Could we not argue that poor privacy standards create a toxic environment for everyone, not just the poor who are directly subjected to it?
By moving privacy to "only those who have paid for it" you're moving the liability for privacy to the victim rather than the perpetrator.
These type of food safety issues aren't one where choice is an option, these are issues of malice or neglect.
The right of privacy is individual, sure, and can be waived for purposes. Some might not mind. I'm personally okay with that side. But I also think it's pretty easy to come up with examples of private data being misused due to malice and/or neglect. (Particularly the later... it sure seems like companies have a poor track record in keeping data secure.)
I don't understand your argument. Why are they by definition not going to be labeled?
We're discussing the merits of replacing the current law that bans the sale of potentially unsafe food with one that requires such food to be clearly labeled. To know which food they can't sell, producers must know which food is potentially unsafe, therefore they could label it instead. And if you're going to assume that producers will break the law, why would they respect the law banning the sale?
I also think it's pretty easy to come up with examples of private data being misused due to malice and/or neglect.
It's pretty easy to find malice and neglect in almost every possible social interaction. By itself, it can't be a sufficient argument, otherwise we'd be prohibiting people from having children!
Personally, I doubt it (at any rate I am aware of no law where victim ignorance is a defense for a malicious act).
Now, I do understand what you are saying for cases where the safety risk is more minimal or specific, labeling is all that is needed. So food safety laws often are fine with people consuming, say, undercooked / raw seafood, provided a warning is given that certain people probably should avoid this type of food. I think in a way we're talking about different things, but "food standards" cover a lot of things.
Anyways, this is where I come from in regard to privacy. I don't believe that every time you waive your right to privacy, something awful happens. So I'm not talking about a general ban of waiving the right to privacy. However, I do believe privacy standards need to be strengthened to help prevent (or at least correct) such cases as malicious misuse of private data (example: doxxing) and neglect of private data (example: hacked websites that expose databases of information to criminals).
Not just having melamine in the list of ingredients, but actually clearly labeling the danger. Obviously nobody would sell milk saying "Danger of death", therefore that case is irrelevant (selling without the label would still be illegal, since it's fraud, not just "protecting people from their own decisions", which is what I'm arguing against).
However, I do believe privacy standards need to be strengthened to help prevent (or at least correct) such cases as malicious misuse of private data (example: doxxing) and neglect of private data (example: hacked websites that expose databases of information to criminals).
I fully agree, and I'm quite happy to live in the EU which has at least some decent privacy protections, but those aren't cases in which people are willingly giving up anything.
Also, as people who are into cheese or beef will tell you: you should go for the oldest one available at the shelf anyway ;-)
What do you think would happen if supermarkets were allowed to have shelves with cheaper groceries that are not subject to the usual health standards?
People will gladly trade their health for discount coffee as well. Do you think that's a good idea as well?