What I would compare it to though are other deceptive business marketing practices like photoshopping before and after pics for weight-loss products, or marketing your dog food as premium, all natural meat based when it is in fact the same junk, bought from the same supplier, as another dog food brand that costs half as much (and is specifically called out as inferior in commercials).
At the least, even if not criminal, it would seem to open the door to civil lawsuits.
Its current "agenda" is based on reputable news sources, plus Fox News (1):
"We measure this by checking if it is leading at least 5 of the following 10 news websites: BBC News, CNN, Fox News, The Guardian, NBC News, The New York Times, USA Today, The Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, Yahoo News or Yahoo."
I'd say that was a fair reflection of mainstream media.
If you object to those, what's your personal agenda based on, and how mainstream is it?
(1) Fox News has specifically said in court that it is not required to be truthful.
I don't see the need for you to put those digs in against Fox News.
I get people don't like Fox News. I'm not a fan. But everyone here (on the whole) seems to hold a similar opinion, so the digs aren't necessary.
They weren't even germain to your point. You were making a perfectly good argument that numerous sources from both sides of the spectrum were included. I felt your commentary and singling out of Fox News distracted me from that.
If you had editorialized about the quality of the other sources then the commentary on the quality of Fox would have fit in.
your comment seems like two disparate things in one. On the one hand it notes that Facebook appeared to try to balance things. On the other hand it felt like a slam at Fox News couched in the form of a comment that might fit in. Clearly you can't write "Fox sucks" as a comment because it wouldn't be in topic. But if you weave it in...
It just distracted me from what I took to be your point, harming the force/usefulness of your comment.
Secondly, I too won't claim that FOX News isn't uniquely bad. But the criticism of it that people toss around always feels kneejerk rather than pointing out they're leading the pack of disastrous "news" programming. After a decade of Jon Stewart vilifying FOX News, he didn't get actually people to think critically about news sources - just FOX. And it's not even critical thinking, he just managed to demonize the outlet away from being taken seriously.
What is the purpose of pointing out FOX is a bad news org to a left-leaning crowd? Or a mixed crowd that is smart enough to already know of the well-established criticism of the network? I can't help but see it as perpetuating demonization rather than elevating critical thinking applied to all news sources. In either scenario FOX News is trash, but only one scenario are you actually helping people become better news consumers.
If this bothers you, contact Fox.
(If you're gonna be That Guy and hurr about sports being entertainment, you can pass.)
As previously mentioned their sports coverage is superb.
Yahoo has at least experimented with original content but I am not sure if they still have it.
[1] http://www.npr.org/sections/alltechconsidered/2016/02/26/467...
His quote from that article explains it
"'Black lives matter' doesn't mean other lives don't. It's simply asking that the black community also achieves the justice they deserve. We've never had rules around what people can write on our walls — we expect everybody to treat each other with respect. Regardless of the content or location, crossing out something means silencing speech, or that one person's speech is more important than another's."
There may be other cases of him pushing the "left agenda" but I don't think the article you link shows it.
Ha! Yes, actually it does mean that. Otherwise you would not single out a single group as more deserving of life than others.
When you call out a specific thing in your argument, you do that to specifically exclude other similar items.
It doesn't say "Black lives matter more than others."
Everyone who understands why it's "Black Lives Matter!" instead of "All Lives Matter!" also understands why you think it should be "All Lives Matter!", we just disagree. There's no subtlety to your point, it's blunt and easy to understand.
The difference is, people who think it should be "All Lives Matter!" don't understand why we think it should be "Black Lives Matter!". There's a nuanced point that you don't seem to understand. When you suggest that we're saying black lives matter more than any other lives, you make it clear that you don't get it. This is fine, if you stop misrepresenting the intentions of others they might be willing to explain it to you.
Edit: And by the way, you don't have to agree with it the nuanced point in order to understand it. So Zuck insisting people not cross out "Black Lives Matter" is not him pushing that as an agenda -- it's just him showing an understanding that "Black Lives Matter!" is not the same as "White Power!"
Really? Didn't this slogan arise in the context of a black life trying to kill, or at least harm, another life? How can they possibly defend such a person? And to make him the center of this saying?
It's very clear they mean "Black life matters more than other life." If they meant anything else they would not defend attempted murderers and thugs.
>>> white_lives = {"matter": True}
>>> black_lives = {"matter": True}
>>> black_lives['matter'] == True
True
The statement 'black lives matter' doesn't cause white_lives['matter'] to evaluate to false, or to less than black_lives['matter']. Sometimes you call out a specific thing just to assert its truth.It doesn't work that way in English. If you call it out it's because you feel there is something distinct about it that is different from the other members of its group.
Saying "Black lives matter" implicitly says "and others don't", and even if you won't agree to that, at a bare minimum it says "black lives matter more than other lives".
It doesn't help that this slogan arose in a context of defending a black life that was trying to take another life, or at least harm another life. By defending such a person, as they have done, they are very clearly saying "that black life matters more than other life".
Context matters. Every time they use that saying it reminds people that these activists are defending attempted murderers.
Exactly. The thing that's distinct is that, in the US, it is necessary to assert that black lives matter. It's not necessary to assert that white lives matter because that's a given.
You may not agree with that view, but that's the view held by most people who say "Black Lives Matter!" You seem convinced that your alternative hypothesis is true, that we all think black lives matter more than other lives. Ask yourself honestly if your alternative hypothesis is just a convenient straw man, easy to argue against, easy to use to cast people who disagree with you as horrible people.
I'm curious what you think of the common advice of parents to little boys, "Treat women with respect." Would you start blathering about how you should treat everyone with respect? Obviously you should treat everyone with respect, but there's a reason to call out women in particular as deserving of respect -- because it's all too common for them not to get it.
You may not like this way of getting a point across, but if you pretend it doesn't exist you risk coming off as a person who doesn't understand nuance.
So, now that you understand this, could you please stop suggesting that people who support "Black Lives Matter!" think other lives don't matter as much?
No, I don't think all of you think that. I definitely think the founders of the movement think that.
> I'm curious what you think of the common advice of parents to little boys, "Treat women with respect."
Since you asked, I would find that quite sexist and I would never tell anyone that, because it implies that women are inferior and need special protection.
If in fact they do need special protection, then fine. For example the anti-discrimination against blacks laws of the Civil Rights Act in 1964.
Now, I know what you are thinking: Blacks do need special protection, so we need this slogan. Except that the heroes of the slogan are criminals who brought things on themself.
The fact that that is the origin story of the slogan is a big problem for me, and I have a hard time accepting that anyone would support it.
> You may not like this way of getting a point across, but if you pretend it doesn't exist you risk coming off as a person who doesn't understand nuance.
I understand it, I simply disagree with it. It's not the same thing.
> So, now that you understand this, could you please stop suggesting that people who support "Black Lives Matter!" think other lives don't matter as much?
I'll stop suggesting it, when they stop supporting criminals.
For example, I would routinely fire most employees who expressed sentiments similar to Donald Trump's in an office. I would not censor Trump from customer feeds though.
He's been calling out people who vandalize messages they don't like - in particular, BLM.
Rather than oversimplifying, I think the OP is more likely correct and I fully expect Mark and team to wake up in the morning wondering how they can use their privileged access to many millions of users to advance whatever agenda they are supporting that day (political or economic); within some limits of "seemliness", of course. I expect them to act on those thoughts, too.
Perhaps it is an oversimplification to bundle ideologies into a monolithic "left" and "right"; reality there is more complex than that. However, for the purposes of generalization it's not unreasonable to group people together when many of their ideologies bear resemblance to the archetypes of political division. To be overly literal about that is, itself, being overly simplistic.
The power Facebook has. Power needs to be controlled. As a lefty-ish person I'm not up in arms about this, but I see the problem.
The article specifically points out that human editors were introduced after Facebook failed to surface Ferguson protests—making it look bad because those protests were in fact trending on Twitter. Moreover, some theoretical perfect algorithm could have asserted that was a trending topic.
In fact, there is not perfect algorithm for determining what is "trending." Part of hiring human curators is to train an algorithm which can more effectively use judgement in figuring out topics which are truly trending/newsworthy/interesting instead of coincidentally used a lot without being valuable (ex. #FollowFriday).
Moreover, it seems clear that injecting stories is actually relatively rare. The primary reason to have human curators is to do filtering to prevent the junk from showing up in trending.
By whom? I'm legitimately asking this as a lefty-ish person.
It is controlled. You're suggesting that it should be controlled by different people.
Unless you're a publicly traded company, which Facebook is. Then you are beholden to the people who are invested in your company; some of which I would assume are probably conservative and right leaning.
If FB was still a private company, then yeah, your sentiment holds true. All bets are off when you're a publicly traded and funded company. At that point, it's the investors who tell you what the direction of the company is. Don't like it? Then buyout all the shareholders and return your company back to the private realm.
It may be a little nit-picky to point it out, but in the general sense this isn't true. As soon as the company went public it stopped being Mark Zuckerburg's business and enterprise, becoming instead the property of the shareholders who employ Zuckerburg to look after their company. Zuckerburg owns less than 30%.
http://venturebeat.com/2012/02/01/zuck-power-play/
But the point remains, even if it's kind of technical when he can always outvote everyone else. He can't treat the company as his personal fiefdom if it crosses the legal interests of other shareholders. If he goes too far they can probably sue successfully.
We all have legal rights to do things that are morally wrong. He has a resposibility to the world to be a responsible citizen, just as we all do.
Prior and current generations of responsible citizens are mostly responsible for Facebook: Without generations of people doing the responsible thing, even dying, for democracy, liberty, science and technlogy, education, infrastructure, law, etc. ... he'd be living in a country and world where there would be no technology, legal rights, literacy, or many other things necessary to Facebook.
This is only biased if we can provide concrete evidence that similar tabloid-esque publications that happened to align "left" of the political spectrum in the U.S. were allowed to pass while their political counterparts were passed up.
If the standard for journalism remained constant, but the sources that were "suppressed" largely happen to be conservative that doesn't seem like a problem with curation, it seems like a problem for the conservative media ecosystem.
I fully expect, despite adhering to basic scientific principles, to be downvoted yet again in this thread, because I already see a lot of the same names from the last time this article was posted and politically charged rhetoric (i.e. "leftist agenda").
If Fox News had actually reported the truth all the way through the campaign, they would not have been surprised.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/blog/2012/nov/07/barack-oba...
Even if they were detached from reality, I'd say that was a huge punch in the nuts for the Democrats after re-electing their president to a second term, and holding a super majority for 2 years.
You wanna know why Donald Trump has swept the Republican establishment? Because after all the promises by the Republicans about what they were going to do after being elected, they've done almost nothing they promised and their constituents are pissed and sending a message - time for the establishment to go.
It doesn't matter if Trump wins or not. The message has been sent, and if the "establishment Republicans" don't get it, and get in line, then they might as well hand the Presidency back over to the Clinton political machine.
You seem to be calling holding a majority in the House and Senate a "super majority," that's not what a super majority is. Generally in the U.S. federal government a supermajority requires 2/3rds in the respective body (e.g. a party holding 67 seats in the Senate would have a supermajority there) [0]. Senate rules also make 60 seats a magic number to reach on many votes but one party hasn't held that many seats since 1979.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supermajority#Federal_governme... [1] http://www.senate.gov/history/partydiv.htm
Facebook doesn't target a different population segment or a different political segment of the US, or even the US. It wants everybody to be on Facebook (if they're over the age of 13). That's how it got to $1.65bn users.
It's up to us, the consumer, to vote with our feet. I haven't used Facebook in years and I'm certainly glad not to be using it now that this comes to light as I disagree with it's agenda.
Does anyone have an alternative argument as to why Facebook DOES NOT have the RIGHT to suppress and promote information based on it's own agenda?