News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by ams6110 on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:32PM (#11662908)
A certain well-known electric car maker (maybe all of them, though) can push software updates to systems that have lives in their control not to mention costly machines. A sobering reminder of the need for very careful testing and control over this sort of thing.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by marssaxman on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:07PM (#11663612)
If the programmers of a multimillion dollar satellite can't guarantee that their patches won't break anything, I'm sure as hell not willing to risk my life on the possibility that an automaker's programmers can. No remote updates for me; if it is my car then it is my car, and I will decide if, when, and how I will upgrade it. If a carmaker won't accept that, I won't drive their car.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by danielrhodes on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:17PM (#11664035)
It stands to reason it will eventually happen, but compared to a satellite there is a much lower liklihood that as an individual you will experience harm because of such an update.

Some mitigating factors:

- they can do slow releases. So if a serious anomaly does occur it is unlikely to be with your car.

- the conditons of space make errors much more catosptrophic. Although I can imagine similarly catosptrophic scenarios with a car, there are also more opportunities to safely rectify the situation (like the car pulling over and refusing to drive if things are not ok). In space, the satellite cannot just stop and wait for a tow truck to arrive.

- there is only one satellite to test the update on. If they screw it up, it's gone. With cars, there are many to test on, so errors will turn up and be fixed faster.

But back to the issue of risk:

Just like with drunk driving, you are at risk of somebody else's car going haywire as well, so it's a risk regardless of whether you yourself updated or not. At that point, the difference between your existing risk and the risk you take on from the update is probably not that great, so might as well just do the update.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by marssaxman on Monday May 09, 2016 @09:21PM (#11664609)
It's the loss of control that bugs me. When I buy a car I am not buying an ongoing relationship with the car's maker; I'm buying a physical object, which is then mine, and I'll choose when and how it will be serviced. The over-the-air auto-update thing is as though... well, it's like some mechanic from the automaker shows up at your house unannounced a year after you took your car off the lot; without a word, they haul your car away on a trailer for an hour, then bring it back and park it. Ta-da, hope you like what we did to "your" car, because it's done now whether you wanted it or not!
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by danielrhodes on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @07:51AM (#11666539)
When that car is a computer on wheels, you kind of do want that relationship. I imagine an open source car will one day be a thing, but like the personal computer, it's going to be a niche market.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by marssaxman on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @12:16PM (#11668296)
Well, perhaps, but I'd rather just... not have a car that is a computer on wheels!
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by Tycho on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:58PM (#11663917)
You know this could give the FOSS movement a new lease of life. Realistically only nerds care about whether they can install/configure exactly what they want on their computer hardware, but when it comes to safety things like this many more people are going to care deeply.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by rconti on Monday May 09, 2016 @08:19PM (#11664339)
2016 is the year of Linux on the dashboard!
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by hyperbovine on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:55PM (#11663899)
Is it possible that satellites are more complex than cars?
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by IMTDb on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:18PM (#11664037)
Or that car maker actually have the ability to test their software in real-life situation before pushing the update to the intended client
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by ganeshkrishnan on Monday May 09, 2016 @09:16PM (#11664591)
If it's a self driven car then an controlled environment with hundreds of cars with new patch will test for couple of weeks before the patch is released. Chances are mitigated and the cars can be observed physically unlike satellites.

Also every technological advancement we are reducing fatality. We are not bringing it to complete zero but we are definitely reducing it.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by mathattack on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:24PM (#11664079)
There's also many more cars to test software on.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by mathattack on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:26PM (#11664091)
By this logic - you wouldn't want to drive any car since no satellite programmer could guarantee no bugs in their initial software either.

I think it's a tradeoff. If self-driving cars can save tens of thousands of lives in the US every year, how many should we be willing to risk to enable this?

Eventually your insurance company may force this on you due to higher premiums, or government may make injuring someone in a manual car accident a crime like assault.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by marssaxman on Monday May 09, 2016 @09:18PM (#11664597)
Perhaps. I'll worry about such things after self-driving cars actually exist. Right now they are an engineer's fantasy, or a salesperson's exaggerated way of describing semi-automatic assistance features; who knows what the reality will eventually be.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by nsgi on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:35AM (#11666193)
It's not only self-driving cars that use software.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by marssaxman on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @03:59PM (#11670157)
Self-driving cars only exist as research prototypes. They are as speculative as flying cars.

Tesla is the only offender I know about when it comes to real cars that actually exist and have obnoxious over-the-air update systems, because normal car companies are constrained by their contracts with dealer networks, so any software updates they might want to push on us would have to be done through the normal vehicle service program. This can easily be avoided by choosing a different mechanic. One can't very well choose a different mechanic if you are stuck a Tesla-like system that pushes diffs at you via radio, and that's what concerns me.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by elevensies on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:36PM (#11664151)
I think they already have the ability to push upgrades during routine service, so the only difference here is the frequency. I don't know what their testing regimes look like, but it may not even be different.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by mmaunder on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:02PM (#11663183)
Which certainly makes vulnerabilities more interesting.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by askafriend on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:21PM (#11663329)
"Oh you discovered a life threatening vulnerability that affects every car in the deployed fleet of electric vehicles?

Thanks, here's $5k for your hard work as part of our bounty program."

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by beeboop on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:41PM (#11663452)
I know this is a joke, but I am unsure if you're pointing it directly at Tesla. To clarify, Tesla does not have a bug bounty program that I was able to find for their car software.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by askafriend on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:59PM (#11663552)
Haha no, I was just poking fun at high profile bug bounty programs like Facebook/Google's which routinely offer pennies for very very serious vulnerabilities.

I'm not in a position to discuss bug bounty ethics or judge what the right thing to do is given the market circumstances, I'm only in a position to make an opportune joke.

But you gotta admit...it is amusing seeing very critical vulnerabilities like ubiquitous user login being reported by researchers whom get 5k or 10k for doing the right thing. These holes could instantly cripple the trust of a company's userbase and yet the people reporting them get pennies.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by bpchaps on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:35PM (#11663776)
Yeah, I can attest to that. Found a github page with ssh keys, home directories, infrastructure scripts, configs, etc for Comcast that could've been used to do just about anything within their infrastructure. I raised the issue as ethically as I could, particularly since someone with an "infosec background" already forked it a bit before I found it. The engineers who I got in contact with were hugely appreciative, got the issue fixed almost immediately (seriously, kudos again), and brought up the possibility of starting a bug bounty program with me as a pilot of sorts. Cool, right?

Well, after talking to their CISO, it sounds like no such thing will happen. Her reason was, "It's not actually a 'bug', so it's not going to be included in a bug bounty program". So there goes that idea.

I really don't get it. I could have just as easily sold everything in there for big monies, or could have personally done havoc of my own. There's a certain point where "thanks" just doesn't feel enough, especially after the bug bounty comment.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by melvinmt on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:39PM (#11663802)
Look at it this way, you could also have been "rewarded" with a 30-year jail sentence. Please don't mess with big corps.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by bpchaps on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:07PM (#11663973)
Your attitude is so amazingly fear based - fuck that sauce.

What makes you think I'm actually messing with big corps? I'm not. I disclosed the issue properly and safely. I have a good lawyer who would step in to help if something bad happened. But hell, if something bad did happen, where I can't get out of a sentence like that, then fine. It is what it is.

But letting that fear of 30 years of prison prevent me from disclosing something that could have long term effects for millions? Fuck. That.

I wasn't even doing any of this for money. I found it, I wanted to correct it. That's it. But for their CISO to drop a giant deuce on me like that without as much as a "Thank you" from her? Heh. It's a little annoying.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by melvinmt on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:35PM (#11664146)
Have you ever heard of a thing called the "Computer Fraud and Abuse Act"? Even the act of disclosing a vulnerability to the company itself can be misconstrued by paranoid big corps as a "security breach", hence the possibility of a 30 years sentence. I'm just saying it's not worth the risk. At least not in the US.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by bpchaps on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:43PM (#11664188)
I'm well aware of what the risks are. It was something from github, so it's not like I was doing anything crazy, anyway. During my disclosure, I told them the kinds of port scans I did, and the types of individuals I shared the information to. As full disclosure as I possibly could have been.

I'd rather not fall into this trap: https://theintercept.com/2016/04/28/new-study-shows-mass-sur...

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by lawnchair_larry on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @04:24AM (#11665848)
That isn't possible under the CFAA.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by sangnoir on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @02:14AM (#11665446)
> Your attitude is so amazingly fear based - fuck that sauce.

I really think this part:

> > I really don't get it. I could have just as easily sold everything in there for big monies, or could have personally done havoc of my own.

would have earned you a prison sentence (if caught). The most obvious ways to 'profit' from security bugs for corps with no bug bounties are illegal.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by bpchaps on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @02:30PM (#11669418)
Right. I'm just sharing my experience at this point, though. Can't get caught if I'm not doing anything to get caught. And again, I went through the proper, ethical channels to get this raised.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by TeMPOraL on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:42PM (#11663822)
If bpchaps would mess with Comcast directly then maybe; if he sold the knowledge somewhere else than not really. I don't recall hearing of any case where a hack was traced all the way back to the third party that found and sold the vulnerability.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by 67726e on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:48PM (#11663852)
Well considering it's Comcast, I'd be more then happy to "accidentally" disclose those vulnerabilities.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by TeMPOraL on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:48PM (#11663858)
Yeah, it's one of those companies that are really asking for it. In some cases it's hard to do the ethical thing :).
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by bpchaps on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:19PM (#11664048)
The thought crossed my mind. ;)

But being able to say "$GOODTHING happened because of me" felt so much better. It just means in the end that 50% of my meals are lentil based :P.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by ars on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:44PM (#11663830)
But small corps are OK?
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by lobotryas on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:32PM (#11663753)
I'm not seeing what point you are trying to make.

What other option do these researchers have? Try to sell the vuln on the black market (illegal) or to a state actor (unethical and likely illegal)? Keep quiet about what they found and not get any money/recognition?

Companies are under no obligation to pay and researchers are under no obligation (except ethics, I guess) to turn over their findings. By having some non-trivial payment the companies are encouraging people to provide cheap sec audits for them.

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by TeMPOraL on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:40PM (#11663804)
> What other option do these researchers have? Try to sell the vuln on the black market (illegal)

That's probably what GP is alluding to. They do have this option and I can imagine they could get much more money this way, with little or no way to trace the source of a 0day back to them.

> Companies are under no obligation to pay and researchers are under no obligation (except ethics, I guess) to turn over their findings. By having some non-trivial payment the companies are encouraging people to provide cheap sec audits for them.

Well, of course. The question is, whether the amount companies chose to pay is enough to get most people to report vulnerabilities instead of selling them elsewhere, or if those companies are just putting a lot of trust in the strong morals of security researchers?

Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by hrehhf on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:17PM (#11664030)
Is it actually illegal to sell information that a particular bug exists and can be exploited? What if it is sold to the company which owns the software? What if it is sold to one's own government?
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by sigmar on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:38PM (#11663797)
Well it is "pennies" + public recognition. I am also of the opinion that small bounties are much better than no bounty (cough apple cough)
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by Titanous on Monday May 09, 2016 @07:04PM (#11663955)
Tesla does have a bug bounty program: https://bugcrowd.com/tesla
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by beeboop on Monday May 09, 2016 @08:55PM (#11664513)
I specified they didn't have one for their car software, but I missed the part of that webpage that does actually list "vehicle" as a potential target. I was thrown off by the "This program is focused on Tesla's public facing web application" statement. So you're correct.
Re:Software Update Destroys $286M Japanese Satellite by sqeaky on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:41PM (#11663817)
From the article:

> High energy particles may have disrupted the onboard electronics.

If this is a problem Humanity has a bigger problem.

Humor aside I agree defects in devices that can rapidly become two ton death machines must be taken seriously. There must be safe guards at every level.