News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by carbon8 on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @06:35PM (#1165587)
Gnome's biggest downside is the same core problem of the Windows interface: having a menu bolted on to each window is incredibly inelegant, redundant and wasteful of screen space.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by rbanffy on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:15PM (#1166028)
OSX's biggest downside is having a fixed region of the screen that changes according to the context of the selected window on the desktop. That makes it impossible to check what two windows can do or even what program is responsible for them until they are selected. That's terribly inelegant solution that separates the data (what's inside the window) from the menus that act on that data (the menu).

Admit it. That's a draw.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by carbon8 on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:46PM (#1166098)
"what program is responsible for them"

This is handled by title bars in Gnome, OS X and Windows, not window menu bars.

"separates the data (what's inside the window) from the menus that act on that data"

The menus don't just act on what's in the window. At least some menu items act on the application itself.

In a multiple document interface with a system that ties menus to windows, the menu of one window acts on multiple other windows. The other windows are either sub windows shoved inside the main window or they are windows floating independently from the window with the menu, which means you need to return focus to the main window to use the menu.

In a single document interfaces, the same menu, application controls and all, is repeated on each individual window.

Furthermore, in both of those cases, once you close the window with the menu bar, you no longer have access to any controls for the application, which is why most applications in these windowing systems can't run without at least one window open.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by rbanffy on Thursday March 04, 2010 @12:33PM (#1167452)
> which is why most applications in these windowing systems can't run without at least one window open.

As opposed to "application buildup" MacOS users experience since the OS7 days, when they are on a clean desktop and five applications running for no particular reason.

Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by Daishiman on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:37PM (#1166081)
What are you talking about? OSX's menu bar is useless when you have huge monitors or multiple screens, and the menu bar and other behaviors makes focus-follow-mouse impossible.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by yoden on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @11:28PM (#1166155)
Moving my mouse 2000 pixels to get to the menu bar on my other monitor... shudders
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by antigua on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @08:54PM (#1165860)
OS X's biggest downside is the same core problem of the Windows interface: having icons, menus and windows bolted on to a desktop is incredibly inelegant, redundant and wasteful of screen space.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by danieldon on Wednesday March 03, 2010 @10:30PM (#1166069)
How does that make any sense whatsoever as a response to the OP?
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by antigua on Thursday March 04, 2010 @12:02AM (#1166205)
Linux distributions can get all the face lifts in the world, but at the end of the day they were not designed to be cute and accessible.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by s3graham on Thursday March 04, 2010 @12:38AM (#1166256)
I find the menus ridiculous on OSX.
Re:Ubuntu introduces new theme and branding by sid0 on Thursday March 04, 2010 @05:53AM (#1166611)
OS X's biggest downside is that it doesn't allow an interface without menus. :)