News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by labster on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:09AM (#11665259)
for there is no art in what they do.

I couldn't disagree more. There is common trolling and there is sublime trolling. The ability to sow the perfect amount of strife to create real change is a thing of beauty. This goes beyond the tactics of information warfare -- for which trolling has its uses -- and reveals truth to those in ignorance. For most true knowledge cannot be learned by the advice of elders alone, but must be learned through the long and winding path. Many of life's truths are best revealed through fiction.

This essay reads like it fears trolls and their threats to social order. But the way of discord and strife is also true. Did Eris not troll Olympus most excellently with her golden apple? Did she not reveal that divine folly was no less than mortal folly? This is the awesome power that is trolling in a skilled hand.

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by hguant on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @01:55AM (#11665394)
Your comment relies on a misunderstanding of what Aristotle - or his proxie here - means by the term "art". In modern usage, something that has no art to it is base, simple, and requires no effort to achieve. However, art meant something more nuanced to Aristotle (that nuance is why people still make a living arguing over the implications of what he said). For Aristotle, an art was something that pointed to the Good. Politics was the art of governing men, Ethics was the art of ruling oneself. These things involved skill - the skill you allude to the troll possessing, the power to weave webs of words and manipulate people - but also involved something more - an understanding that the purpose of the art was to further a good in some way. When "Aristotle" says there's not art in the troll's activities, he means they do not point to the good, and they will in fact do harm.

PS apologies if this isn't well reasoned, I just got off a plane and am a bit jet lagged.

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by sspiff on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @03:36AM (#11665702)
Regardless of what definition of "art" you follow, I feel like trolling as described by labster can certainly be used for good.

Labster himself describes the use of trolling in tricking the reluctant apprentice into learning, or using it to sow strife to further policy making and bring about social change. "Good" is in the eye of the beholder, but I could certainly consider some of those things to be good some of the time.

There is a difference in abusing other people online for entertainment - "common trolling" as labster describes it - and the "sublime trolling" in which he sees art.

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by a3n on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:52AM (#11667103)
> Regardless of what definition of "art" you follow, I feel like trolling as described by labster can certainly be used for good.

Or at least for effect.

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by zevkirsh on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:20PM (#11671997)
EXAMPLE; BANKSY.

IF THERE IS NO ART IN BANKSY, THEN WHY DO PEOPLE PAY MILLIONS FOR HIS ART? HAHAHAHAHAH..........

metatrolling in this comment by dual useage of the word 'art' fully intended.

but what banksy does seriously is not easy. and if you don't believe me, please watch 'exit through the gift shop', a truly sublime documentary, itself fake , but SO TRUE, totally worth watching twice.

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by dang on Wednesday May 11, 2016 @10:03PM (#11680846)
Please don't use all caps in comments here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by blub on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @03:53AM (#11665751)
The only problem is that "sublime trolling" is something he made up. Tricking apprentices to learn, come on.

He's just playing devil's advocate in a not very convincing way.

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by iopq on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @04:59AM (#11665936)
http://thecodelesscode.com/

almost all of these koans are masters trolling students

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by Karunamon on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @11:25AM (#11667872)
Hah! This was my first thought too. The whole purpose of a koan is to, one way or another, subvert (i.e. troll) your normal thought process so some important truth can be learned.
Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by sspiff on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @04:21AM (#11665841)
From the essay:

> but what trolling is, and how many its species are, and whether there is an excellence of the troll, is unclear.

I happen to agree with Labster's point that trolling, in rare but excellent cases, can be a thing of art, and can be used with purpose.

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by Kurtz79 on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @09:00AM (#11666825)
In general, "art" had a different meaning in past times compared to today.

It was the subject of this very interesting excerpt by Knuth, recently posted by pg.

http://www.paulgraham.com/knuth.html

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by feedjoelpie on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:32AM (#11667435)
Would you consider, as I would, the Yes Men's activities as both trolling and more or less good? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LiWlvBro9eI
Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by igravious on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @02:13AM (#11665442)
Rest assured, the jet lag appears not to have blunted the art of your reasoning ;)
Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by akavel on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @04:01AM (#11665784)
As to the quote, you've either misread, or are actually amusingly trolling yourself ;) Given that the whole sentence that the quote comes from actually explains how to detect non-trolls:

"And none of these is the troll, or perhaps some are of a mixed type; for there is no art in what they do."

and as a follow-up, close to the end the essay says:

"And since the one [a troll] who does this on every occasion must act with knowledge, and on the basis of practice and care, he has a kind of art"

With that out of the way, the gist of your comment is totally very interesting and thought provoking, thanks!

edit: or did I just perfectly fall for the troll here? :) still not really sure...

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by flurpitude on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @10:33AM (#11667439)
Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by tremon on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @05:31AM (#11666027)
The ability to sow the perfect amount of strife to create real change is a thing of beauty

But if the goal is to effect change, then it is (arguably) not a troll:

And the community has some good in common, and this the troll must know, and what things promote and destroy it: for he seeks to destroy

Re:Aristotle, “On Trolling” by carapace on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @02:09PM (#11669254)
"Science does not remove the terror of the gods"