Because desperate people can be coerced to give up anything, whether they truly want to or not. Because these sorts of issues form the basis for many kinds of discrimination that society finds unacceptable.
Big="L" Libertarians and Randians opinions notwithstanding, there are worse things than preventing a race-to-the-bottom society built on degradation of the weakest individuals.
I do think that they perhaps haven't thought through the implications of what giving up their purchasing history could mean in a decade or two. Or maybe they have, and they're making the very rational choice to focus on the concrete effects of the here & now rather than some abstract consequences in the future. Data has an expiration date, after all.
Of course, we do make some conscious decisions to give up privacy - I don't give a damn who knows what I buy at the grocery store, so I'll have it tracked for 3% off - but a lot what people agree to isn't.
I think you have a point, but consider that there are many people who are counting every penny. But more importantly, consider the larger point that privacy shouldn't be only for those who can afford it.
Prohibiting doesn't fix the actual problem, only the symptom. It does, however, allow many to sleep well at night knowing they "helped" the poor.
Society prohibits many things and often it works fine. You can't run red lights, violate sanitation laws in your restaurant, defraud your customers, violate zoning laws, burn down your neighbor's house, practice medicine without a license, etc. Many of these rules have demonstrable positive outcomes.
Rather than applying an ideological theory to reality, I think we need to examine the data - the messy details - on what actually has worked and what hasn't, and where that's unavailable use serious, non-ideological economic analysis.
We successfully regulate many business practices to protect consumers, and Europe appears to successfully regulate privacy. Privacy doesn't seem particularly difficult to regulate, but I'm open to research on it.
> It does, however, allow many to sleep well at night knowing they "helped" the poor.
This starts with a fallacy about 'prohibiting', creates a fictional person who 'sleeps well' (implying the fictional person has some shallow view of the world), and mocks the fictional person. It's possible their feelings are hurt; perhaps you should consider apologizing?
Yes it does. I'm talking about this specific kind of prohibitions - taking away options from the poor for "their own good".
And I fully agree that privacy can be regulated and the EU does a decent job of it. They also happen to not prohibit me from giving/selling one's personal data away, so I'm not sure how it helps that argument.
As for the fallacy about prohibiting, the context of this conversation is about "deny[ing] these people their right to abandon their own privacy". What's denying a right if not prohibiting? If your argument is that privacy should be regulated in general, not that people should be denied the right to give it up, then you should say so, we're not mind readers.
* Most importantly, we often preserve people's fundamental freedoms by protecting them. You can't agree to be slave, for example; that is, you can say you agree and even play the role, but at any moment you can walk away and sue for unpaid wages and the employer/owner will be guilty of having violated labor laws. I think people's rights to privacy should similarly be protected.
* While maybe we shouldn't outlaw people's rights to sell private data, we can outlaw others from buying them.
* In some circumstances, people have literal freedom but not a realistic ability to make a choice, due to lack of expertise or exploitation: We don't let people choose to be part of dangerous medical experiments, for example; the experiments must be approved. People lack the expertise to make an informed choice (and even approved medical experiments take care with how prospective subjects are informed). We don't let vulnerable populations be used for medical experiments; For example, prisoners and children can too easily be pressured into participating, against their will. I'm honestly not sure to what degree privacy fits this category; people understand the concept, but they have no idea of how their information is used and the risks of that.
Informing, requiring consent and - especially - offering better alternatives to the "exploitative" option should, in my opinion, be used instead of the paternalistic prohibition (which is often just a cover for other interests).
What do you think would happen if supermarkets were allowed to have shelves with cheaper groceries that are not subject to the usual health standards?
People will gladly trade their health for discount coffee as well. Do you think that's a good idea as well?
Could we not argue that poor privacy standards create a toxic environment for everyone, not just the poor who are directly subjected to it?
By moving privacy to "only those who have paid for it" you're moving the liability for privacy to the victim rather than the perpetrator.
These type of food safety issues aren't one where choice is an option, these are issues of malice or neglect.
The right of privacy is individual, sure, and can be waived for purposes. Some might not mind. I'm personally okay with that side. But I also think it's pretty easy to come up with examples of private data being misused due to malice and/or neglect. (Particularly the later... it sure seems like companies have a poor track record in keeping data secure.)
I don't understand your argument. Why are they by definition not going to be labeled?
We're discussing the merits of replacing the current law that bans the sale of potentially unsafe food with one that requires such food to be clearly labeled. To know which food they can't sell, producers must know which food is potentially unsafe, therefore they could label it instead. And if you're going to assume that producers will break the law, why would they respect the law banning the sale?
I also think it's pretty easy to come up with examples of private data being misused due to malice and/or neglect.
It's pretty easy to find malice and neglect in almost every possible social interaction. By itself, it can't be a sufficient argument, otherwise we'd be prohibiting people from having children!
Personally, I doubt it (at any rate I am aware of no law where victim ignorance is a defense for a malicious act).
Now, I do understand what you are saying for cases where the safety risk is more minimal or specific, labeling is all that is needed. So food safety laws often are fine with people consuming, say, undercooked / raw seafood, provided a warning is given that certain people probably should avoid this type of food. I think in a way we're talking about different things, but "food standards" cover a lot of things.
Anyways, this is where I come from in regard to privacy. I don't believe that every time you waive your right to privacy, something awful happens. So I'm not talking about a general ban of waiving the right to privacy. However, I do believe privacy standards need to be strengthened to help prevent (or at least correct) such cases as malicious misuse of private data (example: doxxing) and neglect of private data (example: hacked websites that expose databases of information to criminals).
Not just having melamine in the list of ingredients, but actually clearly labeling the danger. Obviously nobody would sell milk saying "Danger of death", therefore that case is irrelevant (selling without the label would still be illegal, since it's fraud, not just "protecting people from their own decisions", which is what I'm arguing against).
However, I do believe privacy standards need to be strengthened to help prevent (or at least correct) such cases as malicious misuse of private data (example: doxxing) and neglect of private data (example: hacked websites that expose databases of information to criminals).
I fully agree, and I'm quite happy to live in the EU which has at least some decent privacy protections, but those aren't cases in which people are willingly giving up anything.
Also, as people who are into cheese or beef will tell you: you should go for the oldest one available at the shelf anyway ;-)
A lot, I suspect.
CCTV cameras. "Real Name" policies. Corporate monetization of user data. Third-party cookie networks. Password/data leaks. Doxxing. Tape over laptop webcams. PRISM. TVs with built-in microphones and cameras. Facebook listening to your ambient audio. It is an incessant and relentless reality that everything we say, do, and soon think, is being collated to enable later correlation possibly years from now.
And yes, I feel capable of choosing how much of my data I give away. But that's a feeling I get by virtue of being a privacy-concerned software developer. To get what I would consider a basic level of control in a web browser requires half a dozen scripts, extensions, or settings changes. Do you really expect someone who's never heard of Javascript to understand why disabling execute-scripts-by-default is an important step for privacy and security?
I've had smart, STEM-employed family members ask me to "set up privacy stuff on my computer". Even at a medium-low level (no VPN, no Linux) it takes me a decent amount of time and thought, and I already know the tools and topics I want to deal with. My mom shouldn't need a third college degree to understand how to protect her privacy.
How many people do you think are fully aware of what tracking they're subject to? Every time you hit a webpage, or see a "share on Facebook" button, or take a smartphone somewhere, that's another data point. Usually the concession of privacy is made before you know what you're agreeing to - you open a webpage, then see how many tendrils of user tracking you've just been touched by.
If you want to talk about whether I should be able to sell my private information, absolutely. I can sell it for discounts (on insurance, say) or straight cash (see Datacoup) and that's my right. But it feels like burying the real issue to discuss that instead of the unannounced, implicit-consent tracking that defines most of our technology today.
In any capitalist system, if anything is permitted, someone (i.e. the poor) will be coerced into doing it.
A truly compassionate society would offer better alternatives, so that nobody would be coerced.
Prohibitionism is not a solution to anything except to the guilt in the moral conscience of the well-fed middle class.
We aren't discussing restructuring all of society radically and enacting a massive cultural and political revolution right now, we are discussing specific privacy law in specific technical settings in our socioeconomic and legal circumstances.
Prohibition works very well, depending on the circumstances. But you know this, of course: you are simply making a rhetorically contentless incendiary broad generalization. Murder is illegal and there is less murder. Fraud is illegal and there is less fraud.
My point is that they are being exploited, because even being exploited is better than the alternatives they have, and by prohibiting it, you're actually harming the people you're supposedly trying to help. My argument is not a Nirvana fallacy. I'm saying that we're actually better off doing nothing than prohibiting people from taking the least worse option they have.
If we want to help, we should provide an alternative (and no, this certainly doesn't require an end of capitalism). If we can't do that, we should leave it alone.
Prohibition works very well, depending on the circumstances. But you know this, of course: you are simply making a rhetorically contentless incendiary broad generalization. Murder is illegal and there is less murder. Fraud is illegal and there is less fraud.
I thought it was clear from context, but I'll be specific: I'm talking about Prohibitionism as in preventing people from deciding what to do with their lives "for their own good", much like the Prohitibion Party did with alcohol in the early 20th century.
I almost stopped reading there. The author does not understand that the privacy right is held by the individual. It can be waived. A generation ago we thought that people wanted to protect their privacy. We now know that many don't. Many will trade their entire life history for a discount coffee. Why should we deny these people their right to abandon their own privacy?