News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why you should bet big on privacy by icebraining on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @02:50AM (#11768073)
Society prohibits many things and often it works fine.

Yes it does. I'm talking about this specific kind of prohibitions - taking away options from the poor for "their own good".

And I fully agree that privacy can be regulated and the EU does a decent job of it. They also happen to not prohibit me from giving/selling one's personal data away, so I'm not sure how it helps that argument.

As for the fallacy about prohibiting, the context of this conversation is about "deny[ing] these people their right to abandon their own privacy". What's denying a right if not prohibiting? If your argument is that privacy should be regulated in general, not that people should be denied the right to give it up, then you should say so, we're not mind readers.

Re:Why you should bet big on privacy by hackuser on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @10:20AM (#11769924)
I see what you are saying. In principle, I agree that laws shouldn't restrict people's freedom to choose to do such things but reality is messy, as always: This issue is more complex than a simple principle and there are different, equally valid ways to conceptualize it:

* Most importantly, we often preserve people's fundamental freedoms by protecting them. You can't agree to be slave, for example; that is, you can say you agree and even play the role, but at any moment you can walk away and sue for unpaid wages and the employer/owner will be guilty of having violated labor laws. I think people's rights to privacy should similarly be protected.

* While maybe we shouldn't outlaw people's rights to sell private data, we can outlaw others from buying them.

* In some circumstances, people have literal freedom but not a realistic ability to make a choice, due to lack of expertise or exploitation: We don't let people choose to be part of dangerous medical experiments, for example; the experiments must be approved. People lack the expertise to make an informed choice (and even approved medical experiments take care with how prospective subjects are informed). We don't let vulnerable populations be used for medical experiments; For example, prisoners and children can too easily be pressured into participating, against their will. I'm honestly not sure to what degree privacy fits this category; people understand the concept, but they have no idea of how their information is used and the risks of that.

Re:Why you should bet big on privacy by icebraining on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:55PM (#11771209)
I know we as western societies take similar positions on other issues; I'm generally critical of them. People don't need to be experts to make informed decisions; FSM knows politicians aren't experts on most things they decide upon.

Informing, requiring consent and - especially - offering better alternatives to the "exploitative" option should, in my opinion, be used instead of the paternalistic prohibition (which is often just a cover for other interests).