News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @10:24AM (#11675531)
OK, but you are sidestepping the issue here. As you've said, if you accept active euthanasia you'd probably consider the deterioration of Alzheimer's an acceptable reason. And most people take informed and uncoerced consent as important to the process. And yet how do you ensure that consent with someone who is losing their mental faculties?
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @12:08PM (#11676574)
As someone with experience of a relative with Alzheimer's, it's completely clear in every possible way that informed consent is no longer an option.

Alzheimer's creates a mental handicap that makes normal adult functioning impossible. You can literally ask the same question twice in two minutes and get two conflicting answers - with no memory of the previous answer, or even that the question was asked before.

In mid-stage Alzheimer's memory is so impaired that it's literally shorter than a spoken sentence. In late Alzheimer's even that disappears.

The solution in the UK is to hand over care decisions by Power of Attorney. If no relative is available for that, decisions are handed over to care and medical staff.

If assisted death is ever an option in the UK, it would have to be written into a living will while informed consent was still possible.

Obviously there are huge legal issues with that, especially if there's an inheritance involved.

That aside, people really do get to the point where they just want to die.

I've seen it twice now. In one case it was very clear indeed, and had been clear for at least a couple of years. In another it was less clear, but it was something my relative talked about openly.

Personally, having seen cancer and Alzheimer's close up, I'm really not convinced I'd want to wait around for a natural death from either.

Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @01:02PM (#11677053)
I am sympathetic to that view; I am just really troubled by the idea of people pressuring relatives into euthanasia.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by dumbmatter on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:09AM (#11676010)
Encourage people to plan ahead, in the same way that you should have a living will and other legal documents in place before you actually need them.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by emodendroket on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @11:25AM (#11676143)
I think most people would have a hard time accepting active euthanasia one the basis of documents prepared in the past, particularly when you consider the significant possibility of duress, forgery, etc.
Re:On Mother's Day, My Mom Asked Me to Help End Her Life by dumbmatter on Monday May 16, 2016 @02:36PM (#11708501)
Forgery - require a notarized document, a video, etc. Tons of documentation, why not.

Duress - could apply equally to euthanasia today too, couldn't it? If not, then take whatever magical anti-duress method we use now and apply it to this.