News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by danielvf on Sunday May 08, 2016 @08:55AM (#11653849)
I'm learning the game of Go at near fourty. But I'm not having any of the problems he describes.

A great thing about learning and playing online is that you can find an opponent at your same skill level within minutes. Unlike learning in a local club, where every person you will ever play beats you every time, I win slightly more than half my games. I also get this nice increasing graph of my skill level. This is a lot more fun.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by lordnacho on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:39AM (#11654008)
I wish physical sports were like this. Anything online is blessed with this mechanic where you can keep it challenging for everyone other than the people at the top or bottom (based on my experience in CoD where I'm pretty sure I'm bottom).

With sports like soccer it's quite noticeable that some people are way better than everyone else, or way worse. And there's no way to improve since you can't just rearrange thousands of teams.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by IkmoIkmo on Sunday May 08, 2016 @01:11PM (#11654749)
I'm not familiar with your experience to be honest.

For example in the Netherlands we have Football right. There's 9 divisions. You get promoted or demoted at the end of the season, such that on average you're roughly in the middle of a spectrum of 5% worse and 5% better teams.

Of course there's lots of individual differences and some teams get much better suddenly in one season, and ought to play a division higher right away. But that's an issue for online mechanics as well. Online mechanics make that 5% range more granular, sure, but the notion that thousands of teams aren't rearranged isn't true, that's exactly what happens in most sports!

Of course going to the court and playing a quick match with strangers doesn't have this effect, but the vast majority of football players play in some formal sense in a team which plays in some organisation's league system with divisions. At least that's how it is here, although football is an extraordinarily deep sport in most countries and so the difficulty of opposition will be less granular in other sports.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by bgilroy26 on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:12PM (#11657179)
Coming from of the United States and hearing about how federated soccer is all across Europe is really saddening.

In the US we have baseball where we have a sane semi-pro system. In football and basketball which are the real money, growth sports, there's the best-in-the-world professionals, the unpaid 20 year old college players and not a lot in-between.

In college, a buddy of mine became close friends do with a semi-pro soccer player out of Austria. He wasn't the best in the world and he was an au pair in the off-season, but he was in tip top shape in his late 20s playing soccer for a living.

It really isn't like that here. On the top end of the average case scenario, you have 3 years to make a living doing what you've been trained practically 20 years to do and then you're out in most cases. The whole employment market for these athletes would be a lot more sane if it were like baseball where you have families coming out to see minor league football and basketball players at reasonable prices.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by Scarblac on Monday May 09, 2016 @08:24AM (#11659215)
The guy you're replying to is talking about amateur sports, and you reply by talking about semi-pros and making a living out of something. The divide runs deep.

The people in those 9 divisions have a game every weekend, and training once or twice per week on weekday evenings, as a hobby. Pro sport is something different entirely.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by dfc on Sunday May 08, 2016 @04:02PM (#11655487)
Ages ago I was in the top five for Domination in CoD:WaW. It was still remarkably challenging and exciting. Its not about which team wins (as long as I had one or two of my "good friends" any lobby was going to be a team win), as you get better the number of "micro contests" on each map grows: can I get dogs before we get the B-flag, can I satchel charge the enemy tank as I hop in the weakened tank my loser teammate bailed from, etc. Not to mention there is always the increased expectation to never have a bad game if you are on the top of the leaderboards and a bad game is not just a dent in your W/L, it also produces the inevitable deluge of moronic messages from people accusing you of boosting and being a try hard.

I think competitive video gaming is like anything else, in order to excel and stay at the top you have to constantly compete against yourself.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by kansface on Sunday May 08, 2016 @02:40PM (#11655159)
If your up for it, try climbing. Competition is almost entirely with yourself and its typically quite easy to climb with a friend across multiple grades of difficulty. It also heavily involves problem solving, strategic thinking, and risk management that is not found in most other sports.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by kd5bjo on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:45AM (#11654233)
It takes a bit more effort to figure out, but it is possible. I started playing tennis regularly about 2 years ago; I eventually found an academy attached to a resort, so there's a steady stream of players coming through of all skill levels.

About 2 months ago, I left my job at Facebook to move out here and it's been great -- I can always find someone that wants to play, and they're all in a good mood because they're on vacation.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by crispyambulance on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:42AM (#11654213)
Many physical sports are actually just great for 40+ folks, that's why there are "masters" categories in competitions.

As long as individuals recognize the limitations of their age groups they'll be just fine.

Actually, even if individuals _don't_ recognize their age limitations and play against 20-somethings that's also OK (if they're willing to have their ass handed to them on every competition).

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by spdegabrielle on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:44AM (#11654225)
I started playing soccer at 40 - the best way to learn is to play with and against people who are much better than you.

BUT is is a dangerous game - you can get hurt playing against 20year olds!

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by braythwayt on Sunday May 08, 2016 @11:44AM (#11654475)
For a modest value of “much.”

My experience is that you need to play against people who will challenge you, but within an appropriate level of attainment. I am a keeper, so I will speak of keeper skills.

One important skill to learn early is to get off the line and cut off the angles. If you stay on the line when you are just learning, the net is too big and you have no chance to make saves.

Thus, you never learn to make saves because you have no real feedback on what you do. You always lose.

Now if you come out a bit, you start making some saves, and you get better at it. This would lead you to a place where you make nearly all the saves, and you would stop learning, unless your opponents are good enough to use passing and make you keep track of multiple strikers at once.

But if they are so good (or your defenders are so bad) that they are always swarming the net in threes and fours, you would get stick on the line and never learn anything.

So, the best way to learn is for your opponents to be better than you, but not so much better that they discourage good play on your part. And as you get better, they must get better as well, so that you must continue to get better.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by JamesBarney on Sunday May 08, 2016 @03:17PM (#11655327)
This is very common with foos ball. There are local maximums where a player can get stuck. If you're playing opponents as good or a little better it pays to practice your foosball skills like passing and high accuracy shots. However if you're playing opponents far stronger then the best strategy is lower percentage Hail Mary's so it trains less important skills.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by OpenDrapery on Monday May 09, 2016 @10:08AM (#11659935)
I've seen the opposite effect. Parents with too much money placing their mediocre kids on mediocre traveling teams, to drive 800 miles to play other teams, when you know there is local talent that would give them all they could handle.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by wslh on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:50AM (#11654253)
I tried to learn Go, obviously beyond understanding the rules, and found it very difficult comparing to Chess. I wonder how you dealt with the huge exploration space of just putting one stone in the beginning of the game. In Chess, every movement is very constrained.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by tel on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:05PM (#11656915)
I often feel like "learning Go" is deceptively a few steps deep. When one learns Chess you effectively can get to the tactical aspect as soon as you know how the pieces move. When you "learn Go" at the first level you understand the rules and their basic consequences, but you still don't quite know "how the pieces move". This is natural since no rule dictates these things in Go—they're something you learn as handed down from thousands of years of people playing it.

But once you get the "how the pieces move" of Go—essentially, the Haeng-ma and maybe the basic opening algorithm, you can quickly dig in to the really rich tactical and strategic levels just as you can with Chess.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by danielvf on Sunday May 08, 2016 @11:20AM (#11654369)
The first move is actually pretty constrained - there's only four normal choices, of which only two are usual. You are trying to grab a corner, and trading off between a certainty of controlling a corner (4-3), or more influence on the rest of the board (4-4 on the corner dot).
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by dvanduzer on Sunday May 08, 2016 @12:42PM (#11654653)
Crowdsourcing your opponents online is a perfect way to train a skill. (Assuming you've identified a clear skill you wish to train, and that you're willing to make that time commitment to train it.) Anonymous opponents can take the sting out of the learning curve.

A lot of local special interest clubs fail because they don't deal well with newcomers and beginners. This essay was perfect down to the last line, written through the lens of that special bond of parenthood.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by reefoctopus on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:20AM (#11653921)
Where do you play?
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by danielvf on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:24AM (#11653934)
https://online-go.com/

I highly recommend it.

Re:Learning Chess at 40 by karlkeefer on Sunday May 08, 2016 @12:42PM (#11654652)
5 kyu checking in. The client is terrible and old, but the community on KGS go server is unparalleled. Highly recommend giving it a shot - very high level players will often provide commentary to help you improve.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by artursapek on Sunday May 08, 2016 @09:40AM (#11654014)
I just started on there as well, great website.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by aurelianito on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:19AM (#11654141)
11k there. What are your strengths?
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by danielvf on Sunday May 08, 2016 @10:57AM (#11654286)
19k. I started a few weeks after AlphaGo's big games.
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by artursapek on Tuesday May 10, 2016 @11:37AM (#11667983)
I'm hovering around 18k, still a noob
Re:Learning Chess at 40 by fonosip on Sunday May 08, 2016 @04:21PM (#11655583)
Try http://go.ba.net Play Go with Friends or Bots no registration, no download needed