News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by 11thEarlOfMar on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:04AM (#11660322)
Lending Club is building a two-sided marketplace, which is always hard. I've been lending on the platform for almost 3 years now. It was always difficult for me to find loans that met my criteria. Borrowers have 14 days to get their loans funded by lenders and loans were typically funded by lenders within 1 day. So lenders were outnumbering borrowers.

Starting in January this year, however, loans started taking longer and longer to fund. Recently, I've seen them timing out. This means that in the marketplace, the balance shifted and borrowers outnumbered lenders. Another indication that Lending Club was experiencing a shortage of lenders: they began offering bonuses up to $2,000 for new accounts.

Finally, this earnings release indicates that loan originations, while still growing, has slowed considerably. That is the formal evidence confirming a significant slowdown in new lenders.

I suspect that there was a lot of pressure internally for sales personnel to bring in new capital through either retail of commercial lenders (they've served both markets for quite a while), and, someone or some group got too aggressive. Whether LaPlanche knew and ok'd the deal, or whether he was just 'person in charge' and has to take the fall, I don't know. But this will be a major wound. It's really sad that it is self-inflicted.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by pc86 on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:50AM (#11660719)
I refinanced two credit cards for what I thought was a large amount ($9k + I included the LC fees) and I was honestly skeptical that it would even get funded.

It was funded by a single investor in less than two hours.

I've often thought about investing in the platform but I've always been skeptical of the ability to make consistent returns on it - it seems like a platform where unless you have significant capital invested, one or two defaults above what you expect and you could be wiped out.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by 11thEarlOfMar on Monday May 09, 2016 @12:06PM (#11660857)
It is important to lend to many borrowers. Lending Club recommends at least 100. That normalizes the risk. My returns have been consistently 9.5-10.5%, net of defaults.

I started with an experiment: $2,500 loaned $25 at a time to 100 borrowers. Lending Club forecasts the default rate based on their own credit rating. It went well and the actual return was about 1% higher than they forecast.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by heliodor on Monday May 09, 2016 @03:22PM (#11662405)
I was lending on LendingClub back in 2008 and 2009, diversified among at least twenty or thirty loans. Result: -7% (default included). It's not all roses when the market is in a downturn.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by hkmurakami on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:57PM (#11663537)
Interesting. I don't know your exact timeframe, but that still beat the public stock market.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by maxdemarzi on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:58PM (#11663149)
That "normalizes" the risk, but the real world risk is not gaussian. A .com bubble, 9/11, housing crisis, type of event will wipe you out... Seems like every decade we get a one in a million type of event...
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by 11thEarlOfMar on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:11PM (#11663638)
A housing crisis type of event would increase the default rate substantially, but not to 100%. I'd expect that rather than a +10% return, I might see -10% to -20% return during the event. Many stocks dropped 40% - 60% during the crisis, so for my money, stocks are far riskier.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by shostack on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:37PM (#11661584)
How savvy with lending would you say one needs to be to see those sorts of returns with relatively controlled risk? Is Lending Club for Joe Investor?
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by 11thEarlOfMar on Monday May 09, 2016 @02:07PM (#11661836)
They have an option to automate the lending, so it is possible to get good returns as s novice. The automated feature spreads the dollars over many loans.

However, this is really new as a way for retail investors to earn a return, so they really should get comfortable with its structure before putting money in.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by shostack on Monday May 09, 2016 @02:22PM (#11661944)
In your opinion what are the considerations of this vs. say, a Vanguard bond fund?
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by Infernal on Monday May 09, 2016 @02:30PM (#11662000)
You say 9.5-10.5% net of defaults - have the non-defaulted loans all been repaid in full, and if not what portion of them are still outstanding?
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by briffle on Monday May 09, 2016 @12:25PM (#11661004)
I am literally doing the same thing right now, with my tax returns.. Anxious for the end of this month, when the first payments are due..
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by CodeCube on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:41PM (#11662985)
Take my advice ... forget about it for a while, and check back in in a few months :) Generally speaking, first payments tend to come in ... it's not until later that lates and defaults happen ;)
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by Twirrim on Monday May 09, 2016 @12:57PM (#11661278)
>Anxious for the end of this month, when the first payments are due..

Anxious because you need the money, or just anxious because you don't know how it's going to go?

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by exclusiv on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:43PM (#11661636)
You should check out municipal bonds in your state. I'm in Cali and they do monthly dividends which are tax free. The dividends are ~5% annualized (examples: MUC/MYC/NVX). I've been up 8-10% in value too on each as I buy quality ones at a discount to net asset value.

You can buy and sell like a stock. Much less risky than LC and alternatives and almost 100% tax free if you buy muni bond funds from your state. Plus you can get out when you want and lock up any gains outside of dividends.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by wtvanhest on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:26PM (#11662857)
This advice completely misses the biggest risk with Muni Bonds - Interest rate risk

Investopedia has a somewhat hard, but accurate depiction of this risk.

http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/05/ltbondrisk.asp

In general, you should not be investing in Muni Bonds unless you clearly understand how much value the bond will gain or lose with changes in interest rates.

> I've been up 8-10% in value too on each as I buy quality ones at a discount to net asset value.

This could be partially correct, but it is more likely that the OP just doesn't understand what percent of change in bond value came from his/her ability to pick bonds and what change in bond value came from other factors like interest rate risk.

Investing is really hard and deceptively complex. The best advice is to diversify and index whenever possible. Buying some muni bonds as part of your portfolio should be fine, but they should be balanced with equity exposure, corp bond exposure etc. In every case, try to index to gain more diversification with less fees.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by exclusiv on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:45PM (#11663834)
Good points but the same can be said about the stock market. How can you ascertain what news, speculation or any other factor will do (or did) to an equity at any given time?

Nobody knows interest rate trajectory. The value doesn't drop as much as you would think. If interest rates rise and the bond price drops, the yield increases and you or others will buy more. There aren't a lot of safe options right now and people are nervous with the election and the market.

I agree on doing bond funds and diversification. I put a good chunk in muni bonds and cash. I max out a 401k but that's it for the market because I think it's highly overvalued and I don't like putting most of my money where I have no control. The rest goes into my own companies and real estate.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by wtvanhest on Monday May 09, 2016 @10:50PM (#11664866)
> Good points but the same can be said about the stock market. How can you ascertain what news, speculation or any other factor will do (or did) to an equity at any given time?

I would use this logic to also argue against investing in individual stocks.

> Nobody knows interest rate trajectory.

Agreed

> The value doesn't drop as much as you would think.

If the interest rate the market is willing to pay for a particular muni bond rises, that bond will be worth less and that difference is extremely easy to calculate.

> If interest rates rise and the bond price drops, the yield increases and you or others will buy more.

The fact that rate is rising means that investors are not giving as high of a value. The better way to think about this is that investors decide the Muni bond and other fixed income assets are worth less so they pay less so the yield rises. It is kind of opposite of how you are thinking about it.

> There aren't a lot of safe options right now and people are nervous with the election and the market.

Muni bonds are no more 'safe' than other investments.

> I agree on doing bond funds and diversification.

Bond funds can also be highly risky and have large durations which can also mean high interest rate risks.

> I put a good chunk in muni bonds and cash. I max out a 401k but that's it for the market because I think it's highly overvalued and I don't like putting most of my money where I have no control. The rest goes into my own companies and real estate.

It sounds like you are highly exposed to interest rate risk in your portfolio and you should work really hard to understand it more clearly.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by exclusiv on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @06:09PM (#11671084)
> If the interest rate the market is willing to pay for a particular muni bond rises, that bond will be worth less and that difference is extremely easy to calculate.

I think you are thinking of individual bonds and I agree, but the fixed income muni bond funds are not as easy to calculate and don't fluctuate as much.

> The fact that rate is rising means that investors are not giving as high of a value. The better way to think about this is that investors decide the Muni bond and other fixed income assets are worth less so they pay less so the yield rises. It is kind of opposite of how you are thinking about it.

Not the opposite at all. If a bond fund is paying 30 cents per share each month and investors value the bond less causing a price drop, the yield goes up as I mentioned and becomes more attractive. The drop isn't as significant as you would think. The funds are diversified across various bonds with different maturities. If investors devalue a fund too much after an interest rate hike, I'll buy more at a higher yield.

> Muni bonds are no more 'safe' than other investments.

I don't agree here. Muni bonds are a debt obligation with a lower level of default compared to other bonds. If they weren't safer than other investments very few people would care about them. The stock market is just legalized gambling. The article is about LC and I've proposed an alternative. Do you not think muni bonds are safer than other bonds or LC?

> It sounds like you are highly exposed to interest rate risk in your portfolio and you should work really hard to understand it more clearly.

I'm not that exposed to interest rate risk. I have more in cash than muni bonds. I buy cash flow positive properties and have a fixed rate mortgage. Most of my money is in my companies and I have two successful ones (one in tech services and one highly profitable subscription model business). They're the only investments I trust.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by KKKKkkkk1 on Monday May 09, 2016 @03:35PM (#11662494)
Bonds are not nearly as liquid as stocks. You can buy and sell, but the spread and fees will be high and not transparent. A good alternative is to buy a bond fund or ETF. Vanguard has a bond fund specific for CA munis. You also get diversification for free (as much as you can diversify within a CA muni bond fund).
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by exclusiv on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:05PM (#11663595)
Good clarification. I noted Nuveen and Blackrock but I should have clearly stated funds. I'd personally never buy muni bonds direct.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by Unklejoe on Monday May 09, 2016 @02:36PM (#11662042)
This is probably a stupid question, but are they tax free only if you buy bonds for the state you live in?

The reason I ask is because I can't seem to find any NJ municipal bonds that are providing a 5% yield. They all seem to be around 3%.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by exclusiv on Monday May 09, 2016 @03:03PM (#11662250)
You can invest in any state but yes tax-free for the state you live in.

Check http://www.cefconnect.com/closed-end-funds-screener and choose tax free.

I see a few in NJ over 5%: MUJ, MYJ, NXJ. NXJ is at a 10% discount. I've been basically doing those Nuveen & Blackrock equivalents in CA.

I usually go for discount to net asset value so I feel like it has room to appreciate so I can lock in a gain outside of the monthly dividends. And if they go down you can always scoop up more which will then have a higher annual dividend yield.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by a_small_island on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:06PM (#11662702)
And what happens if the muni goes bankrupt
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by exclusiv on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:03PM (#11663582)
That would happen if the state or key cities defaulted. I'm betting that they'd get bailed out by the Feds since they like bailing out banks. :)
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by 11thEarlOfMar on Monday May 09, 2016 @02:58PM (#11662210)
They are state tax free if they are issued in the state you live in. If they are federally tax free, they are tax free in any state. Be aware that not all MUNIs are federally tax free.

You would not get the state tax free benefit of a California bond if you live in New Jersey. But you would get the federal tax free portion.

I suggest that you confirm with your brokerage's fixed income team before proceeding.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by charlesdm on Monday May 09, 2016 @12:23PM (#11660988)
Out of curiosity: what was the interest rate on your credit card, and what was the rate after you refinanced your CC debt through Lending Club?
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by pc86 on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:23PM (#11661478)
LC rate was about 14% (average according to their terms) - they've since sent me mailers offering 8% or lower, not including the origination fee which was in the $400-500 range. This was on the 36-month loan that was paid off in 25 months so I'd have to do the math to tell you how much interest I actually paid.

Credit cards were 28.99% and 24.99%, so even with the origination fee quite a bit of savings.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by charlesdm on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:08PM (#11663226)
Yikes - those interest rates are insane.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by Fomite on Monday May 09, 2016 @05:26PM (#11663360)
The interest rates on credit cards can go through the roof if they start regarding you as a default risk.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by charlesdm on Monday May 09, 2016 @06:12PM (#11663644)
Is that a US thing? I have several credit cards, yet the interest rates tend to "only" be around 10-13% on them (not that I use the actual credit part -- I pay them off each month).
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by GFischer on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @11:52AM (#11668097)
You think that's bad? Interest rates on credit cards here in Uruguay are insane if you don't pay them in full, from 42% to 99%. Inflation is about 10%, so they're ridiculously profitable.

Of course, like a good 3rd world country, we have massive defaults about once a decade, so that wipes out most of the profits for the CC companies.

A startup called TuTasa is trying to build a South American LendingClub, but I don't think they're taking off yet:

http://tutasa.com.uy/

One big difference is there's usually only one credit agency (it's Equifax here in Uruguay), and there's a lot more fraud going on than in the USA.

http://www.eltelegrafo.com/index.php?id=102900&seccion=local...

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by Fomite on Thursday May 12, 2016 @03:48PM (#11686200)
Note the "default risk" part of that. I had a credit card that was at a very reasonable interest rate, then due to a series of unfortunate events, I missed a payment.

The interest rate immediately shot up to >25%, and I was told it wouldn't come down for more than a year.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by GBond on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:30PM (#11661531)
I have invested in LC for about a year and the returns have been ~8% using their auto-investing feature using a filter criteria I've selected.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by pmorici on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:03PM (#11662682)
I guess it depends on what your idea of significant capital is but you can get the advertised returns by investing as little as $2,500 just make sure you never put more than $25 into any single loan.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by cm2187 on Monday May 09, 2016 @04:26PM (#11662855)
This is why I have always been skeptical about peer to peer lending. There aren't that many type of investors in the system. I can think fundamentally of four with big volumes.

1. Banks who have lots of depositors, who are retail investors, but who do not wish to take any risk. They see their deposits as quasi-cash. So the bank takes the risk if a loan goes bad, which is why most of the loans are secured on property (mortgages). And why a smaller fraction will be invested in unsecured loans.

2. Pension funds, again investors with very little appetite for risk, who do not make investment decisions themselves, you just let your pension fund invest the money for you, and they are not in the business with taking big risks.

3. Insurance companies, who invest the proceeds from the premium paid on insurance contract until a claim is made. Again not in the business of taking massive risks.

4. Asset managers, which can manage investment from retails clients, but for who the majority of clients do not manage their portfolio actively and rely on asset managers to make the decisions for them.

All 4 are massive and constitute the backbone of the financial system. All 4 have in common that the ultimate investors (depositors, pension contributors, insuree and retail investors) do not make any investment decision themselves.

For p2p lending to make more than a tiny dent in this market, they need these investors to fundamentally change their behavior, to stop relying on someone else to analyse the risk, and to start actively doing their own due diligence, choose a p2p company, trust them with their money, and start reviewing credit profiles and underwrite the loans. Sure, there are some active retail investors who spend their days on online broker websites, who read lots of articles and research. But in term of volumes, not many. I just can't see where the money would come from for p2p lenders to make a difference.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by ChuckMcM on Monday May 09, 2016 @03:04PM (#11662255)

   > I suspect that there was a lot of pressure internally
   > for sales personnel to bring in new capital through 
   > either retail of commercial lenders 
If this is the case it would be another notch in the 'incentivize without adequate controls' poison pill that seems to kill off AdTech companies and executives regularly.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by 11thEarlOfMar on Monday May 09, 2016 @03:51PM (#11662607)
It's a significant problem for companies that grow too fast. Groupon and Yelp come to mind. Both got into trouble for allegedly over-aggressive sales practices.

It has to be difficult to both on-board the personnel at a high rate, and, keep them educated and mindful of the ethical aspects of their activities. Bad practices take a long time to recover, particularly with respect to market perception.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by thaumasiotes on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:25AM (#11660509)
> Borrowers have 14 days to get their loans funded by investors and loans were typically funded by investors within 1 day. So lenders were outnumbering borrowers.

> Starting in January this year, however, loans started taking longer and longer to fund. Recently, I've seen them timing out. This means that in the marketplace, the balance shifted and borrowers outnumbered lenders.

I'd really like to see some different terminology here. Everything you describe is perfectly compatible with there being one lender, or any other number.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by 11thEarlOfMar on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:32AM (#11660561)
Not sure what terms to use. Each loan is funded by multiple lenders, sometimes more than 100. And each lender loans to multiple borrowers. It's not a one-to-one matching.

It would be more precise to make the statement in terms of dollars rather than 'borrowers and lenders'. I don't know whether the average lender has invested more or less in Lending Club than the average borrower has borrowed.

In dollar terms, the total dollars being invested is less than the loans being offered, which is a shift as of January, 2016.

I did edit out 'investors', perhaps that was what you meant. Thanks.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by forgetsusername on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:14AM (#11660415)
>So investors were outnumbering borrowers.

A microcosm of the global economy: we're awash with capital, hence no one is willing to pay much in the way of interest rates.

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by loceng on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:43AM (#11660652)
Interesting idea perhaps of capital that has an accelerating half-life - invest it or lose it. I can imagine technology and society would develop at a much faster pace.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by toomuchtodo on Monday May 09, 2016 @01:38PM (#11661602)
This is exactly how negative interest rate central bank policy is designed to work.

http://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/negative-interest-rate-p...

"A negative interest rate means the central bank and perhaps private banks will charge negative interest: instead of receiving money on deposits, depositors must pay regularly to keep their money with the bank. This is intended to incentivize banks to lend money more freely and businesses and individuals to invest, lend, and spend money rather than pay a fee to keep it safe."

Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by msandford on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:48AM (#11660699)
Too bad the capital stock isn't determined by individuals but rather the Fed; who knows what the interest rate would be in real life if there wasn't massive money printing. Sorry, "quantitative easing"
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by Phlarp on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:49AM (#11660713)
So, something like inflation along with centrally directed GDP growth targeting?
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by fulldecent on Monday May 09, 2016 @02:06PM (#11661835)
Just look at the price of gold since 1970. And turn the chart upside down. That is the halflife of dollars.
Re:LendingClub CEO Resigns Following Loan Sales Review by maaku on Monday May 09, 2016 @11:54AM (#11660753)
Demurrage money.