News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by CM30 on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:16PM (#11746223)
I'm going to be extremely unpopular for saying this, but I still think the self driving car problem should be solved by having them value the people in the car more than those on the road around them. Is that immoral? Maybe, but if I'm buying a car, I like to think it's looking out for me first and someone else seven hundred and fifty sixth.

Of course, this is rather less of an issue that it seems, since the article itself points out that other, more normal safety features are being included that lower the risk from accidental collisions and the cars might not be going fast enough for this sort of issue to be a concern in most instances (read, those not involving a motorway or autobahn). And in those cases, well, anyone who might be in the path of such a car in such a situation might be best classed as 'too dumb to live', since high speed roads are not good places for pedestrian crossings or playing chicken.

But in the 0.00001% of cases which this issue might be a thing, then they should honestly just value the driver and passengers. Like every other tool and item in human society,for good or bad alike.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by ChuckMcM on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:34PM (#11746292)
I actually got a rather deep insight from the article, which was "How would an autonomous car get itself into such a situation?"

Such a car would not drive so close to a truck that it could not simply stop should the truck lose its cargo. It would not approach a tunnel at a rate of speed where it could not brake to avoid an obstruction. People do that because they ignore risk in favor of some perceived time advantage, but robots don't.

If we imagine the sets of circumstances that require a life and death decision to occur while driving safely, suddenly the number becomes vanishingly small. Things like "an earthquake occurs and the bridge you are on loses a section." or "a power transformer explodes and drops a power line across the road", or "a plane crashes into the ground in front of you." Under these extreme situations how the human in control would perform is practically a random number function. That a robot would minimize the loss of life, seems like the "correct" choice regardless.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by facetube on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:53PM (#11746351)
Completely agree. The self-driving car doesn't need to pick who to kill, mostly because it started braking 1.5 seconds ago.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by Retric on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:14PM (#11746415)
Exactly.

People sometimes need the back sides of lane markers to be red to show there driving in the wrong direction at highway speeds. That's the kind of safety issues self driving cars need to address. Highly convoluted but what if a clown and a child jump off an overpass style crap completely misses the point. Self driving cars could chose to randomly kill someone randomly once per 1,000 years on the road and still end up safer than people.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by CM30 on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:43PM (#11746524)
Safer than what's already there is a valid point, but it's also (somewhat unfortunately) not one a lot of legal systems tend to go by. For example, it's likely that if alcohol or tobacco was invented in this decade, it would have been banned as a 'dangerous' drug. But safer alternatives aren't exactly legalised because they're safer than what's already out there.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by Retric on Saturday May 21, 2016 @10:20PM (#11747134)
Depends on how similar something is. There are a lot of drugs that are basically morphine with basically all it's downsides, that have been approved. ex: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydromorphone Trying to get a drug like that approved on it's own would have been vastly harder.

As to cars the major upside is they are all one on one collisions. And insurance companies are really good at handling that already. There are even laws limiting how much pedestrians for example can sue for if they are struck in some areas.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by CM30 on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:45PM (#11746327)
Yeah, the chance of such a situation occurring is pretty much slim to none. A driverless car isn't going to be driving like a maniac at many times the speed limit and putting itself into dangerous situations at every opportunity.

Then again, given some of the stuff there's a market for, I guess there is the worry that 'driverless car aimed at person who wants to be in James Bond/Bullitt/whatever' might turn out to be a selling point for some manufacturers with questionable ethics.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by JulianMorrison on Saturday May 21, 2016 @09:05PM (#11746986)
Knight Rider, surely.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by Tiktaalik on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:50PM (#11746554)
Supposing autonomous cars actually drive extremely safely and this results in them going 20 km/h under the speed limit. Are drivers going to be happy about the length of their commute increasing while regular car drivers (due to human recklessness) wiz by in the left lane at 130 km/h? I think you'd see a lot of human drivers get frustrated and turn off the AI.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by kenshaw on Saturday May 21, 2016 @08:26PM (#11746876)
Actually, I'd predict the opposite -- that people will purposefully start to increase their commute times and tell the car to "take the scenic route." People are frustrated with commuting because they have to be mentally engaged doing it. When that's no longer a requirement, people will watch movies/tv, read books / news articles, do their makeup/prep their hair, give each other massages/have sex, play video games, etc. etc. instead of driving their cars. I wouldn't put it entirely out of the question (except for the issue of fuel costs) that people will start buying bigger cars (akin to RVs or campers) so that they can take all their crap with them. I can almost guarantee you that people will basically want to roll out of bed into their offices / place of work, assuming the driving can be done all automatically.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by CM30 on Sunday May 22, 2016 @11:30AM (#11748930)
Depends what they're commuting for. A lot of businesses want you to be there even day at 9pm on the dot, no exceptions. For people working at companies like this, minimising their daily commute is basically essential, since their bosses will not negotiate on things like start times, end times and the amount of work done in the day.

Do people really want to lose their remaining time with their family just to spend it commuting and doing the same stuff they could be at doing at home in the car? How about losing their sleep in the morning because their car takes longer to get them to work than it used to?

Some people might want to roll straight out of bed and into their offices/workplace. A lot of others would rather minimise the time spent going to/leaving work and spend it in their own home doing stuff they want to be doing.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by ygjb on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:00PM (#11746581)
Yes, once they get past the initial adjustment, assuming we have actual autonomous cars, and not 95% autonomous that require a completely alert individual driving them, then the commute is not lost time, it can be time spent working, relaxing, or doing something besides simply staring at the bumper of the person ahead of them.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by pekk on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:59PM (#11746579)
Laminar flow might actually be faster than turbulent flow where everyone perceives they are "getting ahead".

Particularly when this "getting ahead" behavior results in accidents that require road closures that back up highways for hours of bumper-to-bumper traffic.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by matt_wulfeck on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:00PM (#11746580)
i think it's a little early in the self driving cycle to be upset at their speed. There's no limitation keeping them going slow. In fact they could easily and safety drive much faster.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by lisivka on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:55PM (#11746781)
We are already have fully automatic transportation machines: lifts. Are you happy with them? Do you want to use faster lifts at exchange of higher risk of injure or death? Do you want such faster lifts for others or for your family?

IMHO, safety will win. Human life is much more valuable than wasted time. 50km/h is consider as safe speed for human driver in city. Computers are faster, so 60-70km/h will be safe for them.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by bryanlarsen on Sunday May 22, 2016 @12:05AM (#11747339)
The maximum safe speed on any street where there is the possibility of a kid hidden behind a parked car is 30 km/h, no matter human or robot driver.

A 30 kph collision with a pedestrian is almost always survivable. Anything faster isn't.

Robots can react faster, but cars still take time to stop. Most streets don't have more than a couple of feet of distance between moving traffic and parked cars. Reaction time is meaningless there.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by lisivka on Sunday May 22, 2016 @05:11AM (#11747890)
Robots can adjust speed of the car according to situation, especially on electric cars with recuperation of energy in brakes. Robots can use statistics or history of incidents to improve safety.

Robots can use also other things to improve safety, which cannot be used by human driver because (s)he is busy with driving, e.g. "laser" pointers of car direction of drive at road, like "mark my lane" light used by bicyclist; or directed audio/video/vibration alarms to warn of potential crash; or safety hands at front of car (like human hands), which will be released by computer to pickup child right before hit, or to to take hit from larger distance, slowly, or to change direction of car, or remove something from the road.

Humans cannot do that but robots can.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by Tiktaalik on Saturday May 21, 2016 @08:03PM (#11746805)
If our society was actually that concerned with safety we would have backtracked from automobile infrastructure a long time ago, but we've allowed them to dominate our public space despite the dangers they pose.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by caseysoftware on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:04PM (#11746389)
I think there's a positive feedback loop in there too...

As cars go autonomous, they'll communicate faster, drive more predictably, and generally be safer. At some point - 1%, 5%, 20%? - the network as a whole will benefit with less accidents and less of the resulting delays which means human drivers will be less likely to be late which takes away anxiety and potential distractions, making it even safer.

Therefore, I think these "Do I kill A or B?" scenarios become less frequent over time.

I just hope that "over time" part happens quickly... or the first "bad" choice by an autonomous car will delay the industry by years.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by kordless on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:30PM (#11746473)
It's all about perspective. If 1M people a year die in auto accidents and you improve that by dropping it to 100K a year, you've done something worthwhile with technology. But, once it's 100K, taking it to 10K deaths a year is 10X as hard of a problem. Etc.

What I'm saying is that there are diminishing returns on eliminating all accidents, unless you are continuously elevating someone's life to an infinite value (your own, for example).

Is our expectation at some point that ZERO people of INFINITE value die shuttling themselves physically around this planet every a year? I'd be willing to accept a small chance of death (by contract even) if I always got to my appointments on time. Think of it as a fancy donor card.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by sokoloff on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:15PM (#11746633)
Is the second 90% reduction really 10X as hard as the first 90% reduction? That doesn't seem at all obvious to me. Sure, each 100 death reduction is harder, but the pace of progress seems it should be about a straight line when graphed semi-log.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by weaksauce on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:53PM (#11746562)
just like Fukushima/Chernobyl/three mile island has slowed the enthusiasm for nuclear energy even though it's safer than coal overall.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by rimantas on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:35PM (#11746716)
What prevents to deploy these systems (e.g. start braking if on collision course) whith human still under the wheel?
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by zwily on Saturday May 21, 2016 @09:51PM (#11747078)
Nothing - there are already several cars that do it.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by mcbits on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:57PM (#11746366)
Putting the occupants' safety first is probably the best default to start with, as it's pretty close to what we have already, although given enough time, there will surely be cases where the car chooses to save the driver when the driver would have sacrificed themselves willingly or by some miscalculation.

But I think the ethical dilemma will end up solving itself over time, as well. When a car has to make an emergency decision, it will make a 5-10 millisecond call to its attorney, Dr. Watson, Esq., who will review all case history and settlements, run background checks on the potential victims, weigh all the factors against the current political climate, and direct the car to choose the accident with the lowest expected liability.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by csydas on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:39PM (#11746303)
I think the issue is slightly misguided as well, but not quite in that way. I think it's sort of natural that the idea of a merged driver and driverless vehicle lanes will eventually vanish, and sections of highway and city roads will eventually give way to entirely autonomous solutions. Segregating the driving population in this way removes a lot of the concerns, since now when faced with the issue of "wayward child in road", a single car doesn't have to make a decision, but instead, collectively cars decide how to mitigate the situation.

This does come with quite a few caveats in regards to road surveillance and infrastructure and legal turnabout, but it makes a lot more sense than trying to merge the two completely different styles of driving. Essentially that is the problem that will cause accidents; pretty much everyone who drive should know that traffic patterns that deviate from what is expected and currently existing on the road are common causes for accidents. Trying to merge two completely separate types of driving just seems like a fools errand, though I do understand that the alternative would probably be a bit too much for the current public and governments.

Ultimately though, I think that while the ethical concerns are real, they become greatly diminished along with the natural evolution of where autonomous cars take city infrastructure.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by unclebucknasty on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:48PM (#11746333)
>if I'm buying a car, I like to think it's looking out for me first and someone else seven hundred and fifty sixth

It seems that, as driverless cars become more common, you are more frequently on the other side of the equation.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by ilostmykeys on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:23PM (#11746256)
"Me first" is pretty dumb in the global sense. Cooperative (nit me first) games are the way to greater benefit for everyone.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by bsder on Saturday May 21, 2016 @08:24PM (#11746868)
> "Me first" is pretty dumb in the global sense. Cooperative (nit me first) games are the way to greater benefit for everyone.

Only for games with multiple iterations.

In addition, "Me first" strategies often create something fairly close to optimal for a lot of cases--we call them "greedy" algorithms for a reason.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by ucarion on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:44PM (#11746324)
People who worry about the moral decision-making of a car are pointing out that there's a sort of ethics reduction (in the math sense of the word) here: deciding on the ideal driverless car is about as hard as deciding on what the ideal moral framework is. The car must have some routine to deal with trolley problems somewhere.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by Shivetya on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:48PM (#11746331)
If we follow Asimov, your car will take the hit and likely that is how it should be. The car's only judgment call should be, can I avoid this threat without threatening another?

You run into a cascade problem if your car decides to weigh the fates of other cars by trying to run some value comparison. Who sets the values? Can they be spoofed, and so on.

So first rule is that it cannot harm another vehicle to save itself. You aren't really part of the equation here, you cannot be. By the act of using the autonomous automobile you and it become one for sake of the how the rules play out.

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by ikeboy on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:32PM (#11746286)
I agree. If doing so makes people more willing to adopt driverless cars, it may save more lives.

However, if the person would only be injured, it should prefer that to someone else's death (as the person himself would be legally obligated to do.)

Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by facetube on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:55PM (#11746359)
Do we actually have a model that can predict death vs. serious injury vs. minor injury in advance?
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by ikeboy on Saturday May 21, 2016 @06:02PM (#11746382)
Perhaps not perfectly, but surely there are scenarios where it is predictable.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars by ygjb on Saturday May 21, 2016 @07:01PM (#11746585)
Can you identify a scenario where an injury is possible that death cannot be an outcome?