News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by at-fates-hands on Thursday May 12, 2016 @10:41AM (#11683721)
This is actually pretty terrifying when you follow this to its logical conclusion.

You're going after license plates, which are regulated by state governments. It's illegal to obfuscate them, so there's no way to conceal your identity like you can with some the CCTV stuff. It's essentially an easy, legal way to keep tabs on your population. As the article pointed out, you can also tie this to all kinds of available data, and start creating profiles for people.

This is really scary, scary stuff.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by peteretep on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:40PM (#11684770)

    > This is really scary, scary stuff
Perhaps. It's been happening for a decade in the UK though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_number_plate_recogni...

    > Vehicle movements on UK roads are recorded by a
    > network of nearly 8000 cameras capturing between 25
    > and 30 million ANPR ‘read’ records daily. These
    > records are stored for up to two years in the 
    > National ANPR Data Centre
Generally no effort is made to disguise it. Police cars have the letters ANPR stamped on them in big letters if they're carrying one.

The profiling you're worried about happening is explicitly touted as an aim of the UK government effort.

The UK approach often appears to be pro-surveillance, and then letting the courts work out what constitutes reasonable usage, a luxury afforded by having such a robust and independent legislature.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by lmkg on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:20AM (#11684020)
I agree that this part is scary, but it isn't news.

I first heard about license-plate readers back in 2008, and at that point police could already take a wired-up squad car for a cruise through a grocery store parking lot, scanning a couple hundred plates. Onboard software would run the numbers for outstanding warrants or lapsed registrations, and alert the officer.

This has already been going on for years. The capacity to mine that data effectively is slightly more recent, but I'm sure the logfiles exist.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by dboreham on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:01PM (#11684372)
I first saw license plate identification by computer in 1982. Just sayin..
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by tyingq on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:39AM (#11684186)
>>It's illegal to obfuscate them, so there's no way to conceal your identity like you can with some the CCTV stuff

You can form an LLC in a state that allows for some amount of anonymity, like New Mexico, and then register the vehicle under the LLC's name.

Edit: Nothing is fully anonymous, of course, so the government can backtrack it, but they probably don't bother unless there's some specific incident.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by nthj on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:23PM (#11684589)
This seems trivial to circumvent by (1) tying into New Mexico's database or (2) cross-sectioning license plates + facial recognition databases the first time you drive through a traffic light; so trivial that the time and expense of the LLC seems moot.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by tyingq on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:28PM (#11684643)
Having worked in somewhat similar spaces in the past, I doubt that (1) would be implemented, at least for the broad gathering/analytics/etc. I strongly suspect resolving company to person name would only happen manually, and only because of some specific request or incident.

As for (2), well, yes...facial recognition is a different problem.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by thrownaway2424 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @10:56AM (#11683834)
Driving has never been anonymous. The license plate is readable from a distance for a reason.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by Bartweiss on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:02AM (#11683872)
Readable, sure. They provided a way to identify the owners of specific cars without stopping them.

But with the advent of digital photography, image recognition, and computerized databases, they do something very different. They make it possible to track everyone passing through a place, and to correlate every sighting of someone to build up a profile of their life.

Sure, surveillance isn't novel. But a sufficient quantitative difference becomes a qualitative difference. Bulk tracking of everyone in a city is something completely new, and there's good reason to be uncomfortable with it.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by thrownaway2424 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:06AM (#11683899)
I don't disagree with your facts but I also don't think they lead to your conclusion. One does not expect privacy in public, by definition.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by pdkl95 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:33AM (#11684141)
Privacy isn't a simple Boolean value; there are degrees of privacy that depend on what's protected, the environment/situation, cultural expectations and awareness, and many other variables. For example, you expect privacy for your body because you wear clothes, even though you "have no expectation of privacy" because you are in public.

When the laws requiring license plates were originally created, there was a certain understanding about how that would impact society. Sure, anybody could see them, but you needed a lot of expensive manpower to track one person for a long time or everybody at any time. The impact of having the data "in public" was inherently limited.

Now that technology has removed that limitation, the consequences of having a license plate in public view have changed. Pretending that this new situation is addressed with the outdated logic we used to define "no pubic expectation of privacy" assumes that the old definitions of privacy are still valid, which is patently incorrect.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by rtkwe on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:33AM (#11684140)
It's the accumulation and correlation of the data that's the problem. At a high enough density you essentially have everyone being followed their entire lives. Formerly if the police wanted to know everywhere that a person visited because they suspected them of crime X they'd have to invest a certain level of resources which means targets had to be chosen judiciously. Now we're approaching a point where they can just trawl everyone's movements looking for anything they like, and as the algorithms get better and the density of things like CCTV and the license plate readers increases it gets easier and easier to follow anyone back in time.

IF the police were filled with perfect angels and laws were all perfectly reasonable and just allowing that might approach being ok. Instead we have a police force made of people who do things like harass whistle blowers who reveal corruption or cover ups or people they have personal vendettas against (or unrequited love toward).

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by baconner on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:32AM (#11684129)
This is clearly true, but legally speaking I think it's time we start reevaluating as a society how far we let this swing. Technology has changed the meaning of no reasonable expectation of privacy dramatically. 100 years ago you couldn't expect not to be overheard or followed (at great cost per individual followed). Today you can't expect not to be recorded and location tracked at all times and it's low cost per person so everyone can be followed and surveiled all the time.

We can disagree if this is a net positive or negative to society, but IMO a lot of folks are treating it as if nothing has changed because the core law hasn't changed. That's missing the point - the scale change is very significant.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by orbitingpluto on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:44AM (#11684225)
One also doesn't expect to look over their shoulder and be constantly stalked. But it's okay because it is the government?
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by JTxt on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:36AM (#11684166)
Said from a throwaway account?

It's likely possible to figure out your identity from what, when, and where you post online publicly... Especially by someone that has the resources to collect and data mine much of what is posted.

Would that be ok?

I don't think so, unless it's part of a legal and targeted investigation.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by thrownaway2424 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:58PM (#11685854)
My throwaway account is as anonymous as yours. I use it because it's been logged in in Chrome for the last five years and I'm lazy. I don't see how "JTxt" differs from "thrownaway2424"
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by Retric on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:04AM (#11683887)
Someone in the 1930's could write down a plate and with a lot of effort transform that into a name. Passively collecting the names of everyone that happens to go past a camera is qualitatively different.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by Aelinsaar on Thursday May 12, 2016 @10:59AM (#11683854)
And walking?
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by throwanem on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:07AM (#11683911)
Unless you walk around wearing a license plate around your neck, I'm not sure how it's relevant here.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by tomtoise on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:11AM (#11683929)
One could argue that you're wearing a license plate 'on' your neck. Facial recognition and that.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by lozf on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:05PM (#11685009)
Don't forget "Gait DNA"[0] for tracking your movement through a crowd, even when your face can't be seen.

[0] http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspon...

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by Aelinsaar on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:17AM (#11683990)
I wear my face above my neck, thanks.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by hackuser on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:02PM (#11684382)
Your phone is probably in your pocket.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by Aelinsaar on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:38PM (#11684749)
I have the choice to leave my phone at home, or take out the battery, or if I'm feeling incredibly paranoid even stick it in a Faraday cage. My face, is my face.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by thrownaway2424 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:03AM (#11683874)
What about it?
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by Aelinsaar on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:18AM (#11683993)
Facial recognition software.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by thrownaway2424 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:57PM (#11685844)
Again I'm not really seeing your point. One goes about in public "openly and notoriously" as the legal jargon goes. It is expected that one's face would be recognized.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by Aelinsaar on Thursday May 12, 2016 @04:48PM (#11686670)
I really can't stand people who use "Not seeing your point" as a substitute for "Disagree with your point."
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by thrownaway2424 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @09:04PM (#11687933)
I'm actually using it as shorthand for "your sentence fragments do not amount to an argument."
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by Aelinsaar on Thursday May 12, 2016 @09:43PM (#11688091)
Trust me, that's not what it's shorthand for.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by kaitai on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:19PM (#11685126)
Not to be at all flip... but it's another good reason to bike instead.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by mc32 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @11:32AM (#11684124)
Compared to what Google/Apple/Facebook know about you? It's not really that scary. Government is accountable, at least in theory. With private services, you're more or less out of luck, if you want to live a normal life surrounded by technology.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by the_ancient on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:02PM (#11684379)
> Government is accountable

that is funny right there....

>With private services, you're more or less out of luck,

In a way, but last I checked google nor facebook are legally empowered to Arrest, Put me in a Cage, Raid my Home at 3am, Shoot my dog, Detonate Explosives in my children face or even Kill Me.

So yes google violates your privacy, to sell you shit, the government violates your privacy to put you in a cage or kill you. I am more concerned with the latter...

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by mc32 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @12:37PM (#11684738)
Is that what the vans are doing though? Are they out there to hunt innocent people so they can kill them? Or are they trying to catch people they are looking for already, except more efficiently?

In other words are they doing what we have in essence ask them to do for us, by and large?

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by the_ancient on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:55PM (#11685828)
Depends on your Definition of "innocent" and crime

Since I do not get my ethics or morality from the government or law I do not view simply breaking one of the millions of laws as criminal, a crime to me has to have a complaining victim, no victim no crime.

Thus the state enforcing the thousands of victim-less crimes, or even crimes "against the state" are immoral, and unethical.

Further I find the governments use of ALPR data to build massive on going databases that are used for government and private uses to be offensive.

It is sad you do not

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by wtetzner on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:10PM (#11685054)
It doesn't matter why they're collecting the information. Once they have it, they have to power to do far worse things with it than Google.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by mc32 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @01:15PM (#11685099)
No, I'd say _why_ is the central question. If it's a corrupt city supervisor spying on foes, that's contrary to their purview, if it's to enforce laws, that is under their duties.

It's like saying, well, we don't care why facebook collects all that information, they may as well sell it all to any bidder.

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by wtetzner on Thursday May 12, 2016 @04:08PM (#11686358)
I think you might be missing my point. Even if they have the best of intentions for collecting the data, once they have it, anyone who has access to it can use it for evil.
Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by the_ancient on Thursday May 12, 2016 @02:52PM (#11685811)
I see you have a much greater trust and respect for government than I

I am a libertarian, I view 99% of government as immoral and unethical

Re:Pennsylvania license plate reader SUV camouflaged as Goog... by mc32 on Thursday May 12, 2016 @03:10PM (#11685943)
I think myself as being skeptical of government, however, I don't think the default for me is "they're bad" rather "let's see what tho is about". It could be for good, it could be bad. Let's look at it. If bad, we can, if we have the will, change it, in many cases.