News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by staticelf on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:15AM (#11674205)
I don't understand why helping people who want to die is illegal in most countries. It's unfathomable why some people are against that. If I become deeply sick when I am of age I will probably also want to decide when I want to die and not die slowly and painfully.

People who are against letting people choose their own death is having a selfish and evil stance, there is no way to excuse that.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by MichaelBurge on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:53AM (#11674386)
Because then your kids could forge a signature on a fake letter to get your inheritance money.

Because then companies that happen to profit from your death have an incentive to convince you that you should die, using manipulative advertising and marketing.

Because then people who are highly depressed might kill themselves with assistance from a doctor, when an alternate route could cure them.

Because then the doctor might forge evidence showing that you wanted to be killed and it could be hard for the police to track down. Maybe they only use the attack against certain high-reward targets.

Because then somebody who is impulsive might agree to be killed when he would've regretted it later if he were still alive.

I tend to be in favor of this for people who legitimately want to die, but there's something to be said for the simplicity of "The autopsy showed poison, so we have a murder case." I could be convinced to make it illegal if somebody found some really plausible attacks that could be used against me; and could be convinced to make it legal if we found and required a scientific test with a legally-enforcable chain-of-custody that proved I was in my right mind when I asked to be killed.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by CaptainZapp on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @08:03AM (#11674435)
Those are all valid points. But oddly enough none of them seems to be a problem in Switzerland, where assisted suicide is legal since the 40s (as mentioned in the article).

On a sidenote: You can write a "Patientenverfügung" (loosely transelated: a patient's will), in which you stipulate that you don't want to be kept alive artificially in case of grave illnes.

This is respected by hospitals and doctors. Case in point was my mother, who had terminal cancer. The doctors gave her morphine to ease the pain and otherwise didn't do anything to prolong her suffering.

She died in a dignified manner.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:18AM (#11674959)
We have "living wills" in the United States and they're the same thing. The controversial issue is active euthanasia, not passive euthanasia. Mostly, anyway.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by bkmartin on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:31PM (#11677310)
But what you describe for your mother is called Hospice here in the US. It is simply a lack of treatment when it is believed that treatment offers more suffering and no better outcome. It is the right of the patient to refuse treatment and enter into hospice care and be kept comfortable until they die. That is not assisted suicide.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by j_s on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:22AM (#11676126)
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by ikeboy on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @10:19AM (#11675483)
>Because then somebody who is impulsive might agree to be killed when he would've regretted it later if he were still alive.

We wouldn't always know in such cases, and there's often no way to know what a dead person would have thought years later if they would have lived.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by lisper on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @12:33PM (#11676781)
That's not quite true. There are people who attempt suicide and survive. Many (though by no means all) express regret afterwards.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by ikeboy on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @12:44PM (#11676889)
That's an excellent point. Obviously we do know sometimes.

But GP's point was that we don't observe bad consequences from the laws in Switzerland, all I'm saying is that it wouldn't show up when someone commits suicide.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by staticelf on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:10AM (#11674915)
You can create legal structures to prevent most stuff like that pretty easily:

* Force everyone who wants assisted death to go through medical discussion alone with physiologists / doctors, require it to be at least 20 sessions or whatever seems enough.

* Only make it available and legal for people with chronic pain or other diseases that make life suck.

* Require several doctors to be present, that don't usually work with eachother or have any other specific connection to eachother.

* Require to let the patient "press" the button that injects the overdose or whatever method is used.

Etc etc. The point is to make the process complicated and to remove any doubt that this person in question didn't want to die. Of course, it isn't completely safe but so is life and that is kind of the point.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:19AM (#11674968)
What do you do about someone with, say, Alzheimer's, who may want to end their life precisely because they are beginning to drift in and out of lucidity? Maybe Switzerland has it all figured out but it is not that easy.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by lmkg on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:39PM (#11677427)
One potential solution is ahead-of-time decision making.

When young and lucid, make the decision of what criteria would cause you to prefer physician-assisted suicide. Write that down in a document. Allow that document to have legal force.

In the US, we already have the notion of Advanced Health Care Directives, which allow for things like power of attorney, nominating a proxy decision-maker, and criteria were a caretaker is allowed, or even required, to stop providing life-extending treatment. Health care providers generally follow these directives if made aware of them.

Thinking about this sort of thing ahead of time is not something that people want to do. But, for people who do complete one (with sufficiently-rigorous criteria), it solves some of the ethical issues around consent and incapacity.

By the way, I strongly recommend more people complete an AHCD. I had to care for a close relative at the end of her life, and the fact that her wishes were written down on paper was an incomparable gift to me. This should really become more routine.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by staticelf on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @10:18AM (#11675478)
Go through the process and let death take you. It's better to help some people than to help no one at all. I don't have the perfect protocol of such a process, I am just writing an example to prove that my original point is valid.

I think people that have Alzheimer's and want to die should be able to be assisted.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @10:24AM (#11675531)
OK, but you are sidestepping the issue here. As you've said, if you accept active euthanasia you'd probably consider the deterioration of Alzheimer's an acceptable reason. And most people take informed and uncoerced consent as important to the process. And yet how do you ensure that consent with someone who is losing their mental faculties?
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @12:08PM (#11676574)
As someone with experience of a relative with Alzheimer's, it's completely clear in every possible way that informed consent is no longer an option.

Alzheimer's creates a mental handicap that makes normal adult functioning impossible. You can literally ask the same question twice in two minutes and get two conflicting answers - with no memory of the previous answer, or even that the question was asked before.

In mid-stage Alzheimer's memory is so impaired that it's literally shorter than a spoken sentence. In late Alzheimer's even that disappears.

The solution in the UK is to hand over care decisions by Power of Attorney. If no relative is available for that, decisions are handed over to care and medical staff.

If assisted death is ever an option in the UK, it would have to be written into a living will while informed consent was still possible.

Obviously there are huge legal issues with that, especially if there's an inheritance involved.

That aside, people really do get to the point where they just want to die.

I've seen it twice now. In one case it was very clear indeed, and had been clear for at least a couple of years. In another it was less clear, but it was something my relative talked about openly.

Personally, having seen cancer and Alzheimer's close up, I'm really not convinced I'd want to wait around for a natural death from either.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:02PM (#11677053)
I am sympathetic to that view; I am just really troubled by the idea of people pressuring relatives into euthanasia.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by dumbmatter on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:09AM (#11676010)
Encourage people to plan ahead, in the same way that you should have a living will and other legal documents in place before you actually need them.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:25AM (#11676143)
I think most people would have a hard time accepting active euthanasia one the basis of documents prepared in the past, particularly when you consider the significant possibility of duress, forgery, etc.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by dumbmatter on Monday May 16, 2016 @02:36PM (#11708501)
Forgery - require a notarized document, a video, etc. Tons of documentation, why not.

Duress - could apply equally to euthanasia today too, couldn't it? If not, then take whatever magical anti-duress method we use now and apply it to this.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by sliverstorm on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:46PM (#11677518)
Alzheimer's patients are still lucid, right? Just can't access all their memories?
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @02:28PM (#11677879)
No. Alzheimer's is a form of dementia. Here is the description of "moderate" symptoms from Wikipedia:

> Behavioural and neuropsychiatric changes become more prevalent. Common manifestations are wandering, irritability and labile affect, leading to crying, outbursts of unpremeditated aggression, or resistance to caregiving.[26] Sundowning can also appear.[31] Approximately 30% of people with AD develop illusionary misidentifications and other delusional symptoms.[26] Subjects also lose insight of their disease process and limitations (anosognosia).[26] Urinary incontinence can develop.[26] These symptoms create stress for relatives and carers, which can be reduced by moving the person from home care to other long-term care facilities.[26][32]

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by sliverstorm on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:45PM (#11677503)
The first one is hard to fix, actually. Family can be really shitty to you, to the point you feel useless and unwanted and really want to be gone. People do that to their parents today, and elderly commit suicide for that reason today!

Clinically available assisted suicide could further embolden people to be really terrible to their elderly parents, and private screening with a doctor doesn't fix this.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by scottkduncan on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:52AM (#11676414)
Per your second point, there is certainly a strong profit motive for keeping terminally-ill patients alive longer than they otherwise might want on the part of health-care providers. End-of-life care costs are no joke.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by zadig on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @12:44PM (#11676888)
While it is true that end-of-life care costs are indeed out of control, to say that there is a "strong profit motive" for keeping terminally-ill patients alive seems to me a very, very cynical view.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by shasta on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:10AM (#11674912)
Simpler still: "the autopsy showed poison, so put the spouse in prison."
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by sokoloff on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:18AM (#11674217)
One concern is, what if the person doesn't really want to die but the "care"givers want their ordeal to be over, or want to collect an inheritance, or collect an inheritance before it's all gobbled up by end-of-life care?

In genuine cases of wanting out, I support it, but I'm not sure how to design the right controls around it to be fully comfortable with it.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by rev_bird on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @10:26AM (#11675554)
I'm from the U.S., and I'm guessing you are too -- I wonder, in Europe, if "end-of-life" care bankrupts old people like it does here.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by notlisted on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:05AM (#11675976)
It won't. Socialized medicine works.

Note: It probably doesn't just bankrupt old people here… I've seen whole families affected by last-ditch efforts to squeeze out a few more months. Second mortgages. College funds. It's horrifying. (live in US, from Europe)

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by naringas on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:20AM (#11674232)
I think it's related to christian morality. They belive something along the lines of "God gave you your life and only Him can decide when it should end"
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by Luc on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:30AM (#11674278)
This is getting downvoted, but at least in Belgium it is mainly Christian organisations that opposed, and continue to oppose, the euthanasia laws.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by cmdrfred on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:29AM (#11674273)
Pro-life.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by masklinn on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:32AM (#11674289)
Anti-choice.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by jacquesm on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:46AM (#11674348)
It's mostly a vestige of religion. Life is considered sacred and it is not supposed to be your own choice whether you want to live or die but up to god in some form or other.

This then became enshrined in law as well as in medical practice (though in medicine there has long been a recognition that not all life extending medical practice is compatible with medical ethics doctors are still bound by the laws of the land and in plenty of cases doctors that assisted with suicide have been charged with murder).

Quite a few countries have now moved to the point where in the case of grave illness or pain you have the ability to request an end to your life.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_euthanasia

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by lambdaphagy on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:53AM (#11674385)
There are plenty of fathomable reasons why some people are against that, just as there are plenty of fathomable reasons why others are for it. Anyone who professes not to understand half of a debate might reconsider their confidence on the issue.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @12:20PM (#11676680)
Libertarian here, so I'm comfortable with people owning their own bodies and being solely responsible for what they do with it.

Having said that, I'd like to make the case for keeping it illegal because I believe there's a strong case to be made. Killing yourself should be a unique, extraordinary event in both your life and the lives of those around you. We should never make a system out of killing people, because systems can be gamed.

In a way, this is much the same discussion as the old "would you torture a terrorist to determine where a nuclear bomb was waiting to go off?"

Yes. Yes I would. I would consider such an act to be horribly immoral, and I might regret it to the day I die, but yes, I would. Likewise I'd take my own life or help people I love take theirs -- but I would worry over whether I did the right thing or not. If I were a religious person, I might consider my act immoral. But I'd still do it.

Once you create a system out of killing people -- people go in one side, forms get filled out, and dead people come out the other -- you've taken a step towards the state arbitrarily deciding who lives or dies based on its own system of value and not the individual's. So in a way, you give up much more in this fashion than if you simply outlawed it and never prosecuted. (Which is probably what happens 90% of the time in countries where assisted suicide is illegal.)

So yeah, I'd torture the terrorist. But I'd raise holy hell for any system of government where torture was a accepted way of doing things. Good grief, can you imagine what just a little tweaking would do to a system like that?

Speeding is illegal. If you want to speed on the way to the hospital because somebody you love is in danger? Speed. By all means, speed. I'll be the first person to protest any law enforcement person that tries to stop you.

But speeding should probably still be illegal for systemic reasons not related at all to your loved one being ill.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by the_ancient on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @12:59PM (#11677028)
Libertarian Here...

I challenge how you square your belief with libertarianism

If you say it illegal for a person to commit suicide you are staking a claim to their life, you are saying you own them

That is about as far from libertarianism as you can get

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:18PM (#11677193)
My stance is that I have that right. So do others.

I made an argument that from a systemic standpoint, it's better to make illegal and never prosecute than it is to create a governmental machine around it.

Please understand, I'm perfectly happy with it being legal. I'm simply trying to describe why there's a strong case for it remaining illegal (and un-prosecuted)

You realize that we're not talking about people freely deciding what to do with themselves, right? What we're talking about is a bunch of new laws, committees, and processes where a person's life can be terminated, sometimes directly by the state. I'd think this is a much worse situation than simply having officials look the other way.

If we were talking about removing all laws around what folks do with their lives, that'd be a different thing entirely. That's where we should be. But nobody is talking about that.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by yourturn on Thursday May 12, 2016 @04:21AM (#11682081)
Funny how those who talk this sort of high and mighty talk rarely walk the walk.

Selective enforcement of laws is evil, unreliable and stupid - it's counter to the very reason we have laws.

I want it to be legal to end one's own life because the consequences of that choice are hard enough on one's family and loved ones. It need not be made harder.

What sort of choice do you want your family to face when it's your turn? Do you really want their hands tied by the risk of imprisonment when your time comes?

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by antisthenes on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:38PM (#11677413)
There's a certain irony that is lost on you when you advocate for torture but are against someone preventing their own suffering.

But then again, you being a libertarian, are probably not aware of such intricacies.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by danieltillett on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @07:31AM (#11674284)
There is only one rational reason and that is to discourage the impulsive. Suicide is not something to be entered into lightly.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by dominotw on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:41PM (#11677446)
I recently saw an NPR debate about this

Intelligence Squared Debate: Euthanasia Should be Legalised https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ge7dlzMCbos

They talk about examples from patients in states where its already legal (under some circumstances).

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by frogpelt on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @08:58AM (#11674827)
You may find this amazing, but not everyone shares your world view.

No one wants to suffer. And no one wants to see other people suffer. But the truth is suffering is a part of life.

Some people I know and love have suffered their last few years of life. And other people I know and love have taken their own lives. My personal experience is that the individuals who allowed death to come on its terms, instead of rushing to that conclusion, left everyone around them with more strength, peace, happiness, and personal growth.

The people who ended their life because they didn't want to suffer anymore left a wake of suffering and trouble around them when they went.

It's unfathomable why you wouldn't see the difference.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by staticelf on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:17AM (#11674950)
I don't find that amazing, because I knew it already.

As I wrote in my original post: > People who are against letting people choose their own death is having a selfish and evil stance, there is no way to excuse that.

I understand that people oppose such freedoms, but I find it to be selfish and evil. Just look what you wrote: > left everyone around them with more strength, peace, happiness, and personal growth.

That is only proof of my original statement.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by frogpelt on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:44PM (#11677481)
Your stance is just as selfish and just as evil to many others.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by Retric on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @09:10AM (#11674910)
Not everyone suffers to the same extent or has family and close friends at the end. The goal should be a life worth living not a continuation of cellular activity.

It's a failure of empathy to equate emotional pain that was going to happen anyway with the kind of pain drugs can't deal with. I really can't equate your stance to anything but sadism on a massive scale. Suffer, so I can avoid feeling bad for a little while and pretend the end is not so bad.