Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by amelius on Monday May 23, 2016 @05:24AM
(#11752731)
I'm beginning to believe that answering factoid questions is still too expensive, from a computational point of view, to put in an API.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by TheOtherHobbes on Monday May 23, 2016 @06:34AM
(#11752944)
I'm beginning to believe IBM is a sinking battleship. Considering the job losses and the - insane - direction set by the board, it's not obvious IBM will still be around five years from now.
Besides, a really good AI should literally be able to sell itself, surely?
Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by rrrx3 on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:24AM
(#11754013)
Let's not make any grandstand statements - IBM may or may not be a sinking battleship (I'm inclined to think they are), but not being around in 5 years is a pretty specious prediction. They'll still be around, and still be peddling malformed solutions. They may be significantly different in leadership, presentation, and execution, but they'll still be around.
Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by rvdm on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:27PM
(#11755788)
I'd love to see how IBM themselves have used Watson to improve their own business.
This, as a potential Watson customer, would give me a much better idea of Watson's potential and real world results. Plus it would establishes more confidence in IBM.
A lesson from my high school economics teacher that has always stuck with me is that you have to be your own product's biggest believer.
Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by pesenti on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:54AM
(#11754226)
No. That's not the issue. We are actually able to shrink wrap it to a point that it has reasonable footprint (a few servers). The problem with factoids are twofold:
- It's always a small part of a broader use case (how many queries do you do on Google that are answered by the factoid pipeline?).
- It has a lot of domain dependency. It's fine to do it like Jeopardy for general domain, but our customer want domain specificity and that's non-trivial.
Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by daveguy on Monday May 23, 2016 @08:45AM
(#11753473)
I agree. I think this is exactly why it isn't available as an API. They probably had supercomputers worth backing Watson, which they couldn't provide for every single API query. Although I still don't know why they didn't provide it and price it accordingly -- $1 / question or whatever it would require. Or shoot -- price it at expense as a loss leader. Even if they had a person filtering and approving each jeopardy answer they could price it to allow that.