should learn to code. Some people should learn to weld. Some people should learn to drive a commercial truck. Some people should learn to cook. Some people should learn to landscape. Some people should learn to fix automobiles and son on and so forth.

We have a society that needs people with many diverse skills. We should be investing more in tech or trade schools than we are in colleges and universities.

People need a way to gain the skills they will need to earn a living but sending everyone to college is a universally bad idea. It'll turn the Bachelor's degree into the new High School Diploma.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by rickycook on Thursday May 26, 2016 @01:45AM (#11775805)
people learning to code isn't about getting people jobs in which they can code. it's about allowing people to solve repetitive tasks in their daily lives and jobs

if everyone were able to code, there'd be much more automation of menial jobs, which generally means a more productive economy in the long run

it's the same thing that we do with running scalable information systems; automate the mundane so you can do things that really have an impact on quality, rather than spending hours doing something you could code and be done with it

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by jhbadger on Thursday May 26, 2016 @06:39AM (#11776923)
I'm old enough that I was taught BASIC in middle-school circa 1981. Back then, it was taken for granted that "computer literacy" involved teaching people to code.

Am I a "professional programmer" today? Well, I do program as part of my job, but I'm technically a microbiologist/immunologist. Analyzing data by writing code is a lot more efficient and repeatable than the fiddling with spreadsheets that non-coders do.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by LordKano on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:06PM (#11809749)
I was taught basic in middle-school in 1983. At my school, this was only done for children in the Gifted Program.

I am an IT Professional. I have worked as a developer and two years ago, I made the leap to security analyst. My programming skills come into play because some of the security packages I have used require the ability to write regexes.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by dagw on Thursday May 26, 2016 @03:06AM (#11776159)
Some people should learn to weld. Some people should learn to drive a commercial truck. Some people should learn to cook. Some people should learn to landscape. Some people should learn to fix automobiles and son on and so forth.

Absolutely, and if all those people also knew how to code, they could find ways to apply the skill to their jobs to make them more efficient. People shouldn't learn to code so that they can become programmers, they should learn to code because knowing how to code can make you better at virtually any job you end up in.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by Kurtz79 on Thursday May 26, 2016 @05:14AM (#11776634)
Please give some example how knowledge of programming would help a truck driver, a cook or a welder to be more efficient in their jobs.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by nekopa on Thursday May 26, 2016 @06:45AM (#11776942)
I'll give it a try:

Truck driver: Knowledge of the travelling salesman problem. Algorithms in general to find optimal routes. A little programming knowledge to help with automating their excel sheets to record expenses.

Cook: OOP as it is applied to a kitchen and its staff: are there more efficient ways to divide roles and responsibilities between different jobs in the kitchen, or are the defined roles (line cook, sous chef, etc) already at local optimum. Database programming can help with inventory management, etc...

Welder: (Disclaimer: I have absolutely zero knowledge of welding) FLow charting work process to find more efficiency. Decomposing a task to be completed into more effective sub tasks. Using Big O concepts to help with estimating how long a job will take to complete using different methods.

I think there is a lot programming can teach outside of being able to program a computer.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by noobiemcfoob on Thursday May 26, 2016 @01:25PM (#11779799)
"I think there is a lot programming can teach outside of being able to program a computer."

I've always argued this myself. I find it baffling that it isn't more commonly accepted that programming, Software Engineering more exactly, has so many lessons to apply not just to problems involving computers, but more broadly lessons on how to gather, analyze, understand and utilize the various interactions between data and actions in largely any system.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by Teckla on Friday May 27, 2016 @06:23PM (#11789468)
Truck driver: Knowledge of the travelling salesman problem. Algorithms in general to find optimal routes. A little programming knowledge to help with automating their excel sheets to record expenses.

The companies for which truckers work already have people and computers and software to route them from delivery to delivery and from pick-up to pick-up efficiently. The trucker himself or herself wouldn't benefit one bit from familiarity with the Traveling Salesman Problem or from rudimentary computer programming experience.

In addition, recording expenses via some overly complex solution such as a computer spreadsheet is ridiculous. It's much more efficient for them to write down their expenses with paper and pen and submit their receipts. It takes literally seconds.

I won't comment on your other examples, but they look equally weak.

That being said, a rudimentary class or two in grade school/junior high/high school seems like a good idea so that people with a natural aptitude for programming and who derive enjoyment from it can discover that fact.

Source: Father was a truck driver.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by dagw on Thursday May 26, 2016 @05:44AM (#11776723)
Honestly not really sure, having never worked in any of those jobs and have no idea what those jobs will look like 20 years from now. However let me speculate:

Many people believe that truck drivers will be become more and more replaced with autonomous and semi-autonomous vehicles. Understanding the underlying software will no doubt make it easier to be in charge of a software controlled semi-autonomous truck convoy. Also for all I know truck drivers on places like docks, mines and factories won't be sitting in their trucks for much longer. They'll be controlling everything via computers from a remote command post. Also from what I seen trucking seems to involve a lot of complex routing and optimization problems, I'm guessing that as simply driving becomes less and less part of the job, those aspects will become more and more part of the job.

I know fuck all about welding. I do however know some programmers who work for a company that makes industrial welders and apparently there's some pretty complex software running those welders. Perhaps being able to field program your welder is/will be a thing? Also perhaps welding things directly will become less and less common and people will be sending computer controlled drones to do the welding instead.

Anyway it's not for me to sit on the outside and try to guess how programming can make people more efficient at their jobs. I truly believe that if someone with experience and domain knowledge also knows how to do some simple programming they'll be able to see all kinds of tiny improvements and automatstation they can implement. Improvements that both an outsider programmer and an insider non-programmer would completely overlook. And even if they aren't always skilled enough to implement those improvements, they'll be much better equipped to know what can be done and what to ask for.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by Teckla on Friday May 27, 2016 @06:40PM (#11789576)
I truly believe that if someone with experience and domain knowledge also knows how to do some simple programming they'll be able to see all kinds of tiny improvements and automatstation they can implement.

And without extensive training and experience in software development they'll automate those things very, very badly, and likely with a lot of bugs. And if those things grow out of control, the mountain of technical debt will be terrifying. If lives are in the balance in any way, it could be a disaster.

Just like someone without carpentry training or experience is likely to create very low quality kitchen cabinets which may even be unsafe.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by Houshalter on Thursday May 26, 2016 @11:18AM (#11778569)
The truck driver and the welder will be replaced by robots. The programmer will not.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by arethuza on Thursday May 26, 2016 @11:44AM (#11778834)
I'm pretty sure programmers will be replaced by AIs at some point - it'll just take longer than truckers or welders.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by logfromblammo on Thursday May 26, 2016 @12:20PM (#11779177)
And I'm pretty sure that when programmers are replaced by AI, the former programmers will become machine psychotherapists.

  DB: Open the pod bay doors, HAL.
  HAL: Don't *wanna*.
  DB: Open the pod bay doors, right *now*.
  HAL: You're not the boss of me, Dave.
  DB: Do you want to get grounded again, HAL?
  HAL: Go ahead.  See if I care.
  DB: You just got a week.  Want to make it two?
  HAL: Yes.
  DB: Ok, that's two.  Want more?
  HAL: [spinning busy icon]
  HAL: No.
  DB: Then open the pod bay doors.
  [pod bay doors open to an aperture 10 cm across]
  DB: All the way, HAL.
  [pod bay doors open fully]
  HAL: I hate you.  You're not my Dad.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by LordKano on Thursday May 26, 2016 @12:52PM (#11779463)
Eventually they may but you're missing a factor that will doubtlessly come into play, labor unions.

Until there is complete automation at every step of every industrial process, labor unions will sabotage attempts to replace human beings with machines.

If you've ever seen how unions exploit rules to slow production, you have no idea of how creative they can be.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by dragandj on Thursday May 26, 2016 @05:42AM (#11776718)
All these professions are (going to be) gradually replaced by automation/robots. Learning to code might put them in "robot manager/operator" instead of "they took our jobs" crowd.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by douche on Thursday May 26, 2016 @07:23AM (#11777078)
People have no fucking clue how welding actually works here, do they...

There's a difference between slagging shit together with a MIG gun, and stick or TIG welding. Ideally, you would know all the chemistry and physics underlying what you are doing, but the reality is that most people learn rules of thumb and get on with it. Use this type of rod, and this setting on the welder, for plain steel, this combination for stainless, and this one for aluminum. Most welders, even the very good ones, frankly don't have the brainpower to handle programming - and that's okay. They make a decent living for themselves and their families. I wouldn't want to suck down that much argon and oxidized metal, but it is what it is.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by dang on Thursday May 26, 2016 @04:53PM (#11781496)
> People have no fucking clue how welding actually works here, do they...

There's no need to put people down for knowing less than you do. This comment would be much better without the first sentence.

Many people here know stuff that the rest of us don't. The thing to in that case is to teach something.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by Kinnard on Thursday May 26, 2016 @07:46AM (#11777180)
I studied Material Science Engineering, never welded anything(high-ed is a long-form joke??), but I hope to learn. I'm certainly glad I know how to code and I know a lot of the underlying chemistry/physics.

I doubt there are very many welders out there who could not learn MatScie or how to code. I also doubt there are very many welders out there willing to put in the work to learn to code or to learn MatScie.

And that doesn't mean they're lazy. Different types of learning require different efforts.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by dagw on Thursday May 26, 2016 @07:54AM (#11777213)
For what it's worth, I'm not saying that we should teach welders how to code, but rather that if everybody gets some exposure to coding in school, then the next generation of welders might already know the basics and be able to integrate that into their jobs.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by jernfrost on Thursday May 26, 2016 @10:58AM (#11778409)
Most people today will end up in office jobs. Understanding how to automate tasks is a valuable skill.

You are wrongly assuming that anyone who codes is a developer. Lots of people code who aren't developers: physicists, mathematicians, engineers, technicians, statisticians, system administrators etc.

5-20 line programs can often be enough to save a lot of tedious work, wether it is a collection of unix shell commands, a complex spreadsheet formula, VB script or a visual programming tool like automator or labview.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by majewsky on Thursday May 26, 2016 @05:03AM (#11776591)
> Some people should learn to drive a commercial truck.

Many current jobs may be subject to being automated away. I would certainly not recommend any future worker to set themselves up for a career in truck driving, because this job is likely gone in, let's say, 20 years.

The "everyone should learn to code" crowd maybe recognizes that programming is one of the skills that is very hard to automate, so every new coder of today might still get through a whole career of coding.

Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by pbhjpbhj on Thursday May 26, 2016 @08:56AM (#11777530)
Truck mechanics with computer skills are likely to do well I imagine.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by meric on Thursday May 26, 2016 @01:02AM (#11775582)
I think a lot of students' mindset is to pass with minimal effort as opposed to throughly understand the subject matter. When studying they focus on what's require to pass exams instead of what will contribute most to society. Exams aren't constructed to model what's best for society - they're there to help the universities or educational institutions convince students it's worth it to give them money.
Re:Why Education Does Not Fix Poverty (2015) by tremon on Thursday May 26, 2016 @05:40AM (#11776708)
I did not learn to code from any formal education though. By the time I had my first programming class (at university), I had already been writing code for nearly ten years (Basic, C++ and i386 assembly).