News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by nearestneighbor on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:13PM (#1165358)
Am I the only one who thinks that at the GUI level Ubuntu is better than OS X? (I use Snow Leopard and Ubuntu 8.04 extensively)
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by barrkel on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:48PM (#1165456)
Ubuntu's default control layout looks ridiculous to me - everything is too far apart, the margins are too big, the buttons are too big, the fonts are too big, acres of space are wasted by toolbars in the File Browser in the screenshot, etc.

It looks like a toy for people with poor eyesight.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by rbanffy on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:17PM (#1165539)
Or big screens.

Unix machines have traditionally been used with big monitors. It's not surprising at all Gnome uses lots of pixels.

And there is nothing forcing you to use Ubuntu's default layout. You have literally hundreds of options to choose from. I tend to change look and feel more or less on a monthly basis.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by barrkel on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @08:27PM (#1165805)
I live with Windows 7 on two monitors, combined pixel area approximately 3600x1200, and it's still not enough even with Windows's more condensed by default tree views, list views, menu bars, toolbars etc. I have e.g. my desktop icons dialed down to 32x32px. I like my toolbar buttons 16x16px. I like my buttons approximately 75x25px. Information density.

When running XP, as I still do on my non-Linux laptops, the total vertical space wastage at the top of Windows Explorer is 65 pixels, including title bar, toolbar, menu bar and location textbox. This is possible because on XP the toolbars and menu bars have customizable locations, unlike Vista and above - I have screenshots in my blog here:

http://blog.barrkel.com/2008/08/venting-on-vista.html

Unless you are talking about a pixel area somewhere in the region of 8000x3000 on high dpi screens, the Ubuntu proportions are nowhere near acceptable.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by rbanffy on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @09:50PM (#1165971)
You have very unique needs. I am always with a lot of open windows, using small fonts and icons and usually have more than one screen at hand, but I am sure I would feel lost on a 3200x1200, at least for a while. A couple weeks ago, I discovered the big Integraph (I restore and collect interesting computers and this one was just gathering dust) screen my mother uses was capable of going up to 2048 by about 1500, I felt oddly agoraphobic.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by barrkel on Thursday March 04, 2010 @03:30AM (#1166447)
It's 3600. 1920x1200 on one screen, 1680x1050 on the other.

There's a trick to window management - I use cascading windows on the second monitor, as I detail here:

http://blog.barrkel.com/2009/11/on-difficulty-of-setting-win...

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by mquander on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @11:48PM (#1166179)
Unlike Windows 7, Linux has proper virtual desktop support, so you can get a big working area without actually having that huge resolution.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by barrkel on Thursday March 04, 2010 @03:27AM (#1166445)
I think you're missing the point. You can have as many virtual desktops as you like - and Windows does support multiple desktops, moreover there are utilities that emulate virtual desktops - but that doesn't let you display lots of information all at once.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by randallsquared on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @07:36PM (#1165697)
The more you change it, though, the less likely you are ever to get it back to a previous set of settings. :( Switch to KDE and back to Gnome in Ubuntu 9.10, and you'll find yourself, bizarrely, with a KDEesque mouse theme, even after you uninstall all the kubuntu-desktop stuff (which should not be necessary, I would expect).

I use Ubuntu because I have the free time to screw around with my home computer, but I wouldn't recommend it for people who don't have the time and knowledge to do that, unless all they ever want to do is use what it comes with out of the box.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by pyre on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @07:39PM (#1165700)
> unless all they ever want to do is use what it comes with out of the box.

Most people don't. At the very least, most (non-geek) people don't switch desktop environments often. The people that are 'too busy' will just settle on a desktop environment and stick with it.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by ANH on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @08:41PM (#1165828)
Why is it a good thing to have hundreds of layouts to choose from? The paradox of choice is real: http://www.ted.com/talks/barry_schwartz_on_the_paradox_of_ch...
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by Daishiman on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:34PM (#1166075)
Because it's a dumb comparison. Ubuntu provides at most 3 or 4 different default themes to choose from. If you want more, you can go explicitly looking for them on the web, but otherwise there's not choice overload.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by abhiomkar on Thursday March 04, 2010 @03:14AM (#1166434)
I agree. The GTK font looks big. The button color and the GTK app color is not matching well. Giving same color to Title bar and menu bar is not a good Idea IMO. But I feel, the new look is better than the previous default brownish theme. Like the new logo of ubuntu. The font is minimal & elegant.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by nailer on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:27PM (#1165407)
In some respects - I switched from GNOME to OS X and I found that Nautilus respected the tree a lot more than OS X did, NetworkManager also showed signal strength before OS X's top bar network thingy did.

Only reason I quit is that after speccing hardware that had OSS drivers (and was fairly underpowered to boot), drivers in Ubuntu still didn't work 100% (eg, connecting to external displays broke X render support) and this got worse over time (Intel drivers being replaced with much more unstable replacements).

I still develop for Ubuntu, but inside a VM.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by AngryParsley on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:54PM (#1166108)
(Intel drivers being replaced with much more unstable replacements).

Ugh, I had this same problem. Every time I upgraded Ubuntu, hardware rendering got another 10x performance decrease and more bugs. Eventually I couldn't even enable vsync, so I got horrible tearing while watching videos. I partially blame Ubuntu for this, since they could have held back Intel's driver updates. Ultimately though, it was Intel's fault for releasing ever-buggier drivers.

A lot of the bugs you're talking about were fixed in updates to 9.10, but I gave up and got a Mac way before that.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by ori_b on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @11:47PM (#1166178)
The problem is that X had a massive amount of crap in it. Getting rid of the crap is hard, and things really had to get worse before they got better.

Switching acceleration architectures to something that's not from the '80s, allowing modern hardware to effectively accelerate the UI, allowing video to interact with OpenGL and so on needed to be done, and there was really no good way to do it painlessly.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by AngryParsley on Thursday March 04, 2010 @03:34AM (#1166454)
I can think of one way: don't put new drivers in your distro until they're at least as good as old drivers.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by nailer on Thursday March 04, 2010 @04:32AM (#1166523)
Exactly. Have a variety of text hardware and a video test suite. Don't release the new drivers until they pass.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by jsz0 on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @07:32PM (#1165694)
GNOME itself has evolved nicely but the wheels fall off the Ubuntu UI when you start installing applications. If you're careful and only install GTK apps it's bearable but once you mix in QT apps and other non-GTK stuff you have a horrible mix of UIs that lack consistency.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by cma on Thursday March 04, 2010 @05:51AM (#1166607)
You can just as easily substitute "Ubuntu" with "OS X" above since QT runs on OS X.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by grandalf on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:25PM (#1165397)
It is for usability. Ubuntu's only weakness is that at the pixel level it's a bit uglier than OSX in some areas... and that by default it doesn't come with quite the same level of fonts...
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by nearestneighbor on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:45PM (#1165439)
Fonts are in the eye (or rather, visual cortex) of the beholder. I got used to the Mac fonts, but at first I thought it was some kind of bad joke or misconfiguration. They seemed annoyingly blurry.

My theory is that one's brain gets used to the particular fonts and may not like change very much.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by grandalf on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @05:59PM (#1165486)
You are right that OSX uses different subpixel rendering than Windows, but I think that at present the free fonts on Ubuntu are not quite at the level of OSX's fonts and some of Adobe's.

This could just be my own aesthetic taste, but I think it could also be due to those companies having highly paid font designers working on those details.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by nailer on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:31PM (#1165578)
Agfa (who do the Ubuntu / Fedora fonts) developers are paid just like anyone else.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by grandalf on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:45PM (#1165608)
Hmm... Well I admit some of the free fonts are awesome... but I have not found them to be quite as pleasing... Maybe it's just my own taste... not worth arguing about since Ubuntu is awesome and the free fonts are certainly good enough for most purposes...
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by carbon8 on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:35PM (#1165587)
Gnome's biggest downside is the same core problem of the Windows interface: having a menu bolted on to each window is incredibly inelegant, redundant and wasteful of screen space.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by rbanffy on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:15PM (#1166028)
OSX's biggest downside is having a fixed region of the screen that changes according to the context of the selected window on the desktop. That makes it impossible to check what two windows can do or even what program is responsible for them until they are selected. That's terribly inelegant solution that separates the data (what's inside the window) from the menus that act on that data (the menu).

Admit it. That's a draw.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by carbon8 on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:46PM (#1166098)
"what program is responsible for them"

This is handled by title bars in Gnome, OS X and Windows, not window menu bars.

"separates the data (what's inside the window) from the menus that act on that data"

The menus don't just act on what's in the window. At least some menu items act on the application itself.

In a multiple document interface with a system that ties menus to windows, the menu of one window acts on multiple other windows. The other windows are either sub windows shoved inside the main window or they are windows floating independently from the window with the menu, which means you need to return focus to the main window to use the menu.

In a single document interfaces, the same menu, application controls and all, is repeated on each individual window.

Furthermore, in both of those cases, once you close the window with the menu bar, you no longer have access to any controls for the application, which is why most applications in these windowing systems can't run without at least one window open.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by rbanffy on Thursday March 04, 2010 @12:33PM (#1167452)
> which is why most applications in these windowing systems can't run without at least one window open.

As opposed to "application buildup" MacOS users experience since the OS7 days, when they are on a clean desktop and five applications running for no particular reason.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by Daishiman on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:37PM (#1166081)
What are you talking about? OSX's menu bar is useless when you have huge monitors or multiple screens, and the menu bar and other behaviors makes focus-follow-mouse impossible.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by yoden on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @11:28PM (#1166155)
Moving my mouse 2000 pixels to get to the menu bar on my other monitor... shudders
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by antigua on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @08:54PM (#1165860)
OS X's biggest downside is the same core problem of the Windows interface: having icons, menus and windows bolted on to a desktop is incredibly inelegant, redundant and wasteful of screen space.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by danieldon on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:30PM (#1166069)
How does that make any sense whatsoever as a response to the OP?
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by antigua on Thursday March 04, 2010 @12:02AM (#1166205)
Linux distributions can get all the face lifts in the world, but at the end of the day they were not designed to be cute and accessible.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by s3graham on Thursday March 04, 2010 @12:38AM (#1166256)
I find the menus ridiculous on OSX.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by sid0 on Thursday March 04, 2010 @05:53AM (#1166611)
OS X's biggest downside is that it doesn't allow an interface without menus. :)